Mentors Comment:
Understanding this question is quite important. It’s not a general question therefore you might find it little tricky. Its not asking you to answer what is caste, why is it good or why is it bad. Instead, the question requires discussion on the Changing Nature of Caste in Modern India.
Basic premise of the answer will include that with modern education, mass urbanisation and social interactions, the rigidity of caste is decreasing in various important fields of our society. Now you can talk, dine, work and commute with & marry anyone, irrespective of his/her caste. Therefore, base your first half of the answer on this discussion.
But while caste in these walks of life have become flexible in modern Indian society, it has taken refuge and entered in other parts of our society, specially politics and education (due to reservation). It has provided life to caste system with new found caste consciousness among Indians. So while in its old forms, it may not exist or survive in modern India, caste has entered into other more flexible realms of our life and it’s still a long way to go before being eradicated. This will be the base of your second half of the answer. And IT’S QUITE IMPORTANT PART.
Towards the end of the answer, briefly, give some steps to eradicate this evil from our society. You can combine it with the conclusion if space is less.
Answer:
Caste is that extreme form of social class organization in which the position of individuals in the status hierarchy is determined by descent and birth. While caste might not necessarily play the same role it did in the olden days, its fluid character ensures it has adapted to play a role in contemporary society as well.
How it is becoming irrelevant in some areas of our life:
Purity and Commensality:
The most conspicuous rule among the caste rules regarding purity was that of commensality or rules regarding eating and drinking with or accepting food and water from other castes.
Post-independence, industrialization, education, and urbanization, amongst other factors, made the applicability of some of these rules unfeasible.
Different castes worked alongside in large factories and shared food and water.
Students of different castes, unaware of commensality rules freely ate with each other in school and at large public gatherings such as marriages, inter-caste mingling happened without commensality rules being adhered to.
While old rules of commensality still remained, their observance by men as well as women had become more relaxed.
Marriage:
Now that marriage is also a result of the free choice of two partners, the caste’s role in determining the match is declining.
Increased education has resulted in the weakening of certain marriage rules.
Inter-caste marriages have become fairly common in urban areas and towns.
However, caste endogamy still persists as is evident by a large number of caste matrimony associations and websites.
Caste Based Occupation:
The very base for caste’s existence- occupations based on caste, have started to weaken.
Industrialization has changed that, for it has brought with it a variety of new, caste-free professions.
More and more youngsters in the current generation have opted out of their family and caste occupation for better opportunities.
But new forms of influence of castes are opening up:
Sanskritization:
If caste is weakening in contemporary India, why is Sanskritization strengthening?
Sanskritisation is where the lower castes seek upward mobility by emulating the rituals and practices of the upper or dominant castes.
This aspiration shows that caste awareness, an implicit awareness about apparent Brahmin supremacy and as a corollary, of the lower-standing of other castes, exists.
This awareness only increased caste identity and consciousness, especially in modern and contemporary Indian society.
Indeed, Sanskritisation is sustaining the continuance of the caste system in contemporary India.
Politics:
Caste has permeated into the political arena with castes representing easily identifiable vote banks.
Caste was chosen over the class as the identities of caste are much clearer than class and almost everyone can say which caste they belong to.
Class is a lot more ambiguous and harder for people to identify with.
As a result, political parties started using caste garner votes and this led to the concept of a vote bank.
When political parties emphasize the caste of their candidates and propose reforms benefiting those belonging to the same caste as their candidate, it increases caste consciousness.
This has made castes think collectively and this self-identity has kept caste alive in modern Indian society.
Education:
Through politics, it has seeped into education as well, in the form of reservation for the lower castes.
This web of caste influence finishes a complete circle with reservations in jobs as well for the scheduled castes.
How casteism can be removed?
Emotional and intellectual appeal to economic determinism, as was advocated by Karl Marx.
Awareness about Constitutional values, ethics, ill effects of casteism, etc.
Promote and incentivize inter-caste marriages as is already done for marrying a SC ST woman in some parts of India.
Evaluate the existing customs, rituals, etc. on the touchstone of Human Rights. Here judiciary can play a positive role but with due respect to religious feelings.
Implement laws and agreements like ICCPR, Protection of human rights, Prevention of atrocities against SC-ST, etc. with full letter and spirit.
Economic empowerment of Dalit through education and ownership of land and capital
Caste, in its older forms, has become irrelevant. But rather than getting replaced with class-based society, the caste system has taken shelter in other walks of our social life. The caste hierarchy might not play a role in these walks, but caste consciousness does. The caste system in India is undergoing changes due to progress in education, technology, modernization and changes in general social outlook. In spite of the general improvement in conditions of the lower castes, India has still a long way to go, to root out the evils of the caste system from the society.
Please review and revert.
Thank you.
Hi Anmol, if you are a paid member of the AWE program then please mention your payment ID while submitting answers.
This structure and presentation style is more suited for essay answers. GS answers need bullet points along with proper subheadings and paragraph is better suited for intro and conclusion.
Underline important points in your answers.
The overall answer missed the demand of the question.
the question requires discussion on the Changing Nature of Caste in Modern India.
The basic premise of the answer will include that with modern education, mass urbanization, and social interactions, the rigidity of caste is decreasing in various important fields of our society. Now you can talk, dine, work and commute with & marry anyone, irrespective of his/her caste. Therefore, base your first half of the answer to this discussion.
But while caste in these walks of life have become flexible in modern Indian society, it has taken refuge and entered in other parts of our society, especially politics and education (due to reservation). It has provided life to the caste system with newfound caste consciousness among Indians.
Always read the mentor’s comments before attempting the questions.
That way you will know the required direction of the answer.
In terms of content and language, the answer suffers from over-explanation. Keep your discussion short and crisp. That is why bullet points are the best bet in UPSC mains.
Read the model answer for the understanding of presentation and content.
Very good handwriting.
Payment ID: MOJO9802W00A98715356
Please review
Hi Sahithya
Very good answer.
The structure of the answer is fluid and well crafted.
the answer has all the necessary points.
The explanation is short and crisp.
Some of the dimensions explained are really very good.
Decent attempt.
IDMOJO9728J00A50299555
Hi Amandeep
No need to discuss the old form or the background of the caste and varna system.
Briefly mention the changing nature of the caste system in your intro. Then jump to the discussion on the modern scenario of the caste system.
Like you boxed your subheadings in the first part, similarly, you should underline or highlight all your subheadings to make them distinct. For example, in the second part where you discussed that casteism is still present, it should be highlighted. these little things go a long way in improving your overall marks.
The 2nd part needs more and better details like the issue of caste in education and job due to reservation, the backlash from upper castes and non reserved castes, politics, caste alliances and groupings, caste assertion, etc.
Read the model answer for the 2nd part.
Decent conclusion but do mention what more needs to be done to remove casteism.
MOJO9813J00N70217069
Hi Pranab
Underline important points.
Use subheadings for bullet points as well as paragraphs.
Highlight your subheadings.
You need to start giving more dimensions to your answers.
Points are good but there are more elements to the discussion that can be explored.
More or less, directions of all the answers are good but they need more content.
Good structure.
Always write a conclusion.
MOJO9803C00N96073071
Hi Ashraf
Its very good that you discussed the 1st part under various dimensions.
Points can be bettered there but the structure in the 1st part is very good.
Similarly, the second part is dealt with nicely.
Good conclusion.
All in all, a very good attempt.
Presentation and structure are good. Try to write like this.
Payment ID: MOJO9731Y00N34245077
Hi Kanchan
Try not to use a paragraph format as you did in the second part of the answer.
Stick to the bullet format in the whole main body.
The direction of the answer is quite decent.
The 1st half is very good and points explored there are decent.
Mojo id-MOJO9908R00A36163556