A judge of the Supreme Court has been part of a judgment. Now the matter has been referred to a five judge bench in which she is also a member. The judge is known for her honesty and integrity. But there is immense pressure on her to recuse herself as her presence brings potential conflict of interest. But she refuses to do so. In your view, what should be the most appropriate conduct in this situation? Give adequate reasons for the justification of your view. 10 marks

Mentor’s comment-

In the introduction briefly present the scenario before the Judge, explain the ethical conflicts involved.
In the body discuss the various aspects involved such as – principle of natural justice, Institutional integrity vs. personal integrity etc.
Explain and present whether the Judge should recuse from the bench, if so what should be her stand. Present your views with suitable backing.
Conclude with a fair and balanced approach.