Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: na
Mains level: recurring floods in Chennai
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Hindutva Rate of Growth
Mains level: Read the attached story
Central Idea
- A popular orator and a Parliamentarian, introduced the term “Hindutva rate of GDP growth” during the discussion.
- This term is distinct from the ‘Hindu rate of growth’, a phrase coined by economist Raj Krishna in 1982 to describe India’s modest growth rate of 3.5%.
Understanding the ‘Hindutva Rate of Growth’
- Argument: The MP attributed India’s recent economic growth, including a 6.3% GDP growth rate, to the policies of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, aligning spending with ‘Dharma (the order)’.
- Historical and Religious Context: He linked economic transformations to key events in India’s history, including the Ram Temple movement and the Supreme Court’s Babri Masjid judgment.
Comparative Analysis of Growth Rates
- Per Capita Income Disparity: Despite high GDP growth rates, India’s per capita income remains low compared to developed countries.
- Post-Covid Growth Calculation: 7.8% ‘Hindutva rate of growth’ refers to the average GDP growth post-Covid, excluding the year of the pandemic.
- Comparison with ‘Hindu Rate of Growth’: Including the Covid year in calculations, the growth rate closely resembles the criticized ‘Hindu rate of growth’.
Economic Growth during Different Governments
- Growth under Modi vs. UPA: The average GDP growth rate under PM Modi is 5.8%, compared to 6.8% under the Congress-led UPA.
- Impact of Global Crises: Both governments faced major global crises, with the UPA dealing with the Global Financial Crisis and the Modi government facing the Covid-19 pandemic.
- Historical Growth Trends: Comparing growth rates across different eras, including PM Vajpayee’s and PM Narasimha Rao’s tenures, provides a broader perspective on India’s economic trajectory.
Conclusion
- Similarity to Historical Growth Rates: The ‘Hindutva rate of growth’ closely aligns with historical growth rates, challenging its portrayal as a significant departure from the past.
- Electoral Implications: The discussion raises questions about the role of economic performance in India’s electoral politics, especially in the context of the BJP’s focus on ‘Hindutva’.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Tear Gas Canisters
Mains level: critical lapses in security
Central idea
The breach of India’s Parliament, a symbol of democratic strength, on the anniversary of the 2001 attack reveals critical lapses in security, prompting a high-level inquiry. This collective failure of intelligence agencies underscores the need for thorough investigations, corrective measures, and strengthened security protocols to prevent recurring breaches and uphold the sanctity of parliamentary institutions.
Key Highlights:
- Fortress Breached: The Parliament building in India, known for its security, faces a significant breach, exposing flaws in the robust system.
- Anniversary Irony: The intrusion occurs on the anniversary of the 2001 Parliament attack, questioning the preparedness of security agencies.
- High-Level Inquiry: The government initiates an inquiry to identify lapses and rectify security vulnerabilities.
Key Challenges:
- Collective Security Failure: The breach underscores a failure of intelligence and security agencies responsible for safeguarding Parliament.
- Questionable Access: Intruders obtained an entry pass signed by an MP, raising concerns about verification processes.
- Efficacy of Corrective Measures: Doubts arise about the effectiveness of measures to prevent recurrent security breaches.
Key Terms:
- Security Blanket: Enhanced security measures implemented in a specific area.
- Inquiry Committee: A high-level committee formed to investigate the breach and recommend improvements.
- Tear Gas Canisters: Devices used for dispersing tear gas, hidden by intruders during the breach.
Key Phrases:
- “Temple of our Democracy”: Symbolic reference to the Parliament building as a stronghold of India’s democratic strength.
- “Sanctum Sanctorum of India’s Democracy”: Describing the innermost and most sacred area of the Parliament.
Key Quotes:
- “How did a breach occur again? This is the main question. Those responsible should be punished.” – The author, a retired director general of Police.
- “The incident happened on the very day on which the dreadful Parliament attacks took place 22 years ago.” – The article highlighting the irony of the timing.
Key Examples and References:
- Arrests Made: Four individuals, including one with an entry pass signed by an MP, are arrested in connection with the breach.
- Historical Comparison: Drawing parallels with the 2001 Parliament attack to emphasize the breach’s significance.
Key Statements:
- “Egg on the Face”: The breach is described as an embarrassment to the security establishment, questioning overall preparedness.
- “Collective Failure”: The incident is considered a collective failure of intelligence agencies, police, and security agencies responsible for Parliament security.
Key Facts:
- Enhanced Security: The new Parliament building, inaugurated earlier in the year, is believed to be more secure than its predecessor.
- Timely Breach: Occurred on the day Parliament paid tributes to the martyrs of the 2001 Parliament attack.
Key Data:
- Total Arrests: Four individuals are arrested in connection with the breach.
Critical Analysis:
- Security Vulnerabilities: The breach raises concerns about the ability to prevent intrusions into highly secure areas.
- Symbolic Timing: The timing on the anniversary adds symbolic weight to the security lapse, emphasizing the need for improvement.
Way Forward:
- Thorough Investigation: A comprehensive inquiry is essential to identify lapses and implement corrective measures.
- Strengthen Security Protocols: Stricter verification processes for entry passes and enhanced security measures are crucial for preventing future breaches.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: NA
Mains level: Outcome of the Rusisan Invasion of Ukraine
Central Idea
- It has been six months since Ukraine launched its counteroffensive against Russian forces.
- Despite initial expectations, Ukraine has failed to achieve significant advancements on the battlefield.
- President Zelensky is actively touring Western capitals, including Washington, to secure ongoing military assistance.
Ukraine’s Counteroffensive: Progress and Challenges
- Initial Strategy and Targets: The counteroffensive focused on three fronts, aiming to disrupt Russia’s land bridge to Crimea and make gains in the south and east.
- Challenges in Advancement: Despite receiving advanced weaponry and training from Western allies, Ukrainian forces struggled against Russia’s fortified defenses, particularly in the south.
- Setbacks and Losses: Ukrainian advances were hindered by minefields, electronic warfare, and lack of air power, leading to significant losses and little change in the frontline.
Russia’s Current Position in the War
- Recovery and Defense Building: After initial retreats, Russia has fortified its defensive positions and is on the offensive in certain areas like Avdiivka.
- Mobilization and Military Production: Russia has mobilized additional troops and ramped up its military production, countering Western sanctions and supply challenges.
- Economic Stability Despite Sanctions: Despite Western sanctions, Russia has managed to maintain economic stability by diversifying its energy trade, particularly with China and India.
Waning Western Support for Ukraine
- Shift in U.S. and EU Stance: There are indications that the U.S. and EU might be encouraging Ukraine to initiate talks with Russia.
- Political and Financial Challenges: In the U.S., Republican opposition and declining public support are affecting aid to Ukraine, with potential implications for the 2024 presidential elections.
- Uncertainty Over Continued Aid: The future of Western support is uncertain, especially if Ukraine fails to achieve significant military successes.
Future Outlook: No End to the Conflict in Sight
- Putin’s Stance on Peace Talks: Russian President Vladimir Putin has expressed no urgency in peace talks, focusing instead on achieving Russia’s objectives.
- Ukraine’s Position on Negotiations: Ukraine, similarly, is not considering negotiations at the moment.
- Potential Strategies and Challenges Ahead: As winter sets in, the conflict is expected to see a temporary freeze in frontline movements, with both sides possibly preparing for future offensives and counteroffensives.
Conclusion
- Continued Dependence on Western Aid: Ukraine’s prospects in the conflict remain heavily reliant on sustained Western military and financial support.
- Uncertain Future for Ukraine: The ongoing war, coupled with geopolitical and economic dynamics, leaves Ukraine in a precarious position as it navigates a complex and evolving conflict landscape.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Sri Krishna Janmabhoomi
Mains level: Read the attached story
Central Idea
- On December 14, the Allahabad High Court allowed an application for the inspection of the Shahi Idgah mosque complex, reigniting the Sri Krishna Janmabhoomi-Shahi Idgah Masjid dispute.
- Hindu petitioners assert that the mosque, constructed by Emperor Aurangzeb in 1670, was built over Lord Krishna’s birthplace in Mathura. The mosque is adjacent to the Krishna Janmasthal Temple, a significant pilgrimage site.
Sri Krishna Janmabhoomi: Latest Legal Plea
- Nature of the Application: The application is part of a petition initiated by eight individuals including the “next friend” of Bhagwan Shree Krishna Virajman.
- Survey Approval: Allahabad High Court approved the survey of the Shahi Idgah mosque on December 14.
- Petition’s Demands: The petitioners seek the removal of structures allegedly encroaching on the disputed land by the UP Sunni Central Waqf Board and the mosque committee, and the transfer of this land to the Shree Krishna Janmbhoomi Trust.
- Challenge to the 1968 Agreement: The plea contests the legality of a compromise agreement dated October 12, 1968, between the Shri Krishna Janmasthan Seva Sansthan and the Trust Shahi Masjid Idgah.
Historical Background and Claims
- Aurangzeb’s Alleged Demolition: The Hindu petition cites historical records, claiming Aurangzeb ordered the demolition of Hindu temples, including one at Lord Krishna’s birthplace, to construct the Idgah Mosque in 1669-70.
- Reference to Official Records: The petition mentions the Official Court Bulletin (Akhbaraat) from January to February 1670 as evidence of Aurangzeb’s orders.
Counterclaims by the Muslim Side
- Legal Arguments: Representatives of the UP Sunni Central Waqf Board and the mosque committee argue in the High Court that the mosque does not fall within the disputed 13.37 acres and dispute the location of Krishna’s birthplace.
- Challenging the Hindu Claims: They assert that the Hindu claims are based on speculation and lack documentary evidence.
Historical Ownership and Management
- Land Ownership Changes: The site, originally nazul land, was auctioned by the East India Company in 1815 to Raja Patni Mal of Benaras.
- Subsequent Transactions: The land was later sold to Jugal Kishore Birla, and the ownership rights were transferred to the Shri Krishna Janmabhoomi Trust, established by Birla.
- Temple Management: In 1956, the Shri Krishna Janmasthan Sewa Sangh, later renamed as Sansthan, was established for temple management.
Parallel with the Gyanvapi Case
- Similar Legal Proceedings: The Mathura case is comparable to the Gyanvapi Mosque dispute in Varanasi, where a court-ordered survey led to the discovery of a structure claimed as a “shivling” by Hindus and a “fountain” by Muslims.
- Archaeological Surveys and Legal Challenges: The Varanasi district court’s order for a scientific survey of the Gyanvapi mosque and the subsequent legal hurdles reflect similar developments in the Mathura case.
Conclusion
- Continuation of Legal Battles: The dispute, rooted in deep historical and religious significance, continues to unfold through legal channels.
- Broader Implications: These cases underscore the complexities of addressing historical claims, legal processes, and maintaining communal harmony in the context of religiously significant sites in India.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: AI
Mains level: awareness and critical evaluation of information in the age of AI and deep fakes
Central idea
The article explores the evolving concept of authenticity in the context of AI, deep fakes, and post-truths, highlighting the challenges of discerning between real and fake information. It emphasizes concerns about declining trust in a potential “post-authentic” era and advocates for increased awareness, technological solutions, and ethical AI use to safeguard societal norms and integrity.
Key Highlights:
- Merriam-Webster’s word of the year for 2023 is “authentic,” following the 2022 choice of “gaslighting.”
- The article explores the evolving concept of authenticity in the context of AI, deep fakes, and post-truths.
- The rise of AI-generated content poses challenges to distinguishing between real and fake, impacting trust and societal norms.
Key Challenges:
- The prevalence of deep fakes and AI-generated content challenges the authenticity of information, leading to a blurred line between truth and falsehood.
- The post-authentic era raises concerns about the potential misuse of AI in creating deceptive narratives, impacting trust in various fields, including journalism and research.
- The article questions whether we are entering an era of “post-authenticity,” marked by a decline in trust and a growing inability to take information at face value.
Key Terms:
- Deep Fakes: Realistic-looking audio, video, or textual content generated by artificial intelligence.
- Post-Truth Era: A period characterized by the prioritization of emotional or personal beliefs over objective facts.
- Infocalypse: The potential information and communications crisis in the age of AI and social media.
Key Phrases:
- “To thine own self be true.”
- “Post-authentic age”
- “Trust No One”
- “Infocalypse”
- “Liar’s dividend”
Key Quotes:
- “When we question authenticity, we value it even more.” – Merriam-Webster
- “Trust No One” – Journalist Michael Grothaus
- “Infocalypse,” the biggest information and communications crisis in world history, is imminent.” – AI scientist Nina Schick
Key Examples and References:
- Instances of AI-generated content, including deep fakes of well-known personalities and manipulated images of public figures.
- The fake news incident regarding Amartya Sen’s passing in October.
Key Statements:
- The article suggests that the rise of AI and social media may lead to a “post-authentic” era, where trust becomes a casualty.
- The concept of “Trust No One” is highlighted as a potential consequence of the evolving technological landscape.
Key Facts:
- Merriam-Webster’s word of the year for 2023 is “authentic.”
- Concerns are raised about the impact of AI on the integrity of data and text in various societal aspects, such as GDP, employment, and COVID-19 statistics.
Critical Analysis:
- The article critically examines the challenges posed by AI and post-truth dynamics to the notion of authenticity, emphasizing the potential consequences for trust in society.
- Hazy lines between truth and falsehood are highlighted as a significant issue in the post-authentic era.
Way Forward:
- Emphasize the need for increased awareness and critical evaluation of information in the age of AI and deep fakes.
- Advocate for the development and implementation of technologies to detect and counter AI-generated deceptive content.
- Promote a culture of transparency and ethical use of AI to mitigate the potential negative impacts on trust and authenticity.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: na
Mains level: broader ethical concerns raised by Moitra's allegations to maintain the credibility of Parliament
Key Highlights:
- Mahua Moitra, a former investment banker turned politician, faced allegations of sharing her Parliament ID and password with an industrialist to post questions about a rival group.
- The Ethics Committee recommended her expulsion from Parliament, and on December 8, the motion for expulsion was adopted through a voice vote.
- Moitra admitted to sharing her ID and password, receiving gifts, and made broader allegations that many MPs do not draft their own questions.
Key Challenges:
- The credibility of Parliament is at stake due to false claims by Moitra and another MP, Giridhari Yadav, that MPs generally do not frame their own questions.
- The issue of MPs sharing their ID and password, a violation of rules, raises concerns about the security and integrity of parliamentary processes.
- The definition of “cash for query” is debated, involving considerations of gifts, hospitality, and other non-monetary benefits.
Key Terms:
- Parliament Portal: The online platform where MPs submit questions, Zero Hour submissions, and Special Mentions.
- Ethics Committee: A parliamentary committee responsible for examining matters related to the ethical conduct of MPs.
- Cash for Query: The alleged practice of accepting material benefits in exchange for asking questions in Parliament.
Key Phrases:
- “Cash for query”
- “Parliamentary question”
- “Expulsion from Parliament”
- “Ethics Committee”
- “ID and password sharing”
- “Motion for expulsion”
- “Voice vote”
Key Quotes:
- Giridhari Yadav: “Even I do not remember my password. My PA knows it. I have not asked any questions, thinking God knows what will happen.”
- Speaker’s Response: “I request all MPs to frame their questions themselves and put it up. No one else is allowed to do that.”
Key Examples and References:
- Mahua Moitra’s admission to sharing her ID and password, receiving gifts, and the subsequent recommendation for expulsion by the Ethics Committee.
- Giridhari Yadav’s statement about not framing his own questions and relying on his PA.
Key Statements:
- Sharing ID and password with an outsider is a gross violation of parliamentary rules.
- Moitra’s confession and broader allegations cast doubt on the autonomy of MPs in drafting their questions.
Key Facts:
- Moitra graduated from Mount Holyoke College, worked as an investment banker, and joined politics with stints in the Indian National Congress and Trinamool Congress.
- The motion for expulsion was adopted through a voice vote after the Opposition walked out of Parliament.
Key Data:
- Date of Mahua Moitra’s expulsion: December 8
- Number of questions MPs are allowed to submit: Five (two starred and three unstarred).
Critical Analysis:
- False claims about MPs not framing their own questions undermine the reputation of Parliament.
- The issue of ID and password sharing raises questions about the security of parliamentary processes.
- The definition of “cash for query” is explored, considering various non-monetary benefits.
Way Forward:
- Strengthen security measures to prevent unauthorized access to parliamentary portals.
- Emphasize the importance of MPs independently framing their questions for the integrity of parliamentary proceedings.
- Address the broader ethical concerns raised by Moitra’s allegations to maintain the credibility of Parliament.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Loss and Damage Fund (LDF)
Mains level: global climate justice movements
Key Highlights:
- Shift in Focus: COP28 saw a historic shift as all 198 signatories agreed to “transition away” from all fossil fuels, moving beyond the earlier emphasis on coal.
- India’s Role: India played a crucial role in modifying language at COP26 and supported the UAE Consensus at COP28, signaling a departure from coal-centric agreements.
Key Challenges:
- Loopholes and Criticism: The COP28 outcome faced criticism for not achieving a complete fossil fuel phase-out, with concerns about loopholes such as nuclear abatement and carbon capture.
- Developing Country Struggles: Developing countries, lacking expertise, face challenges in effectively de-carbonizing sectors and raising ambition due to financial constraints.
Key Terms:
- COP28: The 28th United Nations’ Conference of the Parties.
- UAE Consensus: The agreement to transition away from fossil fuels in a just, orderly, and equitable manner.
- Loss and Damage Fund (LDF): Operationalized at COP28, the fund addresses climate impacts but currently falls short in funding.
Key Phrases:
- “Transitioning away from fossil fuels in a just, orderly, and equitable manner.”
- “Compromise after 30 years” regarding the LDF funding.
- “Deep, rapid, and sustained reductions in greenhouse gas emissions.”
Key Quotes:
- Harjeet Singh: “The outcomes have been unprecedented and historic.”
- Karthik Ganesan: “It’s a maze of words. What is clear is that subsidies for fossil fuels must go.”
Key Statements:
- Developing countries insist on technology transfer and removal of trade barriers for effective renewable energy transition.
- India faces a dilemma in balancing economic growth, environmental concerns, and contributions to global climate initiatives.
Key Examples and References:
- India’s role in modifying language at COP26 and supporting the UAE Consensus at COP28.
- Comparison of the economic value of coal and solar sectors in India.
Key Facts and Data:
- The LDF has raised $700 million, falling short of the trillions needed to address climate impacts.
- India is the third-largest emitter of greenhouse gases with a significantly smaller per capita emission rate.
Critical Analysis:
- The COP28 outcome is criticized for loopholes and a lack of ambition, emphasizing the need for a balance between economic growth and environmental concerns.
- The dichotomy of India’s role as a regional power, emerging economy, and its responsibility to contribute to global climate initiatives is highlighted.
Way Forward:
- Developing countries must focus on technology transfer and removing trade barriers for effective renewable energy transition.
- India needs to reassess its economic paradigm, prioritizing environmental concerns and adopting a sustainable growth model.
- Continued engagement, contribution, and learning from large countries like India are essential for global climate justice movements.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Indian Forest and Wood Certification Scheme
Mains level: Not Much
Central Idea
- The Ministry of Environment, Forests and Climate Change has introduced the Indian Forest & Wood Certification Scheme to promote sustainable management of forests and trees outside forests.
Understanding Forest Certification
- Definition: Forest certification is a process for evaluating the quality of timber, wood, pulp products, and non-timber forest products against set standards.
- Purpose: It ensures that forest products are sourced from responsibly managed forests or recycled materials.
Forest and Wood Certification Scheme
- Voluntary Certification: The scheme offers voluntary third-party certification to encourage sustainable forest management and agroforestry.
- Certification Types: Includes Forest Management Certificates, Trees outside Forest Management Certificate, and chain of custody certification.
- Standards: The Forest Management certification is based on the Indian Forest Management Standard, which includes 8 criteria, 69 indicators, and 254 verifiers.
Implementation and Oversight
- Scheme Operating Agency: The Indian Institute of Forest Management, Bhopal, will manage the scheme.
- Accreditation Body: The Quality Council of India will accredit certification bodies to assess adherence to the standards.
- Advisory Council: The Indian Forest and Wood Certification Council, comprising members from various eminent institutions and ministries, will oversee the scheme.
Significance of Forest Certification
- Buyer Assurance: Helps buyers identify products sourced from well-managed forests or recycled materials.
- Discouraging Illegal Sources: Aims to reduce the use of supplies from illegal sources.
- Holistic Benefits: Ensures that forest activities contribute to environmental, social, and economic benefits.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Saiga Antelope
Mains level: NA
Central Idea
- The Saiga Antelope has been reclassified from ‘Critically Endangered’ to ‘Near Threatened’ by the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN).
About Saiga Antelope
|
Details |
| Scientific Name |
Saiga tatarica |
| Physical Characteristics |
Notable for its distinctive bulbous nose; relatively small, with a thin build and long, thin legs |
| Habitat |
Primarily found in the steppe region of Central Asia and Eastern Europe |
| Population Distribution |
Predominantly in Kazakhstan and Russia, with smaller populations in Uzbekistan, Turkmenistan, and Mongolia |
| Conservation Status |
IUCN Red List: Near Threatened
CITES: Appendix II |
| Major Threats |
Poaching for horns (used in traditional medicine), habitat loss, and disease outbreaks like pasteurellosis |
| Diet |
Herbivorous, feeding on a variety of grasses and plants |
| Breeding |
Known for its rapid population growth under favorable conditions; breeds in large herds |
| Migration |
Notable for long-distance seasonal migrations |
| Cultural Significance |
Featured in the folklore and culture of the local steppe communities |
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Goods and Services Tax (GST)
Mains level: Read the attached story
Central Idea
- The government has revived its focus on Goods and Services Tax (GST) rate rationalization by reconstituting the ministerial group of the GST Council.
About Goods and Services Tax (GST)
- Launch and Purpose: GST, implemented on 1 July 2017, is a comprehensive indirect tax across India, replacing multiple cascading taxes levied by the central and state governments.
- Consumption-Based Tax: It is charged at the point of supply and is based on the destination of consumption, benefiting the state where the goods or services are consumed.
GST Slabs and Their Distribution
- Tax Slabs: GST in India is categorized into five main slabs: 0%, 5%, 12%, 18%, and 28%, with an additional cess on certain luxury and ‘sin’ goods.
- Product and Service Coverage: The GST system covers over 1300 products and 500+ services, categorized under these slabs.
- Periodic Revision: The GST Council revises the slab rates periodically, ensuring essential items are taxed lower, while luxury items attract higher rates.
- 28% Slab and Cess: The highest slab of 28% is reserved for demerit goods like tobacco and luxury automobiles, with an additional cess for revenue generation.
Issues with the Current GST Structure
- Complexity: The multi-slab structure and varying rates lead to confusion and increased compliance costs for businesses.
- Rate Heterogeneity: Diverse rates across different goods and services complicate the tax system.
- Dual GST System: The coexistence of CGST and SGST adds to the complexity and compliance burden.
- Cascading Effect: Despite being a value-added tax, GST sometimes leads to cascading taxation, increasing the cost of goods and services.
- Lack of Transparency: Invoicing under GST often lacks clarity on tax breakdown, affecting consumer awareness.
- Collection Infrastructure: Inadequate infrastructure for GST collection leads to administrative challenges and delays.
Rationale behind GST Rationalization
- Simplifying Tax Structure: Reducing the number of slabs can simplify the tax system, making it easier for businesses to comply.
- Addressing Aberrations: Rationalization can correct anomalies where inputs are taxed higher than final products.
- Revenue Concerns: Merging slabs like 12% and 18% could lead to revenue loss, necessitating careful consideration.
Benefits of GST Rationalization
- Easier Compliance: A simplified GST structure would ease the compliance burden on businesses.
- Equitable Tax Distribution: Rationalization ensures a fair distribution of tax burden and efficient use of revenue.
- Improved Tax Collection: Streamlining GST slabs can lead to more efficient tax collection and reduced compliance costs.
Conclusion
- Need for Reform: Rationalizing GST rates is crucial for enhancing the efficiency of the tax regime.
- Expected Outcomes: A reformed GST system is anticipated to be simpler, leading to easier compliance, better revenue collection, and overall efficiency in the taxation system.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: COP28
Mains level: CCS and CCD
Central Idea
- At the COP28 climate talks in Dubai, discussions have centered on carbon capture and storage (CCS) and carbon-dioxide removal (CDR) technologies.
- The interpretation of ‘abatement’ is crucial in understanding the role and limitations of CCS and CDR in climate action.
Understanding CCS and CDR
- CCS: This involves capturing CO₂ emissions at their source, such as in the fossil fuel industry and industrial processes, and storing them to prevent atmospheric release.
- CDR: Encompasses natural methods like afforestation and technological approaches like direct air capture for absorbing and storing atmospheric CO₂.
- COP28 Discussions: The term “unabated fossil fuels” in the draft texts refers to fossil fuel combustion without CCS. The texts advocate phasing out such fuels and enhancing emission removal technologies.
Scale and Efficacy of CCS and CDR
- IPCC’s AR6 Report: Heavily reliant on CDR for meeting the 1.5 degrees C temperature limit, assuming significant CO₂ sequestration by 2040.
- Challenges: Direct mitigation to reduce emissions is daunting, making CDR crucial.
- CCS Limitations: Effective CCS requires high capture rates, permanent storage, and minimal methane leakage from upstream processes.
Concerns and Implications of CCS and CDR
- Land Use for CDR: Large-scale CDR methods, especially technological ones, require significant land, raising equity, biodiversity, and food security concerns.
- Impact on the Global South: CDR projects in the Global South could infringe on indigenous land rights and compete with agricultural land use.
- Financial and Ethical Questions: The cost and responsibility of implementing CDR at scale raise questions about who should bear these burdens.
Pitfalls of CCS and CDR
- Potential for Increased Emissions: CCS and CDR could inadvertently create leeway for continued or increased greenhouse gas emissions.
- IPCC Emission Scenarios: To limit warming to 1.5 degrees C, significant reductions in coal, oil, and gas use are required by 2050, with or without CCS.
- Gas Emissions Pathways: Higher reliance on CCS and CDR could lead to emission pathways with a greater contribution from gas.
Conclusion
- Critical Decade Ahead: The next decade is pivotal in determining the viability and scalability of CDR methods.
- Balancing Act: While CCS and CDR offer potential solutions for emission reduction, their implementation must be carefully managed to avoid unintended consequences and ensure equitable and effective climate action.
- Future of Climate Negotiations: The discussions and decisions at COP28 regarding CCS and CDR will significantly influence the trajectory of global climate action and the pursuit of the 1.5 degrees C target.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Bhagat Singh
Mains level: Read the attached story
Central Idea
- A serious security breach occurred in the Indian Parliament when two individuals jumped into the Lok Sabha chamber, releasing yellow smoke.
- Police sources indicated that the act, involving a total of six individuals, was apparently inspired by the revolutionary Bhagat Singh.
Bhagat Singh’s Historic Act in 1929
- Central Assembly Incident: Over 94 years ago, Bhagat Singh, along with Batukeshwar Dutt, threw bombs and pamphlets in Delhi’s Central Assembly, challenging the British Empire.
- Objective: Their act was not aimed at causing harm but to protest against the lack of autonomy under the Montague-Chelmsford Reforms and to voice against repressive measures.
1929 ‘Indian Parliament’ and Revolutionary Motives
- Political Climate: The period saw Indian nationalists dissatisfied with the limited power under British rule, leading to revolutionary movements.
- HSRA’s Stance: The Hindustan Socialist Republican Army (HSRA), led by Chandrashekhar Azad and involving Bhagat Singh, sought to oppose the facade of an Indian Parliament run by the British.
- Pamphlet’s Message: The HSRA aimed to ‘make the deaf hear’, using their act as a symbolic protest against the British administration.
Fateful Day: April 8, 1929
- Viceroy’s Proclamation: The incident coincided with the Viceroy’s enactment of controversial bills, despite opposition in the Assembly.
- Well-Planned Action: Bhagat Singh and Dutt conducted reconnaissance and executed their plan while dressed in khaki, throwing bombs and pamphlets into the Assembly.
- Immediate Arrest: Following their slogan-shouting and bomb-throwing, both revolutionaries were arrested as per their plan.
Aftermath: Trial and Sentencing
- Response to Criticism: Bhagat Singh and Dutt defended their actions, emphasizing the sanctity of human life and the moral justification of their cause.
- Trial and Sentencing: A month later, both were sentenced to life imprisonment. Bhagat Singh later faced additional charges leading to his execution in 1931.
Conclusion
- Echoes of History: The recent security breach in the Lok Sabha, inspired by Bhagat Singh’s act, reflects a continued legacy of protest in India.
- Legacy of Bhagat Singh: The incident serves as a reminder of Bhagat Singh’s enduring influence in Indian history, symbolizing resistance and the fight for justice.
- Contemporary Relevance: While the motives of the recent perpetrators are still under investigation, their actions highlight ongoing issues in India, from regional concerns to farmers’ rights, resonating with Bhagat Singh’s revolutionary spirit.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Dubai Consensus , COP 28
Mains level: Read the attached story
Central Idea
- The Dubai Consensus, a significant resolution towards reducing fossil fuel dependency, was adopted in COP 28, Dubai.
Dubai Consensus
- Key Clause: The resolution emphasizes transitioning away from fossil fuels to achieve net-zero emissions by 2050, aligning with scientific recommendations to limit global temperature rise.
- Balance between Countries: The text reflects a compromise between developed and developing nations on climate action and responsibility.
- Dilution of Language: Earlier drafts with terms like ‘phase-out’ were softened due to opposition from oil-dependent countries.
- Coal Usage: The final text moderated its stance on coal, crucial for countries like India, calling for a phase-down rather than a rapid phase-out.
- Methane Emissions: The consensus introduces a focus on reducing methane emissions by 2030, a potent greenhouse gas.
- Natural Gas as a ‘Transition Fuel’: The text’s reference to natural gas as a transitional fuel could favor gas-producing countries and overlook the need for developed countries to close the finance gap in climate adaptation.
New Funding Commitments and Future Goals
- Diverse Opinions: While some nations expressed dissatisfaction with the agreement’s scope, others highlighted the lack of financial support for developing countries.
- Financial Pledges: COP 28 saw commitments to the Loss and Damage Fund and pledges to decarbonize the global economy.
- Focus on Renewable Energy: The resolution signals a move towards phasing out fossil fuels and boosting renewable energy and efficiency.
India’s Historical Position on Climate Change
- Emission Statistics: India, a major developing country, has historically contributed 3% of greenhouse gases (1850-2019), compared to higher percentages from the US and EU.
- Per Capita Emissions: India’s per capita emissions are below the global average, but its development needs and population growth have made it the third-largest emitter.
- Balancing Development and Emissions: India has been navigating the pressure to reduce emissions while addressing its developmental needs, particularly its reliance on coal.
India’s Commitments and Challenges
- Net Zero by 2070: India has committed to achieving a net-zero state by 2070, alongside expanding its renewable energy capacity.
- Glasgow COP 2021 Agreement: Under pressure, India agreed to a ‘phase-down’ of coal use, highlighting the need for equitable treatment of all fossil fuels, including oil and gas.
- Import Dependency: As a net importer of oil and gas, India has raised concerns about the focus on coal while other fossil fuels remain under-addressed.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Countervailing Duties (CVDs), RODTEP Scheme
Mains level: Read the attached story
Central Idea
- The US and the European Union have imposed countervailing duties (CVDs) on select Indian products such as paper file folders, common alloy aluminum sheet, and forged steel fluid end blocks.
- These measures are in retaliation against India’s Remission of Duties and Taxes on Export Products (RoDTEP) scheme, initiated in January 2021.
About Countervailing Duties (CVDs)
|
Details |
| Definition |
Tariffs imposed to neutralize the adverse effects of subsidies provided by a foreign government to their export industries. |
| Purpose |
To protect domestic industries from unfair competition due to imports subsidized by the exporting country’s government. |
| Investigation & Imposition |
Requires a domestic investigation to confirm the presence of subsidies and their impact on domestic industries. |
| WTO Compliance |
Imposition of CVDs must comply with World Trade Organization rules. |
| Types of Subsidies |
Includes direct transfers of funds, tax concessions, loan guarantees, and provision of goods/services at a discount. |
| Calculation |
The duty amount is typically equivalent to the value of the foreign subsidy. |
| Duration |
Not permanent; imposed for a specific period and subject to review and removal. |
| Global Use |
Frequently used by countries like the United States, European Union, Canada, and India. |
| Controversy and Disputes |
Can lead to trade disputes, viewed by some as protectionist or unjustified. |
| Impact on Prices |
May result in higher prices for affected goods in the importing country due to increased import costs. |
India’s Response to the Duties
- Government and Exporters’ Defense: The Indian government and affected exporters have actively defended against the subsidy allegations. Their defense covered various programs and schemes at both the Central and State levels in India.
- Method of Defense: The defense was presented through written and oral responses during the investigations.
Potential WTO Dispute
- India’s Stance on Dispute Resolution: Minister of State for Commerce and Industry indicated India’s openness to bilateral resolution.
- WTO Dispute Settlement Mechanism: Any party could approach the WTO Dispute Settlement mechanism if they believe a WTO member has adopted measures inconsistent with WTO agreements.
Conclusion
- Growing Trade Tensions: The imposition of CVDs by the US and EU signifies escalating trade tensions with India, particularly concerning the RoDTEP scheme.
- Impact on Indian Exports: These duties could potentially impact Indian exporters, affecting trade dynamics between India and these global economic powers.
- Prospect of WTO Involvement: The possibility of this dispute reaching the WTO highlights the complexities of international trade laws and the need for careful navigation of global trade policies.
Back2Basics: RoDTEP Scheme
|
Details |
| Introduction |
Announced in 2020, replacing the Merchandise Exports from India Scheme (MEIS). |
| Objective |
To refund taxes and duties on exported products not covered under any other scheme, enhancing export competitiveness. |
| Scope and Coverage |
Covers various sectors, beneficial for a wide range of industries, including those not covered under MEIS. |
| Rebate Rates |
Varies based on the taxes and duties incurred on the production and distribution of the exported product. |
| Eligibility |
Exporters must comply with criteria including the condition that goods must be manufactured in India. |
| Claim Process |
Rebate claimed as a transferable duty credit/electronic scrip, maintained in an electronic ledger. |
| Implementation |
Implemented by the Directorate General of Foreign Trade (DGFT) and Customs Department. |
| Impact |
Aims to make Indian exports more competitive globally by offsetting domestic taxes and levies. |
| Compliance with WTO |
Designed to comply with India’s commitments under the WTO framework. |
| Process |
Fully digital and transparent process for claiming rebates, reducing the compliance burden on exporters. |
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: BNSS
Mains level: need for fundamental transformations in the criminal justice system
Central idea
The article critiques the withdrawal and reintroduction of criminal law bills in India, highlighting concerns over civil liberties, overcriminalisation, and expanded police powers. It emphasizes the alarming increase in police custody duration and the absence of a transformative vision in the proposed legislations.
Key Highlights:
- Legislative Changes: The government withdraws and reintroduces criminal law bills, including Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS-II), Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS-II), and Bharatiya Sakshya Bill (BSB-II), reflecting potential shifts in the criminal justice system.
- Concerns Over State Control: The bills raise concerns about the expansion of state control, overcriminalisation, and enhanced police powers, potentially compromising civil liberties and increasing the risk of police excesses.
- Police Custody Duration: The BNSS proposes a significant increase in the maximum duration of police custody, from 15 days to 60 or 90 days, raising concerns about potential exposure to abuse and coercion.
Key Challenges:
- Risk of Overcriminalisation: The bills introduce broadly worded offenses, especially related to the security of the state, potentially leading to overcriminalisation and ambiguous legal provisions.
- Expanded Police Powers: The BNSS’s expansion of police custody duration, combined with vague offenses, raises concerns about the potential for misuse of power and coercive tactics.
- Lack of Transformative Vision: The bills lack a transformative vision for criminal law and justice, potentially entrenching colonial-era logic and emphasizing state control over citizen liberties.
Key Terms and Phrases:
- Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS-II): A proposed legislation to replace the Indian Penal Code (IPC, 1860), reflecting potential changes in criminal law.
- Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS-II): A bill aimed at replacing the Criminal Procedure Code (CPC, 1973) with potential implications for civil liberties and police powers.
- Bharatiya Sakshya Bill (BSB-II): Legislation seeking to replace the Indian Evidence Act (IEA, 1872), indicating potential shifts in the criminal justice system.
Key Quotes and Statements:
- “The expansion under the proposed BNSS heightens the risk of exposure to police excesses… a shocking expansion of police powers.”
- “These Bills present a missed opportunity to correct the entrenched injustices of our criminal justice system.”
Key Examples and References:
- Overcriminalisation Concerns: The bills introduce broadly framed offenses, including criminalizing misinformation, raising fears of overcriminalisation and potential misuse.
- Expansion of Police Custody: The BNSS proposes a substantial increase in the duration of police custody, contributing to concerns about potential abuse and coercive practices.
Key Facts and Data:
- Duration of Police Custody: The BNSS proposes expanding the maximum limit of police custody from 15 days to either 60 or 90 days, depending on the nature of the offense.
Critical Analysis:
- Missed Opportunity: The bills are criticized for not addressing deep-seated issues in the criminal justice system and potentially entrenching colonial-era logic without a transformative vision.
- Efficiency vs. Fairness: Emphasizes that goals of speedy justice and effective investigation, while important, cannot be achieved without addressing structural barriers and ensuring fairness.
Way Forward:
- Comprehensive Regulatory Ecosystem: Advocates for a regulatory framework ensuring fairness, transparency, and accountability, especially in the context of expanded police powers and overcriminalisation.
- Structural Reforms: Emphasizes the need for fundamental transformations in the criminal justice system, addressing issues like judicial vacancies, infrastructure, and scientific validity of forensic methods.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Na
Mains level: Consultocracy
Central idea
The article explores into the growing reliance on consulting firms for policy formulation and program implementation in Indian government projects. It raises concerns about potential downsides, such as the hollowing out of government capabilities, excessive dependence, and the risk of lobbying and corruption scandals. While acknowledging the benefits, the author calls for a balanced approach, emphasizing the necessity of a regulatory framework to ensure fairness, transparency, and knowledge transfer.
Key Highlights:
- Rise of Consulting in Government: Government projects, including major initiatives like Ganga cleaning and Swachh Bharat, heavily rely on consulting firms for policy formulation and program implementation.
- Proliferation of Global Consulting Firms: Reports reveal that Indian ministries paid around Rs 5,000 million in fees to global consulting firms in the last five years, prompting the finance ministry to seek details of these engagements.
- Concerns Over Dependence: There are concerns about a potential hollowing out of government capabilities due to excessive reliance on consultants, leading to mission creep, repeated redeployment, and potential lobbying for repeat work.
Key Challenges:
- Hollowing of Government Capabilities: The unbridled use of consulting firms raises concerns about a decline in the skills and capabilities of government officials, potentially infantilizing government institutions.
- Mission Creep and Dependence: Excessive dependence on consulting teams may result in mission creep, where routine functions are outsourced, and officials become overly reliant on consultants, risking a loss of institutional knowledge and skills.
- Consulting-Related Corruption: The global trend of consulting firms influencing policy directions and engaging in lobbying raises concerns about corruption scandals and the distortion of public policy objectives.
Key Terms and Phrases:
- Programme Management Units: Consulting firms often establish these units with broad mandates, attached to senior officials, leading to potential mission creep and dependence.
- Consultocracy: A term coined to describe the permeation of consultants into the core of government, diminishing the traditional role and capabilities of public servants.
- Digitisation of Public Service Delivery: The increasing complexity of public service delivery, including initiatives like the Direct Benefit Transfer program, demands specialized technical expertise.
Key Quotes and Statements for mains value addition:
- “There is a tendency to farm out even routine functions like preparing file notes and letters.”
- “The unbridled use of consultants reduces the skills and capabilities of officials, thus infantilising government.”
Key Examples and References:
- Global Consulting Influence: Books like “The Big Con” and “When McKinsey Comes to Town” highlight concerns about the influence of consulting firms, even leading governments down amoral pathways.
- Consulting in Indian Ministries: Reports indicate that Indian ministries paid substantial fees to global consulting firms in the last five years, prompting regulatory scrutiny.
Key Facts and Data:
- Financial Transactions: Indian ministries paid approximately Rs 5,000 million in fees to global consulting firms over the last five years.
Critical Analysis:
- Balancing Act: Acknowledges the benefits of consulting expertise in tackling complex challenges but emphasizes the need for a regulatory framework to prevent overdependence and potential pitfalls.
Way Forward:
- Regulatory Ecosystem: Advocates for a comprehensive regulatory ecosystem addressing fairness, transparency, curbing rent-seeking behaviors, and ensuring knowledge transfer to government.
- Calibrated Onboarding: Suggests a carefully calibrated onboarding of expertise from the private sector within a normative and transparent regulatory framework to enhance public service delivery.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: na
Mains level: Insaniyat, Jamhooriyat, and Kashmiriyat
Note for students: This article is written by our prime minister hence it becomes very important from UPSC Perspective.
Central idea
The text discusses the historic Supreme Court judgment upholding the abrogation of Articles 370 and 35(A) in Jammu and Kashmir. It highlights the positive impact of this decision, emphasizing a shift towards grassroots democracy and renewed focus on development in the region. The author advocates for continued engagement, national integration, and sustained efforts to address historical challenges.
Key Highlights:
- Historic Supreme Court Judgment: Upheld the abrogation of Articles 370 and 35(A), emphasizing India’s sovereignty.
- Long-standing Issues: Jammu, Kashmir, and Ladakh faced violence and instability for seven decades.
- Leadership Perspective: The author expresses commitment to addressing people’s aspirations and removing perceived injustices.
- Articles 370 and 35(A) as Obstacles: Seen as major hindrances to development and rights in Jammu and Kashmir.
- Development Initiatives: Government implemented various initiatives, including a 2015 special package, to address infrastructure, job creation, tourism, and handicraft industry support.
- Grassroots Democracy: Last four years witnessed renewed focus, improving representation for women, SCs, STs, and marginalized sections.
- Positive Impact of Abrogation: Visible development, improved infrastructure, increased tourist inflows, and a boost to various government schemes.
Key Challenges:
- Historical Confusion: Stemming from centuries of colonization, leading to a lack of clarity on basic issues.
- Violence and Instability: Jammu, Kashmir, and Ladakh experienced the worst forms of violence and instability for seven decades.
- Initial Choice at Independence: The narrative suggests a choice between a fresh start for national integration and continuing with a confused approach.
Key Terms and Phrases:
- Articles 370 and 35(A): Constitutional provisions abrogated to enhance constitutional integration.
- Karyakarta: Term referring to a political worker or activist.
- Insaniyat, Jamhooriyat, and Kashmiriyat: A message emphasizing humanity, democracy, and the unique cultural identity of Kashmir.
- Fit India Dialogues: Dialogues promoting fitness and well-being.
- Panchayat Polls: Elections at the grassroots level for local self-governance.
Key Quotes and Statements:
- “August 5, 2019, is etched in the hearts and minds of every Indian.”
- “The people of J&K want development and they want to contribute to the development of India based on their strengths and skills.”
- “The success of Panchayat polls indicated the democratic nature of the people of J&K.”
Key Examples and References:
- Afshan Ashiq: Mentioned as a talented footballer symbolizing positive change from stone-pelting to sports.
- Dr. Syama Prasad Mookerjee: Quoted for quitting the Nehru Cabinet over the Kashmir issue, becoming a source of inspiration.
- Atal ji’s “Insaniyat, Jamhooriyat, and Kashmiriyat” message: Referenced as a source of great inspiration.
Key Facts and Data:
- Over 150 ministerial visits from May 2014 to March 2019: Highlighting the government’s effort to interact directly with the people of Jammu and Kashmir.
- Special assistance of Rs 1,000 crore announced in 2014 for rehabilitation after floods: Demonstrating the government’s commitment during crises.
- Saturation of key central government schemes: Mentioned in sectors like Saubhagya, Ujjwala, housing, tap water connections, and financial inclusion.
Critical Analysis:
- Positive Impact of Abrogation: The author emphasizes the positive changes and development in Jammu, Kashmir, and Ladakh post the abrogation of Articles 370 and 35(A).
- Renewed Faith in Grassroots Democracy: The text suggests a positive shift towards grassroots democracy, with increased representation for marginalized sections.
- Historical Confusion and Choices: The narrative criticizes historical confusion and advocates for a clearer approach at the time of independence.
Way Forward:
- Continued Development: Continue the focus on development, infrastructure, and addressing the aspirations of the people.
- Sustained Grassroots Engagement: Maintain engagement at the grassroots level, ensuring representation for all sections of society.
- National Integration: Strengthen the spirit of “Ek Bharat, Shreshtha Bharat” for unity and good governance.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Central Civil Service (CCS)
Mains level: necessity of academic freedom in fostering critical thinking for societal benefit
Central idea
The article explores the global challenges to academic freedom, accentuated by the Israeli-Palestinian conflict’s impact on protests in the West and restrictive measures in India. It emphasizes the practical and misunderstood nature of academic freedom, highlighting the crucial role it plays in fostering critical thinking within the academic community and the threats posed by government interference.
Key Highlights:
- Israeli-Palestinian Conflict Impact: The Israeli-Palestinian conflict sheds light on the challenges to academic freedom in the West, with protests facing severe threats and legal consequences.
- Global Restrictions on Dissent: The credibility of academic freedom faces a global crisis, as European governments pass laws punishing dissent against the state of Israel, mirroring actions taken in the West.
- Indian Context: In India, authorities align with Western counterparts, stifling protests, banning events, and demanding apologies from speakers critical of the Israeli state.
Key Challenges:
- Threats and Challenges in the West: Protests in American universities against the Israeli-Palestinian conflict provoke threats from donors, alumni, and administrators, showcasing the fragility of academic freedom.
- Public Misunderstanding: The public perceives academic freedom as a privilege for already pampered professors, undermining its significance and practical application.
- Government Interference in India: Indian authorities pre-empt protests, ban events, and cancel talks, aligning with Western counterparts and limiting academic freedom.
Key Terms and Phrases:
- Academic Freedom: Autonomy granted to the practice of academics, allowing the pursuit of ideas and knowledge without external constraints.
- Aam Aadmi: The common person’s perspective on academic freedom as a perk for professors, contributing to a misunderstanding of its true nature.
- Central Civil Service (CCS) Rules: Government regulations governing officials, potentially threatening academic freedom if applied to academics.
Key Quotes and Statements:
- “The credibility of this idea is in tatters today as protests against the war in American universities provoke threats from donors, alumni and administrators…”
- “Each of its two words misleads in its own way. ‘Academic’ suggests something obscure and impractical, far removed from the everyday world…”
- “But despite the global attention it is now receiving, academic freedom remains a much misunderstood idea.”
Key Examples and References:
- Israeli-Palestinian Conflict Impact: The conflict serves as a catalyst for threats against academic freedom in the West, revealing global implications.
- Indian Authorities’ Actions: Actions such as pre-empting protests, banning events, and canceling talks illustrate restrictions on academic freedom in India.
Key Facts and Data:
- Instances of protests in American universities facing threats from donors, alumni, and administrators highlight the vulnerabilities of academic freedom.
- European governments passing laws to defund and punish academic or artistic activities critical of Israel contribute to the global erosion of academic freedom.
- The University Grants Commission (UGC) directive in India, suggesting the installation of “selfie points” with the Prime Minister’s picture, showcases government interference.
Critical Analysis:
- Misunderstood Practicality: Academic freedom is portrayed as misunderstood, practical, and down-to-earth, yet specific to the academic world.
- Scrutiny Within Academic Community: The article emphasizes the scrutiny and criticism within the academic community, balancing autonomy with adherence to academic norms.
- Impact of Government Control: Potential consequences of government control, as seen in the threat to universities under Central Civil Service (CCS) rules, are discussed.
Way Forward:
- Fostering Critical Thinking: Emphasize the practicality and necessity of academic freedom in fostering critical thinking for societal benefit.
- Resisting Government Interference: Advocate for the protection of academic autonomy, resisting government interference that could stifle questioning and research.
- Promoting Public Awareness: Promote public awareness and understanding of academic freedom to counter misconceptions and ensure its preservation.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: UAPA
Mains level: anti-terror law
Central idea
The Jammu and Kashmir High Court’s November 17, 2023 judgment in journalist Fahad Shah’s case questions the broad interpretation of terrorism under UAPA, rejecting its use for defamation. It emphasizes judicial scrutiny in upholding personal liberty, challenging Section 43-D(5), and calls for legal reforms and accountability, urging a just way forward.
Key Highlights:
- Court’s Intervention: The Jammu and Kashmir High Court’s November 17, 2023 judgment intervened in journalist Fahad Shah’s case, granting him bail and partially setting aside charges under UAPA and FCRA.
- Call for Circumspection: The court emphasized the imperative for circumspection in enforcing anti-terror laws, particularly considering their impact on personal liberty.
- Defamation vs. Terrorism: Rejecting the government’s argument, the court challenged the notion that publishing an article harming India’s reputation constituted an act of terrorism.
Key Challenges:
- Vague Terrorism Offenses: The vague text of terrorism offenses under UAPA allows arrests in situations disconnected from actual incidents of violence, contributing to misuse.
- Section 43-D(5) Dilemma: The provision preventing bail if accusations are ‘prima facie true’ poses challenges to personal liberty, raising concerns about procedural fairness.
Key Terms and Phrases:
- UAPA: Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, the primary anti-terror statute in India.
- FCRA: Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Act, governing foreign funding.
- Section 43-D(5): UAPA provision restricting bail based on the ‘prima facie true’ criterion.
- Clear and Present Danger: Legal test invoked to restrict arrests based on a perceived immediate threat.
Key Quotes:
- “To treat allegations of defaming the country as terrorism seemed like a bridge just too far to cross.”
- “Provisions such as Section 43-D(5) were meant to prevent the easy release of persons such as the imaginary bomber.”
- “Both the law enforcement agency and the court must apply their mind to ensure that only in cases where a ‘clear and present danger’ is evinced are persons taken into custody.”
Key Statements:
- Judicial Emphasis: The judgment underscores the need for greater circumspection in enforcing anti-terror laws, especially concerning personal liberty.
- Defamation Clarification: Defamation of the country was deemed not punishable under UAPA, challenging the expansive interpretation of terrorism.
Critical Analysis:
- Judicial Accountability: While not revolutionary, the decision highlights the importance of accountability in state actions, particularly in the context of oppressive laws.
- Compensation Consideration: The legal regime needs to address compensations for wrongful arrest and detention, ensuring accountability and justice.
Way Forward:
- Legal Reforms: The legal system should consider reforms addressing compensations for wrongful arrests and enhancing state accountability.
- Upholding Constitutional Principles: Courts must continue upholding constitutional principles, ensuring a commitment to accountability in state actions.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
