What’s the news?

• In Kerala, a case of medical negligence involving a forgotten surgical instrument inside a patient and increasing vacancies in dental courses across the nation’s colleges spotlight the efficacy and responsibilities of medical institutions in India’s healthcare system.

Central idea

• The rising incidents of medical negligence in leading Indian medical colleges and the Union Government’s 2019 Policy Proposal, which aims to convert district hospitals into medical colleges and establish AIIMS-like institutions in every state, prompt a revaluation of medical colleges’ contribution to patient care from a public health perspective.

The government’s proposal

• Conversion of District Hospitals: The government aims to convert district hospitals across the country into medical colleges. District hospitals are typically considered to be at a secondary level of healthcare, and this policy suggests upgrading them to medical colleges, which are institutions for medical education and training.
• Establishment of AIIMS-like Institutions: The government also intends to establish institutions similar to the AIIMS in every state. AIIMS is renowned for providing advanced healthcare services, medical education, and research. The objective is to replicate AIIMS-like facilities in each state to enhance medical infrastructure and education.

Purpose of a medical college

• Educational Role:

• The foremost purpose of a medical college is to provide education and training to students aspiring to become medical professionals.
• This involves imparting the theoretical knowledge, practical skills, and clinical experiences necessary for students to become competent healthcare practitioners.

• Medical Care:

• A secondary purpose of a medical college is to offer medical care. This is facilitated through the associated medical college hospital, which is equipped with state-of-the-art facilities.
• The hospital serves as a platform for the practical training and apprenticeship (internship) of medical students.
• It provides bedside care, an essential requirement for medical training, and contributes to the development of clinical skills.

Myths related to medical colleges

• Myth of Comprehensive Healthcare: There’s a misconception that having a medical college in a district can address all healthcare needs, which can lead to an overestimation of the capabilities of medical colleges.
• Myth of Increased Medical Seats: Establishing a medical college is often associated with the belief that it will increase the availability of medical seats for local students, creating a false hope for aspiring medical professionals.
• Myth of Quantity Over Quality: There’s a misconception that producing more medical professionals will automatically resolve issues related to inadequate healthcare access, overlooking the importance of quality healthcare provision.
• The Myth of Tertiary Care Solving All Issues: The belief that tertiary care services offered by medical colleges can cater to all healthcare needs may undermine the significance of strengthening primary and secondary care services.
• The Myth of Medical Colleges as Ideal Solutions: The notion that medical colleges are the ultimate solution to healthcare challenges might oversimplify the complexities of healthcare delivery, particularly in areas where secondary-level care can have a significant impact.

Challenges faced by medical colleges in healthcare delivery

• Patient Overload: Higher-level medical facilities, including medical colleges, experience a heavy influx of patients seeking primary and secondary care, leading to patient overcrowding.
• Mismanagement of Cases: A significant majority (over 80%) of cases treated in medical colleges are inappropriate for specialized tertiary care, suggesting a mismatch between patient needs and provided services.
• Deficient Referral System: The absence of an effective referral system in India’s healthcare setup results in patients needing primary and secondary care seeking treatment at medical colleges, causing strain.
• Resource Constraints: The varied patient influx, spanning primary to advanced cases, overburdens the resources and infrastructure of medical colleges, potentially affecting care quality.

Examining tertiary care needs and challenges in district healthcare

• It’s a well-established fact that approximately 1% of the total population annually requires advanced tertiary care.
• For instance, in a district with a population of three million, this translates to a demand for 575-700 specialized beds (considering 100%-85% bed occupancy).Most district hospitals are intended to address this specialized tertiary care need.
• However, the challenge arises as district hospitals, expected to operate and follow referral systems from lower-level facilities, face obstacles due to deficient infrastructure, a shortage of specialists, and a lack of referral systems. These issues are exacerbated by the non-functionality of secondary-level care facilities.

Way forward

• Redefine Priorities: Rather than assuming that medical colleges alone can address the diverse healthcare needs of a population, a shift in perspective is required. The primary focus should be on strengthening secondary-care facilities, particularly district hospitals, which can cater to a wider spectrum of curative care requirements.
• Enhance Referral Systems: Implementing and reinforcing efficient referral systems from primary healthcare centers to well-equipped district hospitals can help streamline patient care.
• Balance Educational and Practical Needs: While medical education remains crucial, a stronger emphasis on hands-on training within well-functioning hospitals is essential.
• Strategic Resource Allocation: When contemplating new medical college establishments, a strategic approach is vital. Focus resources on areas with existing infrastructure, connectivity, and clinical facilities to ensure the institution’s viability and effectiveness.
• Community Education and Awareness: To manage expectations and dispel myths, community engagement is paramount. Educate the public about the specific roles and capabilities of medical colleges, preventing false perceptions of comprehensive healthcare solutions.
• Tailored Regional Approaches: Recognize that diverse regions have distinct challenges. Tailor the establishment and operation of medical colleges to local needs, acknowledging that a standardized approach may not effectively address unique community requirements.
• Elevate District Hospitals: District hospitals should receive substantial support, including infrastructure upgrades, specialist staffing, advanced equipment, and improved connectivity. These efforts will bolster secondary-care facilities, reducing the load on higher-level medical institutions.

Conclusion

• The solution lies in dismantling myths and embracing pragmatic strategies. A reimagined healthcare system built upon patient-focused principles will not only fulfill the curative care needs of the populace but also redefine the role of medical colleges as beacons of comprehensive healthcare.

Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024

Attend Now