Mentors Comments:
- Class XI and XII NCERT – Indian society
- The question is from GS paper I and aims to discuss the role of regional attitudes on the national unity of the country.
- One has to explain with suitable examples of the effect of regional attitudes on the national unity of the country.
- Start by discussing the concept of regionalism.
- In the main body explain that regionalism is the expression of a common sense of identity and purpose by people within a specific geographical region, united by its unique language, culture, language, etc.
- Discuss the emergence of regional political parties as a result of secessionist tendencies. This trend is polarizing citizens of the country on regional lines. Example, Telugu Desam Party of Andhra Pradesh, DMK and AIADMK of Tamil Nadu.
- Regionalism reached that stage where it is equivalent to be an internal security threat to the country. It is causing friction among states.
- Conclude with suggestions to overcome such attitudes.
Answer:
Regionalism is a feeling or an ideology among a section of people residing in a particular geographical space characterized by unique language, culture etc., that they are the sons of the soil and every opportunity in their land must be given to the first but not to the outsiders. It is a sort of Parochialism. In most of the cases, it is raised for expedient political gains but not necessarily.
Regional assertiveness can prove to be a peril to national unity:
- Regionalism puts the regional priority above the national priority. Therefore, it may impair the national development.
- It breeds hatred among the region. Example violence against Bihari workers in the North East by ULFA
- It impacts the integrity of the nation. Over motivated regionalism sometimes turns into a secessionist movement. example Khalistan movement.
- Violence is a very common characteristic of regionalism. To protect regional identity people may take violent means. Example Nellie massacre during Assam movement.
- It discourages cultural exchange and often breeds intolerance towards other regions. E.g.: The anti-migrant or anti-Bihari stance of the Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS) which opposes the employment and residence of non-Maharashtrian people in the state of Maharashtra is a prime example of negative regionalism.
- It discourages migration. Due to hostility towards people from other region workers reference from moving out and settling there
- It impacts the ease of doing business. Due to regional aspiration, local people pass difficulties for private investors to hire freely as per their own requirement private companies are often forced to reserve job and contract only for local people son of the soil
- It also impacts the International relationship example West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee is obstructing Teesta deal between India and Bangladesh only to quench her regional thirst.
- Regionalism beyond a point can lead to secessionism, such as strong regionalism in Punjab ultimately resulted in the growth of Khalistani terrorism.
- Regionalism often promotes Vote- Bank politics, thereby weakening the national integration.
- Regionalism can weaken the time tested fabric of ‘Unity in Diversity’, if promoted in an ultra-manner.
Measures needed to quell the extreme regionalist perspectives:
- Unity in Diversity ethos needs to be preserved for the pluralistic character of the Indian nation-state.
- The accommodation of multiple aspirations of a diverse population is necessary.
- Formation of the NITI Aayog has been a positive step to enhance cooperative federalism by fostering the involvement of the State Governments of India in the economic policy-making process using a bottom-up approach.
- While a number of steps such as the launch of centrally sponsored schemes, incentives to private players for development in backward states have been taken by the government for inclusive development, there is a greater need for their effective implementation.
- There is a need to increase the level of social expenditure by the states on education, health, and sanitation which are the core for human resource development.
- Introducing a system of national education that would help people to overcome regional feelings and develop an attachment towards the nation can act as a long-term solution to the problem of sub-nationalism.
- While the National Integration Council was set up in 1961, there is a need to utilise its potential more effectively.
- Schemes like “Ek Bharat-Shreshtha Bharat” have been launched by the GOI to celebrate unity in diversity culture of the nation and to strengthen sentiment for National Unity between the citizens of states, is a welcomed step.
- National unity is not impaired if the people of a region have genuine pride in their language and culture.
The need of the hour is to develop each region of India, through devolution of power to local governments and empowering people for their participation in decision-making. The governments at State level need to find out the alternative resources of energy, source of employment for local people, use of technology in governance, planning and for agriculture development.
1.
Payment id MOJO0108C00A53108865
Payment id mentioned separately
Use blank sheet for answer writing.
yes i have ordered online. will be getting the upsc answer sheets booklet in three days. till then managing in this
The overall length of your statements and paragraphs is too large. Avoid it.
Keep the discussion in most parts of your main under bullet points with relevant subheadings. Writing in paragraphs affects your crispness of the content.
Overall discussion is in the right direction but the structure could have been better.
The concluding paragraph is too lengthy.
Also, you have not discussed the main body in the required depth. I mean more content was needed.
Read the model answer for content as well as the structure and bullet-point format.
Your writing is quite clear.
Underline important points in your answer.
Payment Id- MOJO0101D00A20979010
Apart from a missing way forward, the rest of the answer is decent.
Your coverage in the main body is satisfactory.
Your points are exhaustive and well covered.
Good language.
But discuss the steps needed to remedy the issue. Then only conclude your answer.
To break the monotony of the points, you can use flowcharts in your answer.
payment id-MOJO9925Q00A88602377.
The presentation style is flawed and clustered.
In this style, you won’t be touching many issues and the depth of the answer will be affected.
The answer demands that you deal with the overall issues of regionalism and in stead of quoting cases, you should quote specific examples in between your points.
Read the model answer to understand the presentation needed and the required depth in your points.
Your idea is decent but the execution is flawed given that it is a 15 marks question.
Shorten the length of your statements. They are too big.
Underline imp points in your answer.
plz review
Apart from the presentation, the content and the answer are very good.
The direction of the answer is very good.
You got the hang of the question.
Both structure and your language are very good.
The demand of the question has been met in a decent manner.
But avoid cuttings in your answer because with the current handwriting any cutting makes the presentation weak.
MOJO0102A00A52642901
Underline important stuff in your answer.
Good content in the main body.
The structure is superb.
But avoid large statements.
Generally, your statements should be around 10-12 words.
Very good intro.
The way forwards are excellent.
Decent conclusion
MOJO9c26500A04493668
The content and their explanation needs maturity. The examples of children or impact on trade are totally misplaced. For better content in the 1st part of the answer read the model answer.
Your answer is discussing the issue of migration and insiders vs outsiders.
That is not the demand of the question.
Read the model answer.
Way forward is on the right track but again the explanation needs to be top-notch.
payment id MOJO0108200A53118559
PAYMENT ID MENTIONED SEPARATELY, Thank you
Too lengthy paragraphs. Especially in the 1st and last part of the answer.
This is not the ideal length.
First of all, it is advisable to use bullet points under relevant subheadings in the main body. The paragraphs are only suited for the intro and conclusion, that too small ones.
Ideally, the paragraphs should be small with 2 3 statements. That’s it. The paragraph style seems to look like a book or editorial.
Your intro is too bulky. You have discussed the concept f regionalism in great lengths. That is not right.
Your main theme should be on the discussion on HOW REGIONAL ASSERTIVENESS CAN PROVE TO BE PERIL.
Your overall direction is OK but the execution is flawed.
Read the model answer for better structuring.
Right now the points are over-explained.