Mentors Comments:
- 1. Briefly introduce with the significance of the telecom sector in India
- 2. Mention the specific challenges facing the sector
- 3. Also, highlight the ways in which these can be addressed
- https://www.google.com/amp/s/
www.livemint.com/industry/ telecom/multiple-policy-flip- flops-push-telecom-industry- to-a-corner/amp- 11573580873505.html
Answer:
India is the world’s second-largest telecommunications market, with around 1.2 billion subscribers as of September 2018. It has contributed around 6% to the GDP of India and it is expected to increase to an even more significant level.
Challenges in Telecom Sector
- Lack of fixed-line penetration:
- India has very little penetration of fixed-line in its network whereas, most of the developed countries have a very high penetration of fixed lines(telephone line that traveled through a metal wire or optical fiber as part of a nationwide telephone network).
- The countries having high fixed-line penetration are able to operate broadband over the fixed-line and thus are much ahead of India in terms of download speeds. Downloading speed in India is 512 kbps compared to other nations that have touched the speed of 100 Mbps.
- Private Service Providers when entered the sector, started deploying a network using cellular technology that has a limitation in terms of download speeds.
- Though India has almost 1.2 billion connections the fixed line is around 18 million. Broadband Connectivity on fixed-line is also poor.
- Only around 25% of Towers in India are connected with fiber networks, whereas in developed nations, it is in excess of 70%.
- 5G Network requires towers to be connected to very high-speed systems. Those high speeds are not possible on the present radio systems. But are possible on the fibre system.
- High Right-of-Way (ROW) cost: Sometimes, states governments charge a huge amount for permitting the laying of fiber etc. (A right of way is a type of easement that allows a person to pass through another’s land)
- It takes a long time to get right-of-way permissions and thus India is yet not able to exploit the full potential of 4G networks.
- Huge fluctuations in the duties on Telecom Equipment which contribute to connecting the whole system from the central server to the consumer.
- Current System of Tariffs: Major telecom Operators are reporting losses and financial stress. One operator, even, has recently announced bankruptcy. This shows that the current tariff system is not financially viable for telecoms.
Initiatives by Government
- In 2017, the Department of Telecom (DoT) came up with a gazette notification, advising the state governments to give quicker ROW permission and charge very little amount to service providers. Though, only some states responded.
- The government has provided benefits to the telecom sector by withdrawing some duties.
- National Digital Communication Policy that came in 2018 envisages that there should be an enhanced limit of 50 Mbps download to every citizen in the country by 2022. To achieve that, the government is involving state governments for the creation of infrastructure.
Suggestions
- The government should increase the network area through optical fiber instead of copper which is expensive. This is necessary to ensure last-mile connectivity.
- The government needs to prepare a ground for easy right-of-way permissions and lower cost of right-of-ways.
- It is time to go for a generational shift to ensure that the current tariff is financially viable for service providers.
- Telecom Operators should move towards future technologies, should add new services for which consumers will pay and will keep the telecom companies doing well.
- Telecom Operators should leverage the talent pool in the country which is bringing in a lot of new innovations in AI, blockchain technology, etc.
- New Infrastructure on a sharable basis just like the way telecom service providers share the cost of towers is need for the hour. Every establishment requires a cable for one reason or another and roads cannot dig every day. Ducts should be constructed in each and every town so that there is a provision for simply pulling a cable through it as and when required and hence costs can be shared.
- The government should spend large on R&D and create an environment that makes India capable of manufacturing and even exporting hardware components like mobile handsets, CCTV Cameras, touch screen monitors, etc.
Future of Telecom Sector is very bright as its role will be seen in almost everything, from networking of CCTV Cameras to the safety and security of people to providing education in remote places. A long term vision plan should be made accordingly. For the time being, the government needs to provide an easy and soothing environment for telecom operators.
Payment ID:MOJO9b01O00A90839766
Please review
One great thing about the answer is that you have followed the same theme in both the part of your main body
While you discussed the challenges in the form of administration, infrastructure, and markets, your way forwards also followed the same theme.
These styles of structuring and presentation are quite good.
Keep it up.
The overall content is apt to the demand of the question.
Good 1st part of the answer.
Discussion on the importance of the telecom sector after intro is very good.
The presentation is decent with fine language and explanation.
please review…
payment id:MOJO9a29300A61774733
Very good discussion.
The content is to the point and quite informative.
The overall language and explanation are decent.
The structure is also decent.
But write clearly and give some space between changing subheadings.
You can also use flowcharts in between to bring in the XFactor in your answer.
MOJO9930Q00N64198657
Always write conclusions in your answers.
They are the soft landing for your answers.
The overall content is decent.
The explanation and coverage done is fantastic.
The points are well placed and the structure is smooth.
The way forwards are excellent.
Good presentation.
ID
MOJO9b01C00A90817216
Please review.
While the intro is decent, but do mention the main topic of the question: “Challenges”
Always link the issue in hand in your intro. Therefore, towards the end of the intro simply write that “Despite being such an important sector for the Indian economy and society, recently the telecom sector is facing hurdles in its growth. ”
Solutions and way ahead are technically the same thing in UPSC lingo. Hence the last part is ideally your conclusion because the 2nd part of your main body is your way forward/solution.
These little details will help you a lot in structuring the answers.
Overall the content is decent.
Very good use of flowchart in the 1st part of the main body.
The explanation in the way forward is superb.
The language is easy and crisp.
Very good conclusion. But write the last concluding part in a small paragraph, just like your intro. Intro and conclusion should never be never written in bullet points.
Mojo9803c00n96073071
Kindly upload clear images.
Most of the times they are blurred.
The content is very good and deep in the answer.
You have technically covered all the important elements of the topic.
The presentation and structure of the answer are excellent.
In the 1st part of the main body, your divisions of the challenges into various subsects are decent.
Keep it up.
Good that you mentioned the Anil Swaroop Committee’s recommendations.
The way forwards are well explained.
Solutions and way ahead are technically the same thing in UPSC lingo. Hence the last part is ideally your conclusion because the 2nd part of your main body is your way forward/solution.
MOJO9b03K00A07920521
The explanation part could be improved in the 1st part of the main body.
For example, when you say that there is a challenge due to the frequent policy changes by the government, then you have to mention those changes.
Otherwise, it will remain a general statement with no backing by an explanation or data.
The overall direction of the answer is decent.
The structure is fine and the content covered is decent.
Good way forwards
MOJO9903H00A58015579
A very good and detailed intro. But do mention the main topic of the question: “Challenges”
Always link the issue in hand in your intro. Therefore, towards the end of the intro simply write that “Despite being such an important sector for the Indian economy and society, recently the telecom sector is facing hurdles in its growth. ”
The overall structure of the answer is the best part here.
Not that there is anything lacking in the content, but it is the way that you have divided all your content in each subheading in mini subsects, which is refreshing.
Keep it up.
The topic covered through your points is exhaustive and quite decently explained.
The overall presentation is decent.
Good way forwards.
MOJO9828N00A10807750
In the 1st part of the answer, briefly discuss the significance of the telecom sector in the Indian economy and society.
The rest of the answer is fine.
Good and detailed discussion in the main body.
Decent balance in the answer.
Both the parts are covered nicely.
Good way forwards.
Underline important keypoints in your answers.