Mentors Comment:
As mentioned earlier, art and culture questions are factual and straightforward. This question is same too.
Briefly introduce both the religions and then jump to the reasons for Buddhism spreading out while Jainism failing to do so.
Role of royal patronage, characteristics of the religion, flexibility in practices and support from academicians and travellers will the main sub headings.
More than the discussion, your presentation will fetch you better marks. There will be lots of points to mention but in order to score better, try to frame discussion in orderly manner.
Answer:
Lord Buddha was the founder of Buddhism and preached only in the area covering present day UP, Bihar, Jharkhand and Nepal border but his disciples also preached into the foreign lands. Jainism is one of the oldest religion in the world and they traced their history through a history of successors known as Tirthankaras and Mahavir was the last tirthankar. In the early age the political spread of the Bharatkhand was much larger and jainism was spread all across. It travelled outside India in places like Sri Lanka, Nepal, Afghanistan, Iran etc, with the foreign tourists visiting India at that time. But its spread was not as spectacular as that was of Buddhism. Though Jainism and Buddhism share some common features, the latter spread spread to other Asian countries while the former is confined to India.
Role of royal patronage for spreading in foreign places:
The emergence of Ashoka (273-232 B.C.) was an important turning point for Buddhism and made Buddha dhamma the basis of all his actions in the spiritual as well as temporal fields. Under his guidance, third Buddhist council was held and he send missionaries to present day Sri Lanka, Burma to propagate Buddhism.
When Greeks and Kushans established their rule over North-West India in 2nd century BC and the 1st Century BC respectively, they embraced Buddhism and popularised it in different parts of the world.
Though Jainism was also supported by some kings it was not of above scale. Ashoka, Kanishka and Harsha were pivotal in spreading of Buddhism to outside India.
Even when jainism was picked up by rulers, they immediately became ascetics and not rulers.
Different nature of the religions:
Buddhism is a missionary religion with monks and nuns (Sangha) trying to spread the message of Dharma propounded by Buddha where as Jainism is not very missionary.
Buddhism can also be easily practiced by lay people with stricter rules only for monks/nuns trying to attain Nirvana.
Jain branch of Shraman theology remained more close to it’s roots. They did not bother to preach their philosophy to anyone, because for the seekers of this branch of theology, their own emancipation was primary.
The concept of helping others never emerged in early Jainism. Their concept of helping others was to stop creating troubles for them. Thus, the entire focus of this philosophy and its seekers always remained – inwards.
Flexible practices of Buddhism:
Jains considered it a taboo to travel by water since it harmed organisms more compared to barefoot land travel. As Buddhists did not hold such a view and so were able to spread the religion to Sri Lanka, South-East Asia, China etc.
Buddhism has no strong restrictions on food for lay followers and could easily spread to communities and areas with non-vegetarian food habits.
The Belief of Jainism in cycles of birth and death of soul (reincarnation of soul) and it’s goal of liberation from this cycle -Kaivalya might not have been well received by people of other areas who did not believe in such ideas where as the main goal of Buddhism-end of dukkha (suffering, unsatisfactoriness) i.e. Nirvana was well received by people of various areas especially by kings and intelligentsia.
Role of intelligentsia:
Buddhism was also strongly supported by intelligentsia with a glorious Buddhist University (Maha Vihara) at Nalanda and other universities (Viharas) at Vikramashila, Odantipur etc. which boasts of scholars such as Acharya Nagarjuna, Aryabhata, Xuan Zang, Fa Hien etc.
This was pivotal in transmitting Buddhism to the intelligentsia of other Asian countries. Xuan Zang and Fa Hien are especially instrumental in spreading the message of Buddha to China and East Asia.
Buddhism became a prominent subject in architecture, paintings, sculptures, which were based on jataka or the previous birth stories of Buddha. This helped immensely in their popularity abroad. This aspect of aesthetics lacked in Jainism.
During colonization period, archaeologists dug up the ancient Buddhist sites, learned the Pali and Sanskrit text, and they connected the dot. This further enhanced the status of Buddhism worldwide and it started gaining traction once again.
Notwithstanding all the points mentioned, Jainism’s thoughts and philosophy are as equally admirable as that of Buddhism’s. Since the differences between both the philosophies of Jainism and Buddhism are essentially less, it is the marketing of the idea that made much of the difference between present day world population of Buddhists to that of jains. Any idea becomes a reality when it is supported by power sometimes in the form of money. This ensured Buddhism survived even when the Shankaracharya revived Hinduism all over India.
Buddhism and Jainism dates back their origin somewhat parallel in 6th century B.C.
Buddhism which was patronized by Gautama Buddha whereas in Jainism there are 24 tirtankars who are associated with it but Mahavira (24th tirtankar) is mostly recognised for it.
In the present scenario buddhism has lost its base in origin state and as gained more followers abroad , whereas jainism is mostly restricted to sub-continent.
various reason for the following are:
1- CHARACTERISTIC- Jainism which promotes more of austric life in comparison to buddhism. Example- every creature according to them(Jainism) is living hence killing them is a violence. therefore agriculture is as a occupation is restricted which on the contrary accounts large number of people.
2-ROYAL PATRONAGE- Buddhism from the early time has been accepted by various kings like – kaniska , Asoka, Gupta, who in order made it popular among their empire and around the world.
3- ACADEMICIANS AND TRAVELERS – Fa hein , huein tsang , i tsering , nagarguna played a major role in sperading buddhism across the world. the following was lacked in jainism.
4- FLEXIBILITY- Practice like salekena in Jainism in order to end the cycle of life was banned by SC. whereas idol worship patronized by Mahayana Buddhism made in easier for people to switch from old religion to new, as they were acquainted with totem practice.
Overall both the religion as evolved a lot from its original form adopting the changing time making it more user friendly to adopt.
Hi Ankish
Its better if you write on paper. That will give you better sense of presentation and structure due to space crunch.
The content of the answer is good.
The dimensions discussed in the main body are decent and exhaustive.
Good conclusion.
For more points, read the model answer.
Payment ID: MOJO9731Y00N34245077
Payment ID: MOJO9731Y00N34245077
Hi Kanchan
Please upload clear images.
Underline important points in your answers.
The intro is good but the main body needs more dimensions and content.
For more points read the model answer.
the language and explanation in the answer are good.
Please review waiting for your valuable suggestions
Hi Neha
No need to discuss the basic principles of Jainism and Buddhism in details.
The points in the main body are very good.
They are of the required demand of the question.
Work on your writing skills and presentations.
Better conclusion was needed. Read the model answer.
1
Hi Project Osiris
Whats the point of giving way ahead in this answer.
The content needs better placement. Rather than discussing reasons for both’s spread separately, you should discuss them simultaneously.
Points in the main body are of same nature and hence repetitive.
More content in the main body are needed with exhaustive dimensions.
Read the model answer for that.
Q1
Hi Sourav
The history of Jainism and Buddhism spans from the 6th century BCE.
Avoid points like restaurant eating or prostitution. Work on your language
One important aspect that you missed to discuss in the answer is:
“Buddhism became a prominent subject in architecture, paintings, sculptures, which were based on jataka or the previous birth stories of Buddha. This helped immensely in their popularity abroad. This aspect of aesthetics lacked in Jainism. During colonization period, archaeologists dug up the ancient Buddhist sites, learned the Pali and Sanskrit text, and they connected the dot. This further enhanced the status of Buddhism worldwide and it started gaining traction once again.”
Rest of the answer in terms of content depth is fine.
The dimensions covered are very good.
Good conclusion.
Payment ID: MOJO9802W00A98715356
Please review
Hi Sahithya
Please avoid lengthy intros.
Very good answer in terms of content and dimensions.
You have covered all the elements of the discussion.
Good structure and presentation.
Explanation is crisp.
IDMOJO9728J00A50299555
Hi Amandeep
More content in the main body are needed with exhaustive dimensions.
Read the model answer for that.
The explanation is OK.
MOJO9801U00N04106675 Sir, Please Review My Answer.
Hi Vishwanath
One important aspect that you missed to discuss in the answer is:
“Buddhism became a prominent subject in architecture, paintings, sculptures, which were based on jataka or the previous birth stories of Buddha. This helped immensely in their popularity abroad. This aspect of aesthetics lacked in Jainism. During colonization period, archaeologists dug up the ancient Buddhist sites, learned the Pali and Sanskrit text, and they connected the dot. This further enhanced the status of Buddhism worldwide and it started gaining traction once again.”
Rest of the answer is good.
Conclusion is missing.
Work on your presentation,
MOJO9803C00N96073071
Hi Ashraf
The content is rich and has proper depth.
But it needs better placement.
Rather than discussing reasons for both’s spread separately, you should discuss them simultaneously.
Read the model answer for placement.
Overall nice answer.