Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Madan Lal Dhingra
Mains level: Not Much
Central Idea
- On the 114th anniversary of his execution, a memorial is being formally inaugurated in honour of Madan Lal Dhingra.
Who was Madan Lal Dhingra?
- Early Life: Born on September 18, 1883, in an affluent family in Amritsar, Dhingra’s father was a staunch British loyalist, working as a chief medical officer.
- Shift towards Nationalism: Dhingra’s exposure to the nationalist movement in Lahore during his studies ignited his patriotism.
- Socio-Economic Concerns: Driven by a sense of justice and concern for India’s impoverished masses, Dhingra’s patriotism extended to socio-economic issues.
- Expulsion and Resilience: Expelled from college for protesting against the use of British-imported cloth, Dhingra’s defiance marked his commitment to the cause.
Involvement in Revolutionary Circles
- Contact with Leaders: Dhingra connected with prominent figures like Vinayak Damodar Savarkar and Shyamji Krishna Varma, active in London’s revolutionary circles.
- India House: Dhingra frequented India House, a hub for revolutionary Indian nationalism founded by Shyamji Krishna Varma, further igniting his revolutionary spirit.
- Abhinav Bharat Mandal: Dhingra joined Abhinav Bharat Mandal founded by Vinayak Savarkar, where he refined his plan to assassinate Curzon Wyllie.
Assassination of Curzon Wyllie
- Curzon Wyllie’s Profile: Curzon Wyllie was a British Indian officer and intelligence officer known for collecting information on revolutionaries.
- The Assassination: On July 1, 1909, Dhingra attended an event where Curzon Wyllie was present. Dhingra fired five shots, fatally hitting both Curzon Wyllie and a doctor who tried to intervene.
- Dhingra’s Justification: During his trial, Dhingra argued that if fighting Germans was patriotic for an Englishman, fighting the British was even more justifiable for him.
Legacy and Memorial
- Execution and Burial: Dhingra was found guilty, executed on August 17, 1909, and buried in London. His remains were brought to India in 1976.
- Struggle for a Memorial: A memorial in Dhingra’s name has been a long-standing demand. The efforts culminated in the formal inauguration of the memorial on the 114th anniversary of his execution.
- Memorial Inauguration: The memorial was inaugurated by Governor Banwari Lal Purohit on August 17, 2023, in Amritsar’s Golbagh area.
- Memorial’s Significance: The memorial stands as a tribute to Dhingra’s sacrifice and his role in the fight for India’s freedom.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Tachymenoides harrisonfordi
Mains level: Not Much
Central Idea
- The snake, known as Tachymenoides harrisonfordi, was named after Harrison Ford for his commitment to environmental advocacy.
Tachymenoides harrisonfordi
- It is a snake species that was named in honour of the actor Harrison Ford.
- This naming was a recognition of Ford’s dedication to environmental advocacy.
- Its characteristics include:
- Physical Attributes: Tachymenoides Harrisonfordi measures approximately 16 inches (40.6 centimetres) and features a yellowish-brown colour with scattered black blotches.
- Distinctive Features: The snake boasts a black belly, a vertical streak above its copper-coloured eye, and unique markings that contribute to its identity.
- Habitat and Elevation: The sole specimen, a male snake, was found sunbathing in a marsh at an altitude of 3,248 meters above sea level.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: INS Vindhyagiri, Project 17A
Mains level: Naval fleet modernization
Central Idea
- President’s launch of INS Vindhyagiri, the final vessel in the Project 17A (Alpha) frigates series, marked a significant milestone for India’s maritime strength and self-reliance.
- The launch of INS Vindhyagiri, the sixth vessel in the Project 17A Frigates series, carries forward India’s naval legacy.
About INS Vindhyagiri
- INS Vindhyagiri is the sixth ship of the Project 17A Frigates series, showcasing India’s commitment to indigenous defense technology and self-reliance.
- After INS Nilgiri, Udaygiri, Himgiri, Taragiri, and Dunagiri, INS Vindhyagiri derives its name from a mountain range in Karnataka.
- These frigates are a follow-on class of the Project 17 (Shivalik Class) Frigates, integrating improved stealth, advanced weapons, and cutting-edge sensors.
- It is built by Garden Reach Shipbuilders and Engineers (GRSE) in Kolkata, India.
Key features
- Employs a cutting-edge propulsion system enabling speeds of over 28 knots, ensuring rapid response and agility in various operational scenarios.
- Equipped with state-of-the-art stealth features, enhancing its ability to operate discreetly and minimize detection.
- Over 75% of the equipment and systems used are sourced from indigenous firms, including Micro, Small, and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs).
Back2Basics: Project 17A
- Project 17 Alpha frigates (P-17A) were launched by the Indian Navy in 2019.
- The first stealth ship launched was the Nilgiri, launched in 2019.
- The project was launched to construct a series of stealth guided-missile frigates, which are currently being constructed by two companies:
- Mazagon Dock Shipbuilders (MDL) and
- Garden Reach Shipbuilders & Engineers (GRSE).
- These guided-missile frigates have been constructed with a specific stealth design, which has radar-absorbent coatings and is low-observable which can make its approach undetectable for the enemies.
- The new technology also reduces the infrared signals of the ship.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Remission, Pardoning Power
Mains level: Political use of Pardoning Power
Central Idea
- The Supreme Court bench handling petitions related to the early release of convicts in the Bilkis Bano case raised concerns about the selective application of remission policies in Indian jails.
- Justices on the two-judge bench questioned why the policy is not uniformly implemented and sought clarifications from the Additional Solicitor General representing the Gujarat government.
Also read:
What is Bilkis Bano Case?
Bilkis Bano Case and Remission
- Background of the Case: Bilkis Bano was a victim of gangrape during the 2002 riots in Gujarat, where her three-year-old daughter was also killed by a mob. She was pregnant at the time.
- Remission and Release: All 11 convicts in the Bilkis Bano case were granted remission by the Gujarat government, leading to their release on August 15, 2022.
- Justification for Release: The Additional Solicitor General defended the state’s decision, explaining that remission is distinct from sentencing and that guidelines are being considered to address concerns about its application.
Inquiry into Remission Policy Application
- Selective Implementation Query: The Supreme Court inquired why the policy of remission, aimed at granting convicts early release, is applied selectively across jails and states.
- Overcrowding and Undertrials: The court raised concerns about the overcrowding of jails, especially with undertrials, and questioned the reasons behind the policy not being consistently applied.
- Justice Nagarathna’s Query: Justice B V Nagarathna, leading the bench, emphasized that state-wise statistics are needed to understand the extent to which the remission policy is applied and whether every eligible prisoner is given an opportunity to reform.
- Relevance of Rudul Sah Case: Referring to the Rudul Sah case, where an individual remained in jail for 14 years despite acquittal, the court highlighted extreme cases where the prison system failed to provide justice. The court emphasized that fairness should prevail in both conviction and acquittal scenarios.
What is Remission?
- Stay of Execution: Remission involves suspending or postponing the execution of a sentence.
- Reduced Duration: It reduces the sentence’s duration while maintaining its original nature.
- Unchanged Sentence Nature: The sentence’s fundamental characteristics remain intact; only the duration is shortened.
- Release Date Determined: Remission sets a specific date for the prisoner’s release, marking their legal freedom.
- Conditional Release: Any breach of remission conditions cancels it, necessitating the completion of the original sentence.
Constitutional Framework for Remission:
- Prisons as State Subject: Prisons fall under the State List of the Seventh Schedule of the Indian Constitution.
- Pardoning Power: Article 72 (President) and Article 161 (Governor) grant pardoning, suspending, remitting, or commuting powers for sentences issued by courts.
New Norms for Remission:
(A) Eligibility Criteria
- Women and transgender convicts aged 50 and above
- Male convicts aged 60 and above, completing 50% of their sentence (excluding general remission period)
- Physically challenged convicts with 70% or more disability, completing 50% of their sentence
- Terminally ill convicts
- Convicts serving two-thirds (66%) of their sentence
- Indigent prisoners completing their sentence but detained due to unpaid fines
- Offenders aged 18-21 with no criminal involvement, completing 50% of their sentence
(B) Exceptions
- Excluded: Death sentence convicts, life imprisonment convicts, and those convicted under specific acts.
- Prohibited Acts: Terrorism-related offences, acts under anti-terror and security legislation, explosives, national security, official secrets, and anti-hijacking.
Implications and Benefits
- Justice and Equity: The new norms aim to provide justice to certain categories of prisoners and address their specific circumstances.
- Overcrowding Mitigation: By releasing eligible convicts, the policy seeks to alleviate prison overcrowding.
- Reformation Focus: Remission offers prisoners an opportunity to reform, especially those who demonstrate good behaviour or require medical attention.
- Humanitarian Approach: The policy recognizes the needs of the physically challenged, terminally ill, and aged prisoners.
- Respecting Youth: Young offenders with no further criminal engagement are given a chance for early rehabilitation.
Back2Basics: Pardoning Powers in India
- Pardoning powers in India, enshrined in Article 72 for the President and Article 161 for Governors, provide a mechanism for granting leniency, reducing sentences, or offering reprieves to convicted individuals.
- These powers play a crucial role in the justice system, allowing for the reconsideration of punishments in specific cases.
Presidential Pardoning Powers
- Scope and Authority: Article 72 empowers the President to grant pardons, respites, reprieves, or remissions of punishment, or to suspend, remit, or commute sentences.
- Types of Pardoning:
- Pardon: Complete exoneration, restoring the person’s status as a normal citizen.
- Commutation: Reducing the severity of punishment, e.g., converting a death penalty to life imprisonment.
- Reprieve: Delaying execution to allow time for further legal remedies or evidence presentation.
- Respite: Reducing the punishment’s degree due to specific circumstances.
- Remission: Altering the punishment’s quantum without changing its nature.
Cases Covered by Article 72
- Cases tried by court-martial.
- Cases involving offences under Union’s executive power.
- Cases with a death sentence.
Governor’s Pardoning Powers
- Governor’s Authority: Article 161 grants the Governor the power to pardon, commute, suspend, or remit sentences.
- Scope and Limitation: Pardoning authority extends to offences within the state’s executive jurisdiction.
- Exclusion: Governors lack the authority to grant pardons in cases of death sentences.
Nature of Pardoning Power
- Presidential Advice: Though not explicitly mentioned in the Constitution, the President exercises pardoning powers based on the Council of Ministers’ advice.
- Governor’s Power: The Governor’s pardoning power is also guided by the principle of seeking advice.
- Judicial Review: The Epuru Sudhakar case highlighted the possibility of limited judicial review over the pardon powers exercised by the President and Governors. This review aims to prevent arbitrariness.
- Judicial Retained Power: Despite these powers vested in the Executive, the judiciary retains a measure of authority for judicial review, ensuring fairness and constitutionality.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: NA
Mains level: India's youth aspirations and prominence of unemployment
What’s the news?
- A recent report released by Lokniti-CSDS has unveiled significant insights into the perspectives of India’s youth, aged 15 to 34, regarding the most pressing challenges confronting the nation.
Central idea
- The Lokniti-CSDS report provides a comprehensive insight into the concerns and preferences of Indian youth, shedding light on their perception of the country’s key challenges and their aspirations for the future. The report, conducted across 18 states with a sample size of 9,316 respondents, reveals a comprehensive picture of the concerns, hopes, and choices of India’s young population.
Findings of the Report
- Unemployment, A Central Worry:
- 36% of the surveyed youth view unemployment as the most critical challenge facing India.
- This represents an increase of 18 percentage points since the previous survey in 2016.
- 40% of highly educated respondents, including graduates and those with advanced degrees, identify unemployment as the most pressing issue.
- 16% of respondents expressed concerns about poverty.
- 13% highlight inflation as a major challenge.
- Gender plays a role: 42% of males compared to 31% of females see unemployment as their top concern.
- About 49% of the surveyed youth are currently engaged in some form of work.
- Among those working, 23% are self-employed, indicating an entrepreneurial inclination.
- Various sectors are represented: 16% are professionals, 15% are engaged in agriculture, and 27% are skilled or semi-skilled workers.
- Only 6% are employed in government jobs.
- Aspirations and Preferences:
- When considering ideal career paths, 16% of respondents aspire to roles in the health sector.
- 14% prefer jobs in the education sector.
- 10% express interest in science and technology-related roles and entrepreneurship.
- 2% are content with continuing in their current jobs.
- Employment Choices: Government Jobs and Entrepreneurship:
- 60% of respondents favor government jobs, reflecting their consistent appeal over time.
- Over 25% lean toward entrepreneurship, showcasing a growing trend in entrepreneurial ambitions.
The Significance of the Age Bracket Between 15 and 34 for India
- Demographic Powerhouse: The youth aged 15 to 34 constitute a considerable 34% of India’s population, making it a demographic powerhouse. With over 40 crore individuals, their collective influence is significant in determining societal trends, economic patterns, and policy priorities.
- Human Capital Reservoir: This age group forms the core of India’s human capital reservoir. Their energy, creativity, and potential can drive the nation’s progress across various sectors. The report’s insights highlight the youth’s aspirations, which, if harnessed, can contribute to the nation’s growth.
- Agents of Change: As the report suggests, the youth possess a dynamic outlook and are open to exploring diverse career paths. Their adaptability and willingness to embrace new opportunities position them as agents of change, capable of shaping industries and driving innovation.
- Future Workforce: This age range encompasses individuals in different stages of education and employment preparation. Their choices and preferences, as illuminated by the report, offer insights into the future composition of India’s workforce, guiding policy decisions and skill development initiatives.
- Socio-Economic Transformation: The youth’s concerns, such as unemployment and poverty, directly correlate with the socio-economic fabric of the nation. Addressing these challenges is crucial for achieving inclusive growth and elevating the living standards of millions.
- Cultural and Social Trends: The age group between 15 and 34 witnesses the convergence of traditional values and modern aspirations. Understanding their perspectives can aid in shaping cultural and social trends, influencing areas ranging from consumer behavior to family dynamics.
- Global Competitiveness: India’s global competitiveness is intricately linked with the capabilities of its youth. As the report reveals, their interest in sectors like technology and entrepreneurship can position India as a hub for innovation on the global stage.
- Long-Term Implications: Investments made in education, skill development, and employment opportunities for youth can have long-term implications. Nurturing this demographic can result in a more educated, skilled, and capable population, boosting economic growth and societal progress.
Addressing Youth Concerns: A Path Forward
- Targeted Employment Generation: Address the rising concern of unemployment by implementing policies that stimulate job creation across sectors. Encourage public-private partnerships to create diverse and suitable job opportunities for educated youth.
- Inclusive Economic Policies: Formulate and execute inclusive economic policies that uplift marginalized sections of society. Tackling poverty and controlling inflation will directly alleviate concerns among youth from lower economic backgrounds.
- Gender-Responsive Initiatives: Develop gender-specific initiatives to provide equal opportunities for education and employment. Empower young women with skills and education to bridge the gender gap in the job market.
- Education Reforms: Align educational curricula with the aspirations of youth. Promote practical skills alongside traditional academic subjects, enabling them to pursue careers that resonate with their interests.
- Fostering Entrepreneurial Ecosystems: Establish supportive ecosystems for entrepreneurship. Offer mentorship, funding, and regulatory frameworks that encourage young individuals to embark on entrepreneurial ventures.
- Government and Private Sector Collaboration: Foster collaborations between the government and private sector to create a diverse range of job opportunities. Provide stability through government jobs while embracing innovation through private sector growth.
- Youth-Centric Policies: Translate the insights from the report into concrete policies that address the concerns of youth. Regularly review and adapt these policies to ensure they remain relevant and effective.
Conclusion
- The prominence of unemployment as a pressing issue underscores the need for focused efforts to address this concern, especially among educated youth. As the nation strives to harness the potential of its youth population, understanding their viewpoints and preferences becomes essential for shaping policies and initiatives that align with their aspirations and drive sustainable growth.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Three key bills, provisions
Mains level: Reforming criminal justice system
What’s the news?
- Union Home Minister Amit Shah has put forth three significant bills for consideration in the Lok Sabha, aiming to overhaul India’s criminal justice system.
Central idea
- The proposed legislation includes the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita Bill, the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita Bill, and the Bharatiya Sakshya Bill. The introduction of these bills has sparked a spirited debate regarding the necessity of these reforms, the perceived misuse of existing laws, and the potential implications of the proposed amendments.
What is the proposed legislation?
- Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita Bill:
- This bill aims to replace the existing Indian Penal Code (IPC) of 1860.
- The proposed Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita Bill seeks to update and modernize the criminal laws to better reflect evolving societal values and democratic aspirations.
- Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita Bill:
- This bill is intended to supersede the current Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC) of 1973.
- The proposed bill aims to reform these procedures and streamline the criminal justice process.
- This bill aims to replace the Indian Evidence Act of 1872.
- The proposed Bharatiya Sakshya Bill seeks to modernize and adapt these rules to the contemporary legal landscape.
How are the new Bills different from the prevalent laws?
- Indian Penal Code (IPC) Replacement (Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita Bill):
- The existing IPC, enacted in 1860, is considered operational but might not adequately reflect changing values and democratic aspirations.
- The proposed Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita Bill seeks to update the IPC, with amendments to 175 sections, the addition of eight new sections, and the repeal of 22 sections.
- The aim is to align the criminal laws with contemporary socio-economic and political realities.
- Code of Criminal Procedure Replacement (Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita Bill):
- The current Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC) was established in 1973.
- The new Bill introduces significant changes, including extending the period of detention without charges to 90 days.
- New discretionary powers are granted to law enforcement, such as the ‘right to handcuff,’ which was previously uncommon in India.
- The new CrPC introduces provisions that could legitimize encounters and violence during arrests.
- Amendments in the new CrPC appear to move in the opposite direction of global criminal justice jurisprudence by extending detention periods, contrary to shorter periods adopted in other countries.
- Indian Evidence Act Replacement (Bharatiya Sakshya Bill):
- The Indian Evidence Act of 1872 is being replaced by the proposed Bharatiya Sakshya Bill.
- The changes in the evidence law aim to modernize the rules and principles for the admissibility of evidence in court proceedings.
What are the similarities between the existing laws and the new Bills?
- Continuation of Existing Practices:
- The new Bills maintain many existing practices in the current legal framework, endorsing and legitimizing established procedures and norms.
- Detention and Criminal Offenses:
- The new CrPC maintains the practice of detention without charges.
- Both the existing laws and the new Bills address various criminal offenses, albeit with potential changes in definitions and terminology.
- Continued Concerns:
- Both the existing laws and the new Bills raise concerns about the potential misuse and abuse of certain provisions. For instance, concerns are raised about expanded discretionary powers granted to law enforcement as well as potential ambiguities in the new definitions of offenses.
- Gendered Provisions:
- The existing laws and the new Bills both highlight gendered provisions. For example, the new rape provisions are said to be gendered and apply specifically to women, possibly excluding other scenarios.
Concerns raised over the new bills
- Detention Period Extension:
- One of the prominent concerns is the extension of the detention period without charges from the current duration to 90 days in the proposed Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC) Bill.
- This longer detention period raises apprehensions about potential misuse and human rights violations, particularly in cases where individuals may be held without sufficient evidence.
- Discretionary Powers for Law Enforcement:
- The introduction of discretionary powers, such as the ‘right to handcuff,’ to law enforcement officers under the new CrPC raises ethical and practical concerns.
- These discretionary powers might lead to potential misuse, undermining individual rights, and potentially legitimizing violence during arrests.
- Gendered Provisions:
- The gendered nature of certain provisions in the new Bills is a concern. For instance, the new rape provisions apply specifically to women.
- This approach may exclude scenarios involving sexual offenses between men and women and may not adequately address the full range of potential cases.
- Broad Definitions and Ambiguity:
- The broad and vague definitions introduced in the new Bills for offenses like sedition, subversive activities, and terrorist acts are sources of concern.
- These vague definitions can lead to ambiguity in legal interpretations and may potentially infringe on individuals’ rights due to overreach.
- Repeal and Revocation of Sections:
- The complete repeal and revocation of certain sections without retaining core legal principles raises concerns about the continuity of established legal precedents.
- This discontinuity could create confusion and disrupt legal processes, particularly in the transition period.
- Impact on Minority Rights:
- The new Bills, with provisions like the ‘Love Jihad’ offense, raise concerns about their potential impact on minority rights and freedom of choice.
- Such provisions might disproportionately affect certain communities and could be seen as invasive and discriminatory.
- Lack of Public Participation:
- Concerns are voiced over the pace at which the new Bills are being introduced, with experts emphasizing the importance of seeking public input and feedback before making sweeping changes to the legal framework.
- Overarching Disruption:
- The introduction of such comprehensive changes in a relatively short span of time might lead to disruption in the legal system and raise challenges for law enforcement agencies, legal professionals, and the public.
What are the welcome changes in the new Bills?
- Definition of Terrorism and Organized Crime:
- The new Bills introduce a clear definition of terrorism and organized crime, address the evolving nature of criminal activities, and align the legal framework with contemporary challenges.
- Expedited Trial Process:
- The new Bills propose measures to expedite the trial process by setting a limit of 30 days for concluding judgments and allowing only two adjournments.
- These measures aim to prevent unnecessary delays in delivering justice.
- Mob Lynching as a Separate Offense:
- The new Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita Bill defines mob lynching as an offense, underscoring the importance of addressing violence perpetuated by mobs and providing stricter punishment for such crimes.
- Stricter Punishment for Crimes Against Women:
- The new Bills propose stricter punishment for crimes against women, reflecting a commitment to ensuring the safety and well-being of women.
- Petty Offenses and Timely Trials:
- A provision in the new Bills suggests that trials for petty offenses should be concluded within six months; otherwise, the accused will not be tried.
- This provision aims to streamline the legal process and reduce the backlog of cases.
- Recognition of Changing Political and Social Debates:
- The inclusion of offenses like love Jihad and specific provisions related to mob lynching in the new Bills demonstrates an effort to address issues that have emerged in recent political and social debates.
- Organized Crime and Community Service:
- The new Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita Bill introduces provisions related to organized crime and community service, indicating a comprehensive approach to addressing diverse criminal activities and emphasizing societal responsibility.
- Adaptation to Contemporary Needs:
- The proposed changes reflect an effort to modernize the legal framework to align with the evolving socio-economic and political landscape.
Way forward
- Public Participation and Feedback: Open the proposed Bills for public input and discussions to incorporate diverse perspectives, ensuring that the laws are comprehensive and well-rounded.
- Address Concerns and Ambiguities: Carefully address concerns regarding potential misuse, gendered provisions, and ambiguity in definitions to create clear, equitable, and just laws.
- Balancing Rights and Security: Strike a balance between safeguarding individual rights and ensuring law enforcement effectiveness when granting discretionary powers.
- Expert Involvement: Engage legal experts, scholars, and human rights activists to provide insights and ensure a thorough understanding of potential implications.
- Gradual Implementation and Monitoring: Implement proposed changes incrementally to minimize disruptions and establish a robust monitoring system to evaluate their impact and address issues as they arise.
Conclusion
- While updating and adapting laws to changing societal values is required, it is crucial to underline the importance of thoughtful and balanced reforms that safeguard individual rights and prevent misuse. As these Bills continue to garner attention and feedback from the public, legal professionals, and lawmakers, it remains to be seen how these transformative changes will shape the future of India’s legal landscape.
Also read:
IPC is history: In 1837, how Macaulay cracked the code
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Organoid Intelligence and apliactions
Mains level: Organoid Intelligence, applications and ethical concerns
What’s the news?
- By utilizing brain organoids derived from stem cells, Organoid Intelligence (OI) seeks to explore new frontiers in information processing, offering potential breakthroughs in understanding brain functionality, learning, and memory.
Central Idea
- In recent years, Artificial Intelligence (AI) has brought forth remarkable technological advancements. Yet, the realm of cognitive computing is being further extended by Organoid Intelligence (OI), a burgeoning interdisciplinary domain that envisions innovative biocomputing models.
What is an Organoid?
- An organoid is a specialized type of tissue culture that is generated from stem cells and intended to mimic the structure and function of specific organs.
- These three-dimensional structures are cultivated in vitro, or outside the body, under controlled conditions that attempt to recreate the microenvironment of the target organ.
- The term organoid encompasses diverse structures that imitate different organs or tissues.
What is Organoid Intelligence (OI)?
- Organoid Intelligence is an emerging multidisciplinary field that merges the realms of biology and computing to explore the potential of using brain organoids to achieve cognitive capabilities and enhance our understanding of brain function.
- This novel concept envisions harnessing the unique properties of brain organoids, which mimic certain aspects of brain structure and function, to develop biocomputing models that could process information and potentially exhibit rudimentary cognitive abilities.
Potential applications of OI
- Cognitive Computing: Integrating brain organoids and computation for information processing and adaptive learning.
- Disease Modeling and Drug Testing: Using organoids to simulate diseases, test treatments, and study cognitive aspects.
- Understanding Brain Development: Analyzing Organoids to grasp early brain stages and cellular memory processes.
- Personalized Brain Organoids: Tailoring organoids to study genetics, medicine, and cognitive conditions.
- Advantages over Traditional Computing: Exploring organoids’ capabilities for intricate data tasks and energy-efficient processing.
- Biocomputers and Energy Efficiency: Developing faster, greener biocomputers with brain organoids.
- Ethical Considerations: Addressing ethical concerns like informed consent, gene editing rules, and inclusive access.
- Sustainable Alternatives: Offering eco-friendly options for intensive cognitive tasks and learning, amidst technology advancement.
Case Study: DishBrain System Experiment
- The DishBrain system stands as a compelling case study illustrating the application of Organoid Intelligence (OI). This innovative experiment, led by a team of researchers from Cortical Labs in Melbourne, demonstrates the integration of brain organoids with computational systems to achieve rudimentary cognitive capabilities.
- Experiment Overview:
- Brain Organoid Culturing: The researchers cultivated brain organoids, which are complex three-dimensional structures derived from stem cells. These organoids simulate certain aspects of brain development and function.
- In Silico Integration: Brain organoids were interfaced with computational simulations and algorithms through in silico computing. This integration aimed to enable enhanced neural processing and cognitive functions.
- Gameplay: Pong’: The brain organoids were trained to engage in the classic video game Pong. They were programmed to respond to key in-game variables, such as the movement of the virtual ball.
- Learning Mechanism: When the brain organoids failed to respond correctly in the game, the system provided feedback in the form of electrical pulses. This approach mimics the concept of reinforcement learning observed in living organisms.
- Application of the Free-Energy Principle: In the absence of real-time incentive systems like dopamine pathways, the researchers employed the free-energy principle. This principle suggests that living systems strive to minimize unpredictability. Brain organoids adapted their behavior to make the game environment more predictable.
- Key Outcomes: Within an astonishingly short span of five minutes, the brain organoids demonstrated signs of learning in response to the game stimuli. The utilization of the free-energy principle showcased the potential to guide the behavior of brain organoids using computational principles, driving them toward predictable responses.
Challenges and ethical considerations associated with Organoid Intelligence
- Challenges:
- Technological Advancements: Scaling up brain organoids and enhancing their cognitive capacities pose significant technical hurdles. Developing more sophisticated blood flow systems and introducing diverse cell types are among the challenges.
- Complexity of Learning: Despite promising results, achieving advanced cognitive capabilities in brain organoids remains a complex task. Imitating the intricacies of learning and memory seen in human brains is a challenge that requires further research.
- Gap in Knowledge: There are aspects of OI technology that are yet to be fully understood and developed. This includes improving memory storage mechanisms within brain organoids to enable more complex cognitive functions.
- Ethical Considerations:
- Informed Consent: Obtaining voluntary informed consent for cell donation is crucial to upholding donors’ rights and dignity.
- Selection Bias and Discrimination: Preventing selection biases during organoid development is essential to avoid potential discrimination risks and ensure neurodiversity.
- Gene Editing Regulations: Balancing commercial interests with ethical gene editing regulations is necessary to ensure the responsible and ethical culturing of brain organoids.
- Data Sharing and Open Access: Ensuring data sharing and open access to OI technology promotes inclusivity and diverse knowledge generation.
- Stakeholder-Informed Regulations: Developing regulations for the ethical use of OI technology requires stakeholder input to ensure responsible applications.
- Consciousness and Suffering Concerns: Ethical concerns range from the potential consciousness of brain organoids to addressing the possibility of suffering in these bioengineered systems.
Technological Advancements and Future Prospects
- Scaling up brain organoids, introducing diverse cell types, and enhancing memory storage are essential steps for augmenting OI’s cognitive potential.
- A 100-fold increase in the number of cells could yield complex cognitive capabilities, necessitating innovations in blood flow systems and cell diversity incorporation.
- The rudimentary success of DishBrain’s Pong experiment signifies the journey towards intelligence through OI.
- Although complete realization is distant, the limitations of current AI and silicon technologies in complex cognition, learning, and energy efficiency emphasize the urgency to explore sustainable alternatives.
Conclusion
- Through brain organoids, researchers are poised to unlock an unprecedented understanding of cognitive processes and revolutionize the ways we approach learning, memory, and neurological disorders. As OI advances, navigating ethical considerations and embracing technological innovations will be pivotal in ensuring a responsible and impactful journey toward an era of more sustainable and intelligent computing solutions.
Also read:
AI to improve maternal and child health in India
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now