Mentor’s Comments-
- https://www.thehindu.com/opinion/op-ed/beware-the-tempting-apple-of-ukraine-mediation/article66133040.ece
- Introduce the answer with defining the Ukraine crisis.
- In the body of the answer, first, discuss why India’s balanced response reflects its mature strategic thinking.
- Next, give some arguments in favour of India playing a role in seeking to bring Russia and Ukraine to the negotiating table for brokering peace.
- Next, underline the pitfalls in assuming such a responsibility.
- Suggest a way forward.
- Conclude by emphasizing the need to exercise caution in undertaking such efforts.
Payment id – KbDAF1tATt88eX
Pallab
Good Effort.
Introduction and India’s approach till now have been decently written. You can also mention that through this stance India has secured its significant defense partnership with Russia, kept door open for partnership with Russia in event of a crisis with China (national interests). Other points are good.
Before starting the next part about India’s possible role in a mediation you should mention that India’s commitment towards dialogue, diplomacy and stability has enhanced India’s credibility and both Ukraine and Russia have welcomed Indian mediation in the ongoing Ukraine crisis. (it shows that India indeed can play that role). This should be enough for showing that India has the capacity.
After that, you need to analyse whether India should play that role or not. Mention the advantages and disadvantages.
In advantages you can mention- such a role could justify India’s theory of all-alignment, bring India closer to UNSC membership, show India as a responsible power especially as India is going to become the G20 president etc.
Disadvantages are that it can hamper India’s present diplomatic stance, in the past such efforts haven’t yielded good results for India and there are no particular advantages for India for such an effort, Cracks in Indo-Russia relationship mentioned by you is fine.
Not clear how this will lead to collapse in Indo-US relationship as you have mentioned, need to explain that. In fact it is the west which wants India to mediate as they think that India has good leverage with Russia.
Way forward is fine, conclusion is also okay except that Indo-US thing.
Keep practicing. 🙂
5.5/15
Pay_KaNUBqe9x9tIgg
pay_KaRyPM2bJjqanb
Payment Idpay_KbP4ZbGolDMldc
Razorpay Order Id: KaV0C7aA9qwW8k
Staff @CD NOT EVALUATED
@Staff
Idpay_KaRPF4ETAAtEFs
Payment ID : #0000645504
Staff @CD
Payment ID – pay_KXNTIDpjHTMiv0