Mentors Comments:
1. What is monetary policy transmission
2. What are the challenges it faces and why
3. Solutions
Answer:
Monetary transmission refers to the process by which a central bank’s monetary policy signals (like repo rate) are passed on, through financial system to influence the businesses and households. There are many monetary policy signals by the RBI; the most powerful one is the repo rate.
Asymmetry in monetary policy transmission
Banks find it more difficult to cut lending rates immediately after a cut in the policy rate because the cost of deposits does not adjust commensurately and immediately, given the fixed nature of deposit contracts. However, banks can raise lending rates far more quickly after a policy rate hike, because loans are mostly at variable rates, and can be re-priced faster.
There is a competitive constraint of reducing deposit rates too much and too quick as well. If bank deposit rates are lower than small savings rates which are administratively fixed, there could be some deposit flight to small savings schemes providing higher returns.
The Reserve Bank of India has been highlighting the problems with the economy’s monetary transmission mechanism for some time now. Some reasons that result in a lag in monetary transmission in India are:
1. Pressure on banks due to locking of funds in government securities (SLR) and cash reserves (CRR). As some funds are already locked in these, banks find it difficult to remain profitable while passing on rate cut benefits.
2. While the banks are not that eager to lend, the demand for credit from corporates also remain low, due to balance sheet concerns, difficulty in acquiring land for fresh green-field projects, low capacity utilisation and lower working capital loan requirement, helped by falling global oil prices.
3. Increasing NPAs in bank balance sheets are one more reason why they cannot quickly pass on rate cuts to users.
4. Just as CRR increases coupled with increase in repo rate reduces liquidity, a decrease in repo rate has to be coupled by decrease in CRR also by RBI, to incentivize banks to increase liquidity in economy.
5. Lack of developed bond markets ensures that most public savings are in Bank deposits, reducing the banks' dependency on repo rate. This in turn reduces the repo rate’s effectiveness in influencing monetary transmission.
6. There is the rather frustrating legacy of administered interest rates, the most prominent of which are the rates on small savings and provident funds.
7. Similarly, the return on provident funds is decided annually by a process that can only be described as political.
Way forward
The RBI can address this issue by measures to
1. Reduce CRR to induce liquidity in banks
2. Improve bond markets by reducing conditions on banks to purchase govt. bonds, and making the govt. bond market more open as recommended by Urjit Patel Committee.
3. Reduce constraints on bank lending through Priority sector norms.
4. Recommendations by committees headed by Y V Reddy and Shyamala Gopinath that the small savings rate be linked to market rates
5. RBI has told banks to link their interest rates to external benchmarks instead of MCLR to ensure better transmission of monetary policy rates. The options to banks are linking rates to repo rate, the 91-day T-bill yield, the 182-day T-bill yield, or any other benchmark market interest rate produced by the Financial Benchmarks India.
Given the persistence of rigidities, the RBI needs to take a holistic view of all the factors that might hinder transmission and act in concert with the government to deal with them.
Payment ID: MOJO9802W00A98715356
Please review
Very lengthy intro. Avoid over explanation there.
Your language and content are good.
But answer suffers from over explanation in most parts of the answer.
Also you can add multiple dimensions in the 1st part of your answer, regarding the reasons for monetary policy transmission. For that, read the model answer.
Overall structure is good.
Try to keep points short like you did in the geography answer.
Pls review
Hi Wasim
The content in the 1st part is general and repetitive.
For better and to the point content and more dimensions in the 1st part, read the model answer.
Way forwards are very good.
Language and presentation are very decent.
MOJO9803R00N96087322
Hi Megha
You dont have to mention what Central Bank in India means. Do not write such detailed statements. It is intrinsic.
You have discussed so many thing after intro which are not the demand of the question. Never lose the focus from the demand of the question and stay in the periphery of it.
After intro, simply mention what is monetary policy transmission.
You whole answer is based on some random premise of monetary policies and its challenges but it is not the question.
You had to discuss why does the RBI’s rate cuts are not reflected in the commercial banks’ lending rates? What are the issues? What should RBI do to nudge banks to transmit those benefits to customers.
Always read the question carefully and break it into multiple dimensions.
The answer is not at all regarding the question.
Monetary transmission refers to the process by which a central bank’s monetary policy signals (like repo rate) are passed on, through financial system to influence the businesses and households. There are many monetary policy signals by the RBI; the most powerful one is the repo rate.
MOJO9803C00N96073071
You dont have to write sub headings like Content or Conclusion. It is intrinsic.
The discussion is good.
But try not to over explain things.
Keep the discussion short and simple.
Dont mention the names of people until and unless its very important in UPSC answers.
Give better way forwards in terms of depth.
Q2
You misunderstood the theme of the question.
You whole answer is based on some random premise of monetary policies and its challenges but it is not the question.
You had to discuss why does the RBI’s rate cuts are not reflected in the commercial banks’ lending rates? What are the issues? What should RBI do to nudge banks to transmit those benefits to customers.
Always read the question carefully and break it into multiple dimensions.
The answer is not at all regarding the question.
Read the model answer please.
MOJO9801U00N04106675, Please Review My Answer.
The 1st part of the answer is really good and well discussed.
The 2nd part lacks content and depth.
For more points and dimensions in that part, read the model answer please. You will get ample amount of inputs.
The flow of the answer is decent.
Payment ID: MOJO9731Y00N34245077
Very good answer.
The only missing point is a conclusion.
Otherwise the answer is very good and to the point.
Both the parts in the answer have proper depth and coverage.
Points are apt and well placed.
Language and presentation are crisp.
Do write a conclusion.
q2
MOJO9731E00D34250209
You understood the demands of the question which is good.
The explanation overall is very good.
The 1st part of the answer is really good and well discussed.
The 2nd part lacks content and depth.
For more points and dimensions in that part, read the model answer please. You will get ample amount of inputs.
The flow of the answer is decent.
MOJO9728J00A50299555
Answer suffers from lack of content.
The flow and structure are good.
Some of the major points you missed in the 1st part are:
locking of funds in government securities (SLR); demand for credit from corporate also remain low; lack of developed bond markets; most public savings are in Bank deposits; legacy of administered interest rates; the rates on small savings and provident funds; return on provident funds is decided annually etc.
Read the model answer for more inputs and dimensions in both parts.
Q2
Very good answer.
You have covered the theme of teh answer in decent manner.
All the parts are perfectly discussed in details which lends the perfect balance to the answer.
The content is to the point and language crisp.
All in all decent try.
MOJO9801A00D04078686