Mentors Comments:
1. Give an overview of water sources and demands on water
2. Mention the challenges in water management in India
3. Provide solutions
Answer:
Recent incident of severe drinking water crisis in various parts of the country like Chennai, Bihar etc highlights the need for efficient water management practices in India.
India is today facing a Water Emergency-
India has only 4% of global freshwater resources. But, it has to address the needs of about 18% of global population.
About 75% of households do not have drinking water at home, 84% rural households do not have piped water access, and 70% of India’s water is contaminated, with the country currently ranked 120 among 122 in the water quality index.
Currently, water resources in India are shrinking.
The groundwater in most of the parts of northwestern India is now available at 100 metres below the ground. With the present rate of extraction, in future, the groundwater will be available at 200 or 300 meres below the ground.
Level of water in the reservoirs is going down. At present, the 91 reservoirs that Central Water Commission (CWC) monitors, are around 19% of their life storage.
Due to climate change, India in the near future will witness an increase in hot spells, change in rain patterns, thus, the problem of frequent floods and frequent droughts.
Reasons for Water Stress and Water Scarcity is due to poor water governance which are follows-
Inefficient water management and uneven distribution: In India, some regions have an excess amount of water for their needs or requirements while some regions are facing droughts or have less amount of water simultaneously.
Improper water irrigation: as we know India is one of the top agricultural countries in the world so they need for the water for irrigation is very high.
Traditional techniques of the water irrigation resulted in the loss of water due to evaporation, drainage, excess use of groundwater, etc.
Government several policies to farmers for providing free electricity and financial support for water extraction through tube wells and bore wells resulted in the exploitation of water.
Rapid urbanization, industrialization, population growth, demand for domestic use increases the demand for water in India.
Water pollution in the form of disposal of industrial wastes, domestic wastes into the freshwater bodies like rivers, lakes have resulted in polluting water bodies. Hence eutrophication of surface water along with coastal water will increase.
The most common reason is that water is not valued in India.
Poor water storage: During the monsoon season the desilting operations of the water bodies, dams, etc are not done at the time affecting the water storage capacity of India.
Poor legislation on groundwater extraction, political reasons for not valuing water, etc. enhance water scarcity in India.
The participation of individuals, NGOs and different communities in the water management process is quite missing.
Suggestions-
The time has come when India needs as rigorous a program on water efficiency as it has on energy efficiency.
Managing the demand side of water management is crucial as India cannot increase the per capita availability of water.
Almost all major rivers in the country are shared between the states and perhaps, it is premature to expect that the states will surrender their authority over the river basins in their respective territories. But, at least, they can come together for coordination over the river basins and sharing the relevant information. The Central Government can play a major role in bringing the states together.
The country needs to have a specific plan for water-stressed states.
Both the central government and the state governments need to have considerations on setting the Minimum Support Price (MSP) of water consuming crops.
The government needs to encourage local participation for conserving water in the country. Hiware Bazar is a good example.
Incentive based water conservation in rural parts in the water stressed areas is another solution, for example, if a particular level of groundwater level is maintained, higher MSP can be provided to the farmers of that region.
Water-use efficiency in agriculture can be ensured by making farmers aware and by providing them, on the ground, technologies like the one related to water resistant crops.
In-situ water conservation techniques like rain water harvesting, check dams need to be continued.
The effective answer to the freshwater crisis is to integrate conservation and development activities – from water extraction to water management – at the local level; making communities aware and involving them fully is therefore critical for success. All this will ultimately pave the way for combining conservation of the environment with the basic needs of people.
Payment ID: MOJO9731Y00N34245077
Your answer is comprehensive.
To make the structure better, divide your discussion into two components: climate change and food security.
That will make your discussed points more relevant to the demand of the question.
Points are good and well framed.
Neha pandey : please review waiting for your valuable suggestions
Good discussion.
Points are exhaustive.
All the major dimensions are covered.
Well explained.
The way forward could have been divided into two sections: Climate Change and Food security.
Fine conclusion.
MOJO9803R00N96087322
Hi Megha
Your answer is very good.
Well tried.
The points and their dimensions are deep and wide.
The way forwards are well placed and discussed.
All the elements are good in answer.
Keep writing
Q3. MOJO9808900D18943247
Hi Shivangi
The overall discussion could have been divided into two sections: Climate Change and Food security and answered accordingly.
Points are extensive.
Fine conclusion.
Q3
Focus more on the points regarding water management.
Also link them to the statement of the question which points out food security and climate change.
The structure of the answer is good.
Way forward could have better points regarding management.
MOJO9803C00N96073071
Make your flowcharts readable. Do not make the fonts so small that it is not visible and it fails the purpose of flowchart.
Your points are very good all in all.
But while presenting points, make them coherent to each other.
I mean link them to the flow of the answer.
For example,the point of Mihir Shah committee is very good but it is not placed with the flow.
Mention it in the starting of the way forward discussion.
Right now it looks a separate discussion from the rest of way forward while both of them have same discussion.
Work on your skill of this element.
q3
MOJO9731E00D34250209
Very well written answer.
Your structure and dimensions within it are excellent.
Your points are significant.
Flow, presentation and explanation all are covered holistically.
MOJO9801U00N04106675, Please Review My Answer.
Lengthy discussion after intro. No need for that.
After intro, simply discuss what are the issues with water management in India in terms of food security and climate change.
Good points overall in the main body.
To make better use of space if you are having trouble giving more points, use flowcharts. These are lengthy topics and sometimes you are not left with much space.
Conclusion is missing.
Payment ID: MOJO9802W00A98715356
Please review
No Need to discuss those things regarding water consumption etc after intro.
Jump to the issues with water management in India in terms of food security and climate change, after intro.
Rest of the answer is fine.
Sometimes points are over explained but right now it is not hindering your answer because of smooth flow. But do work on it because it can hurt the structure of answers and you will feel lack of space many times.
Way forwards are very good.
MOJO9813J00N70217069