Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Forest Rights Act, 2006 and its key provisions; Forest Villages
Mains level: Read the attached story
Introduction
- Triggering Concerns: Recently, the notification about the Thanthai Periyar Sanctuary in Tamil Nadu’s Erode district worried nearby forest communities.
- Potential Rights Denial: Residents fear losing their rights under the Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition of Forest Rights) Act 2006 (FRA) due to the sanctuary’s establishment.
About Forest Rights Act, 2006
|
Description |
| Purpose |
Recognizes and vests forest rights and occupation in Forest Dwelling Scheduled Tribes (FDST) and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (OTFD). |
| Recognition Criteria |
- Forest rights can be claimed by FDST and OTFD who have been residing in forest land for generations.
- Members or communities must have resided in forest land for at least three generations (75 years) prior to December 13, 2005.
|
| Types of Forest Rights Recognized |
- Title rights: Ownership rights to land farmed by them, subject to a maximum of 4 hectares.
- Use rights: Rights to extract Minor Forest Produce, grazing areas, etc.
- Relief and development rights: Provides for rehabilitation in case of illegal eviction or forced displacement and access to basic amenities.
- Forest management rights: Includes the right to protect, regenerate, conserve, or manage any community forest resource traditionally protected and conserved for sustainable use.
|
| Authority |
- Gram Sabha
- It is responsible for initiating the process for determining Individual Forest Rights (IFR) or Community Forest Rights (CFR).
|
| Empowerment |
- Aims to strengthen the conservation regime of forests while ensuring livelihood and food security of FDST and OTFD.
|
| Historical Injustices Addressed |
- Recognition of historical injustices faced by forest-dwelling communities
- Empowerment of forest-dwellers for sustainable resource use and livelihood security
|
| Issues |
- Predominant focus on individual rights, neglecting community rights
- Poor recognition of Individual Forest Rights (IFRs) and Community Forest Rights (CFRs)
|
What are Forest Villages?
- Definition: Forest villages are settlements located within forest areas, inhabited predominantly by tribal and indigenous communities.
- Historical Context: These villages have often existed for generations, with residents relying on forest resources for their livelihoods.
- Conversion Mandate: In 1990, the government ordered all forest villages to become revenue villages, aiming to formalize their status and grant them legal recognition.
- Incomplete Conversion: Despite these orders, the conversion process remains unfinished in many areas, leaving forest dwellers without essential rights and facilities.
Rights Admitted in the Sanctuary
- Continuation of Rights: The notification recognizes rights granted under previous laws and the FRA, ensuring some rights for individuals.
- Implementation Challenges: Tamil Nadu has struggled to enforce the FRA effectively, casting doubt on its implementation within the sanctuary.
Impact on Forest Communities
- Grazing Restrictions: The ban on cattle grazing within the sanctuary could affect the traditional grazing practices of forest-dwelling communities.
- Legal Discrepancies: Prohibiting grazing conflicts with the FRA’s recognition of grazing rights, highlighting inconsistencies in policy.
Legal Framework and Challenges
- WLPA Provisions: Sanctuaries and national parks are governed by the Wildlife (Protection) Act (WLPA) 1972, which mandates protecting rights within them.
- FRA Supremacy: The FRA overrides conflicting provisions of the WLPA, emphasizing the need to balance conservation with community rights.
- Implementation Gaps: Despite legal frameworks, inadequate enforcement of the FRA persists, undermining the rights of forest communities.
Tamil Nadu’s FRA Implementation
- Low Recognition Rate: Tamil Nadu has a poor record in recognizing forest rights, with only a fraction of entitled areas acknowledged under the FRA.
- National Context: Similar challenges exist nationwide, indicating systemic failures in upholding forest rights and conservation mandates.
Conclusion
- Urgent Action Needed: Addressing the concerns of forest-dwelling communities and ensuring compliance with legal provisions are crucial for sustainable forest management.
- Harmonizing Conservation and Rights: Balancing conservation goals with the rights of forest communities is essential for fair and effective forest governance.
- Call for Accountability: Authorities must prioritize implementing laws and policies that protect both forests and the rights of those dependent on them, promoting environmental justice and social equity.
Try this PYQ from CSP 2019:
Consider the following statements:
- As per the recent amendment to the Indian Forest Act, 1927, forest dwellers have the right to fell the bamboos grown on forest areas
- As per the Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition of Forest Rights) Act, 2006, bamboo is a minor forest produce
- The Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition Forest Rights) Act, 2006 allows ownership of minor forest produce to forest dwellers
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
(a) 1 and 2 only
(b) 2 and 3 only
(c) 3 only
(d) 1, 2 and 3
Post your answers here.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: President's/Governor's Address
Mains level: Significance of the address
Introduction
- The recent episode in the Tamil Nadu Assembly, where Governor R.N. Ravi declined to deliver the customary address, has reignited debates surrounding the significance of the Governor’s Address.
- He actually walked out in response to an insult of National Anthem in TN Assembly.
President’s/Governor’s Address
- Constitutional mandate: Articles 87 and 176 of the Constitution confer authority upon the President and Governor, respectively, to address the legislature.
- Occasions for Address: The addresses are reserved for two specific occasions: the commencement of a new legislative session post-election and the inauguration of the annual legislative session.
- Significance: Termed the President’s or Governor’s Address, these speeches are pivotal for initiating legislative proceedings.
Governor’s Address to the State Legislature: A Constitutional Obligation
- Prescribed Duties: Article 176 delineates the Governor’s obligation to address the Legislative Assembly at the onset of each legislative year and post-general elections, with both Houses convened if a Legislative Council exists.
- Procedural Norms: Established rules govern the time allocated for deliberating the address’s contents, ensuring parliamentary discourse.
Global Parallels: Similar Practices across Democracies
- Cross-National Comparison: Analogous provisions are observed in democratic nations worldwide.
- State of the Union: In the United States, it manifests as the “State of the Union” address (1790), while in the United Kingdom, it is the Queen’s Speech (1536), heralding the parliamentary year’s commencement.
- Indian Context: India’s Presidential Address mirrors the British model, reflecting the ceremonial role of the President, a sentiment echoed during the Constitution’s framing by Dr. B R Ambedkar.
Features of the Address Content
[A] Address Content: Proposals and Achievements
- Legislative Agenda: The President’s or Governor’s speech encapsulates legislative proposals and government policy initiatives, coupled with a retrospective glance at previous accomplishments.
- Government Input: Inputs for this address are curated from various government ministries, embodying the administration’s agenda.
[B] Authorship and Agency: Government Responsibility
- Constitutional Mandate: Governed by constitutional mandate, both the President and Governor are obligated to adhere to the Cabinet’s advice (1950) in their functions, including address preparation.
- Policy Reflection: Hence, the address is meticulously crafted by the government, serving as a reflection of its policy stance.
[C] Flexibility vs. Normative Adherence: Presidential/Governor Discretion
- Adherence to Protocol: While refusal to deliver the address is impermissible, deviations from the prepared script are permissible.
- Instances of Departure: Instances of Governors veering off the scripted path have transpired, although such actions remain rare for Presidents.
Judicial Pronouncement: Upholding Constitutional Framework
- Legal Precedent: The Supreme Court, in Shamsher Singh v. State of Punjab (1975), underscored the President’s (or Governor’s) adherence to Cabinet advice across functions.
- Contested Discretion: While discretion to modify the speech is contested, any departure from parliamentary norms may invoke debate.
R. Venkataraman’s Perspective
- Venkataraman’s Critique: R. Venkataraman, who served as President from 1987 to 1992, vehemently opposed the practice of Presidential and Governor’s addresses, deeming it a “British anachronism” and a “meaningless formality.”
- Calls for Constitutional Amendment: Venkataraman repeatedly urged PM Rajiv Gandhi and Chandra Shekher to abolish this tradition through a Constitutional amendment, emphasizing its lack of relevance and inherent biases.
Perceptions of the Address
- Government’s Voice: Venkataraman viewed the address as a mere reflection of the ruling regime’s perspectives, rendering Presidents and Governors mere “mouthpieces” devoid of independent expression.
- Controversies and Criticism: He expressed dismay over controversies surrounding Governors’ addresses in states like Maharashtra and West Bengal, condemning the opposition’s heckling of figures like Governor Nurul Hasan.
- Symbolic Adjustments: Venkataraman, in presenting his maiden Presidential address in 1988, advocated for subtle changes like replacing “My government” with “The government,” aligning with India’s constitutional ethos framed by the people.
- Legacy of British Colonialism: He underscored the incongruity of retaining British-era conventions in India’s democratic framework, emphasizing the need for symbolic adjustments to reflect the nation’s sovereignty.
Conclusion
- Symbol of Governance: The tradition of Presidential and Governor’s addresses, rooted in constitutional mandate, and symbolizes the fusion of ceremonial protocol with legislative functionality.
- Executive-Legislative Nexus: As integral components of democratic governance, these addresses underscore the synergy between executive authority and parliamentary accountability, while navigating the delicate balance between tradition and evolving norms.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Mohammed Quli Qutb Shah and his contemporaries
Mains level: NA
Introduction
- A digital twin of the Mohammed Quli Qutb Shah’s tomb was unveiled by a reality technology company, Hexagon in Hyderabad.
Who was Mohammed Quli Qutb Shah?
- Parentage: Muhammad Quli Qutb Shah was born on April 4, 1565, as the third son of Ibrahim Quli Qutb Shah Wali and his Hindu mother Bhagirathi.
- Literary Talent: He was not only an able administrator but also a skilled poet who composed verses in Persian, Telugu, and Urdu.
Contemporaries of Quli Qutb Shah
- Akbar (1556–1605): Mughal Emperor known for his religious tolerance and administrative reforms.
- Rani Durgavati (1550–1564): Queen of the Gondwana Kingdom in central India, renowned for her bravery in resisting Mughal expansion.
- Maharana Pratap (1572–1597): Rajput ruler of Mewar, famous for his defiance against Mughal Emperor Akbar and his valor in battles.
- Chand Bibi (1550–1599): Regent of the Ahmednagar Sultanate in Deccan, known for her role in defending Ahmadnagar against Mughal forces.
- Guru Ram Das (1574–1581): Fourth Sikh Guru who established the city of Amritsar and contributed significantly to Sikhism’s growth.
- Sher Shah Suri (1540–1545): Founder of the Sur Empire in North India, celebrated for his administrative reforms and construction of the Grand Trunk Road.
|
Key Accomplishments
[A] Reign and Accomplishments
- Ascension to the Throne: Muhammad Quli succeeded his father in 1580 at the age of 15 and ruled for 31 years.
- Military Campaigns: Despite facing rebellions, he effectively led troops and quelled disturbances, ensuring stability in his realm.
[B] Foundation of Hyderabad
- Urban Planning: Concerned about overcrowding in Golkonda, Muhammad Quli initiated the construction of Hyderabad in 1591.
- Land Selection: While folklore suggests a romanticized version of land selection, Muhammad Quli’s vision for Hyderabad’s development aimed at relieving congestion and promoting growth.
[C] Architectural Marvels and City Planning
- Charminar: As the architectural centrepiece, Charminar was built under Muhammad Quli’s patronage, symbolizing the city’s grandeur.
- City Layout: Hyderabad was meticulously planned with a gridiron layout, featuring significant landmarks like Darulshafa, Mecca Masjid, and Badshahi Ashurkhana.
[D] Support for Arts and Literature
- Calligraphic Art: Under Muhammad Quli’s rule, calligraphy flourished, with various scripts adorning buildings such as the Mecca Masjid.
- Literary Contributions: Muhammad Quli’s poetic works in Urdu and Dakhni languages reflected his diverse interests and cultural appreciation.
- Taraqqi: He was a poet himself and composed poetry in Persian and Telugu under the pen name “Taraqqi”.
[E] Medical and Literary Contributions
- Intellectual Hub: Hyderabad became a centre for medical and literary pursuits, with scholars producing notable works during Muhammad Quli’s reign.
- Preservation of Culture: Muhammad Quli’s literary legacy, including his Diwan, is preserved in institutions like the Salar Jung Museum, showcasing his contribution to cultural heritage.
Legacy and Influence
- Cultural Integration: Muhammad Quli’s reign represents a period of cultural fusion, blending Hindu and Islamic traditions in the Deccan region.
- Symbol of Unity: His efforts to promote harmony and coexistence endure as a testament to the inclusive ethos of his administration.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: APAAR, One Nation, One Student ID
Mains level: Read the attached storyapaar
Central Idea
- About 25 crore Automated Permanent Academic Account Registry (APAAR) have been created, Union Education Minister informed at a national conference on ‘APAAR: One Nation One Student ID Card.’
What is APAAR?
- What is it? : APAAR serves as a unique identification system for all students across India, commencing from early childhood.
- Lifelong Student ID: Every student is assigned a lifelong 12-digit ID, simplifying the tracking of academic progress from pre-primary education through higher education.
- Gateway to Digilocker: APAAR functions as a gateway to Digilocker, a digital repository where students can securely store crucial documents, including exam results and report cards, for convenient access during future endeavours such as higher education or job applications.
How does APAAR ID function?
- Unique Identification: Each individual receives a unique APAAR ID, linked to the Academic Bank Credit (ABC), a digital repository housing a student’s earned credits throughout their academic journey.
- Seamless Data Transfer: When students change schools, whether within the state or to another state, their data in the ABC is seamlessly transferred to the new school by sharing the APAAR ID, eliminating the need for physical document submission.
- All-Inclusive Repository: APAAR allows students to store certificates and credits from both formal and informal learning experiences, with digital certification from authorized institutions.
Rationale behind APAAR
- Streamlined Education: APAAR’s introduction aims to streamline education processes, reducing the burden on students to carry physical documents.
- NEP 2020 Initiative: This initiative was launched as part of the National Education Policy 2020 by the Ministry of Education.
- Empowering State Governments: APAAR empowers state governments to monitor literacy rates, dropout rates, and educational improvements effectively.
- Combatting Fraud: It seeks to combat fraud and the proliferation of duplicate educational certificates by providing a single, reliable reference for educational institutions, ensuring authenticity through first-party verification.
How to get an APAAR ID?
- Registration Process: To enrol for APAAR, students provide basic details such as name, age, date of birth, gender, and a photograph, all of which are verified using their Aadhar number.
- Aadhar Authentication: The Aadhaar number is used solely for verification purposes to match the name and date of birth, with no sharing of this data during registration.
- Parental Consent for Minors: For minors, parental consent is mandatory for using the student’s Aadhar number for authentication with UIDAI.
- Voluntary Registration: Registration for creating an APAAR ID is voluntary, not mandatory.
Concerns surrounding APAAR
- Data Security Concerns: Parents and students express concerns about sharing their Aadhar details, fearing potential leaks of personal information to external parties.
- Government Assurance: The government assures that shared information will remain confidential and will only be disclosed to entities engaged in educational activities, including UDISE+ (Unified District Information System for Education Plus), scholarships, academic record maintenance, educational institutions, and recruitment agencies.
- Data Control: Students retain the option to cease sharing their information with these entities at any time, with a halt in data processing. However, previously processed data remains unaffected if consent is withdrawn.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Endometrial Stem Cells
Mains level: Not Much
Introduction
- Approximately 20 years ago, biologist Caroline Gargett embarked on a quest to uncover remarkable cells within hysterectomy tissue.
- Dr. Gargett discovered two types of cells in the endometrium through rigorous microscopy examination, suspected to be adult stem cells due to their regenerative capabilities.
- The discovery of these cells, known as endometrial stromal mesenchymal stem cells, opened new avenues for research in tissue repair and disease treatment.
What are Endometrial Stem Cells?
- Potential for Regeneration: Endometrial stem cells possess the ability to differentiate into various cell types, including neurons, cartilage, fat, bone, heart, liver, and skin cells.
- Collection Methods: These stem cells can be obtained through a biopsy procedure or harvested from menstrual blood, offering a less invasive and more accessible means of procurement.
Application in Women’s Health
- Understanding Endometriosis: Endometrial stem cells have been linked to endometriosis, a condition affecting millions of women worldwide, providing insights into its etiology and potential therapeutic targets.
- Diagnostic and Therapeutic Potential: Differences in menstrual stem cells between healthy individuals and those with endometriosis offer promising avenues for diagnostic tests and targeted treatments.
- Treatment Innovations: Clinical trials exploring the transplantation of menstrual stem cells have shown potential for treating pelvic organ prolapse and other gynecological conditions.
Beyond Gynecological Diseases
- Wider Therapeutic Applications: Research indicates the potential of menstrual stem cells in treating diseases beyond gynecological disorders, including diabetes and wound healing.
- Clinical Trials and Future Prospects: Small-scale trials have demonstrated the safety and efficacy of stem cell transplantation in humans, paving the way for further exploration and application in diverse medical fields.
Challenges and Biases
- Underrepresentation in Research: Despite their therapeutic potential, menstrual stem cells constitute a minuscule fraction of stem cell research, attributed to cultural taboos and biases surrounding menstruation.
- Funding and Investment: Limited funding and gender bias in research funding pose significant challenges to advancing research on menstrual stem cells, necessitating greater advocacy and support.
Way Forward
- Addressing Bias: Tackling sex and gender bias in research funding is crucial for fostering equitable investments in women’s health research.
- Recognition and Validation: By overcoming cultural taboos and biases, menstrual stem cells can be recognized as a valuable resource in regenerative medicine, transforming perceptions of menstruation from inconvenience to scientific opportunity.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Mains level: India's evolving relations with the Gulf
Central Idea:
The article discusses the significant transformation in India’s relations with the Gulf region under Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s leadership, highlighted by recent diplomatic achievements such as the inauguration of a Hindu temple in Abu Dhabi and the release of Indian ex-naval personnel from Qatar. It identifies five key factors contributing to this transformation: diplomatic efforts, political engagement, religious perceptions, economic collaboration, and counter-terrorism cooperation.
Key Highlights:
- Modi’s proactive diplomacy in the Middle East, contrasting with the previous administration’s limited engagement.
- The shift from transactional to strategic economic ties, recognizing the Gulf’s growing influence in global capitalism.
- Improvement in religious tolerance in the Gulf, symbolized by the construction of a Hindu temple in Abu Dhabi.
- Enhanced counter-terror collaboration between India, Saudi Arabia, and the UAE.
- The potential for deeper defense cooperation and India’s role as a regional security provider.
Key Challenges:
- Historical religious tensions and the need to overcome past perceptions.
- Maximizing defense collaboration potential amid shifting regional geopolitics.
- Ensuring sustainable economic partnerships beyond oil purchases and labor exports.
Main Terms:
- Diplomacy
- Political engagement
- Religious tolerance
- Economic modernization
- Counter-terrorism collaboration
- Defense cooperation
Important Phrases:
- “Transformation of India’s relations with the Gulf”
- “Personal connection with the emirs”
- “Gulf’s emergence as a major center of global capitalism”
- “Growing religious tolerance”
- “Counter-terror collaboration”
- “Regional security provider”
Quotes/Useful Statements:
- “Modi’s proactive diplomacy contrasts with the previous administration’s limited engagement.”
- “The shift from transactional to strategic economic ties is crucial.”
- “Enhanced counter-terror collaboration signals a new phase in regional security.”
- “The construction of a Hindu temple in Abu Dhabi symbolizes growing religious tolerance.”
- “India must maximize defense collaboration potential amid shifting regional geopolitics.”
Examples and References:
- Narendra Modi’s 15 visits to the Middle East contrasted with the previous Prime Minister’s limited engagements.
- The inauguration of the Hindu temple in Abu Dhabi and the release of Indian ex-naval personnel from Qatar serve as tangible examples of improved relations.
- The establishment of the I2U2 group and the India-Middle East-Europe Economic Corridor illustrate India’s reoriented geopolitical engagement.
Facts and Data:
- Modi’s 15 visits to the Middle East compared to the previous Prime Minister’s four visits during the UPA rule.
- The release of Indian ex-naval personnel from Qatar following their espionage charges.
- The establishment of the I2U2 group and the India-Middle East-Europe Economic Corridor.
Critical Analysis:
- The article provides a comprehensive overview of India’s evolving relations with the Gulf, highlighting both achievements and challenges.
- It emphasizes the importance of Modi’s proactive diplomacy and the need for deeper economic and defense cooperation.
- However, it also acknowledges historical tensions and the complexities of navigating religious and geopolitical dynamics in the region.
Way Forward:
- India should continue to strengthen diplomatic ties and capitalize on economic opportunities in the Gulf.
- Deeper defense collaboration and regional security cooperation should be prioritized.
- Efforts to promote religious tolerance and overcome historical tensions are essential for fostering long-term stability and prosperity in the region.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: na
Mains level: a shift in the approach of Indian scientists towards addressing real-life problems
Central Idea:
The article argues for a shift in the approach of Indian scientists towards addressing real-life problems by integrating knowledge from various disciplines, including the humanities. It emphasizes the need for scientists to engage with societal issues, collaborate across disciplines, and embrace diverse forms of knowledge to find holistic solutions.
Key Highlights:
- Critique of the current scientific paradigm in India, where pursuit of quick rewards and adherence to disciplinary boundaries hinder problem-solving.
- Advocacy for a multidisciplinary approach that incorporates insights from the humanities and social sciences.
- Emphasis on the importance of understanding human complexities and societal context in scientific endeavors.
- Proposal for scientists to engage with communities, embrace humility, and recognize diverse forms of knowledge.
- Criticism of the hierarchical and reductionist tendencies within the scientific community.
- Assertion that addressing complex problems requires creativity, flexibility, and integration of diverse perspectives.
Key Challenges:
- Resistance from scientists accustomed to disciplinary silos and reductionist methodologies.
- Lack of institutional support and incentives for interdisciplinary collaboration.
- Need for a shift in mindset among scientists to prioritize societal impact over academic achievements.
- Overcoming entrenched power dynamics within the scientific community.
- Bridging the gap between academic research and practical problem-solving.
- Incorporating diverse forms of knowledge while ensuring rigor and reliability.
Main Terms:
- Scientific temper
- Reductionism
- Multidisciplinary approach
- Human sciences
- Interdisciplinary collaboration
- Social embeddedness
- Empirical testing
- Holistic understanding
Important Phrases:
- “Science-society border”
- “Climb down from the ivory tower”
- “Human complexities”
- “Tacit knowledge”
- “Integration of knowledge”
- “Extended peer community”
- “Proper scientific temper”
- “Cross-cultural conversation”
Quotes:
- “While religion is a sacred cow that doubles up as a cash cow, science is a cash cow that can often double up as a sacred cow in India.”
- “The whole is greater than the sum of its parts.”
- “Science leaves this kind of integration of knowledge from other sources out of the ‘scientific method’ altogether.”
- “A traditional puzzle solver scientist is like the mediocre artist who starts with a clearly visualized picture in mind and ends up painting it without leaving any scope for growth and change during the process.”
Useful Statements for mains value addition:
- “The time has come for a large chunk of scientific forces to be re-deployed on the science-society border to scout for solutions to real-life problems.”
- “The natural sciences then need to work in tandem with human sciences.”
- “A variety of perspectives and methods from different disciplines need to be brought to bear on a complex real-life problem.”
- “Philosophy has interacted fruitfully with business and medicine on issues of ethics and reproductive technologies.”
- “Science must confront the uncomfortable prospect of dealing with human complexities.”
Examples and References for qauality enrichment:
- The frothing Bellandur lake in Bengaluru vs. scholarly papers on the “giant gravity hole in the Indian Ocean.”
- Collaborations between philosophy, business, and medicine on ethical issues.
- Real-life problems such as human cloning, stem cell research, and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict with religious components.
Facts and Data:
- Reference to Manu Rajan, a retired information scientist from the Indian Institute of Science, Bengaluru.
- Mention of the threats posed by developments such as artificial intelligence.
- Reference to the prevalence of disciplinary silos and reductionist approaches in Indian scientific institutions.
Critical Analysis:
The article provides a compelling critique of the current scientific paradigm in India, highlighting its limitations in addressing real-life problems. It emphasizes the importance of interdisciplinary collaboration and the integration of knowledge from the humanities and social sciences. However, it could provide more concrete examples of successful interdisciplinary efforts and practical strategies for fostering collaboration. Additionally, the article could address potential challenges in implementing its proposed changes, such as institutional resistance and resource constraints.
Way Forward:
- Promote interdisciplinary research initiatives and provide incentives for collaboration.
- Establish platforms for dialogue and knowledge exchange between scientists and diverse stakeholders.
- Invest in education and training programs that emphasize holistic problem-solving skills.
- Foster a culture of humility, curiosity, and openness to diverse perspectives within the scientific community.
- Encourage partnerships between academic institutions, government agencies, and civil society organizations to address pressing societal challenges.
In conclusion, the article advocates for a paradigm shift in Indian science towards a more inclusive, interdisciplinary approach that prioritizes real-life problem-solving and societal impact. By embracing diverse forms of knowledge and collaborating across disciplines, scientists can better address the complex challenges facing society.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
Note4Students
From UPSC perspective, the following things are important :
Prelims level: Disguised unemployment
Mains level: India's economic stagnation, particularly in terms of industrialization and employment generation,
Central Idea:
The article explores India’s economic stagnation, particularly in terms of industrialization and employment generation, and proposes a shift towards high-skill, services-driven growth as advocated by Raghuram Rajan and Rohit Lamba in their book “Breaking the Mould: Reimagining India’s Economic Future”. It argues that traditional approaches to industrialization have not been effective in India and suggests that focusing on high-skill services, particularly in the IT sector, could stimulate manufacturing and address socio-economic inequalities.
Key Highlights:
- India’s historical struggle with industrialization despite various reform efforts.
- Proposal for a shift towards high-skill services-led growth to stimulate manufacturing.
- Critique of traditional industrial policy and its failure to address unemployment and trade deficits.
- Challenges posed by poor employment elasticity of services-led growth and inequality in the service sector.
- Impact of unequal access to education on labor market outcomes and economic disparities.
- Cultural factors contributing to India’s industrial stagnation, including undervaluing certain occupations and skills.
- Importance of mass education and collective absorptive capacity for innovation and economic development.
Key Challenges:
- Poor employment elasticity of services-led growth.
- Inequality in the service sector, particularly in terms of wages.
- Unequal access to education and skills training, exacerbating socio-economic disparities.
- Cultural attitudes towards certain occupations hindering innovation and industrial development.
- Lack of mass education and collective absorptive capacity for technological progress.
Main Terms:
- Industrialization
- Services-driven growth
- High-skill services
- Information technology (IT)
- Unemployment
- Trade deficit
- Inequality
- Mass education
- Absorptive capacity
- Technological progress
Important Phrases:
- “Premature deindustrialization”
- “Disguised unemployment”
- “Mass school education”
- “High-skill services pitch”
- “Cultural prerequisite for industrialization”
- “Useful knowledge”
- “Organic innovation in manufacturing”
- “Collective absorptive capacity”
- “Deep industrialization”
Quotes:
- “Rural entrepreneurship was able to grow out of the traditional agricultural sector on a massive scale [in China]. The rural Indian, in contrast, hampered by a poor endowment of human capital, were not able to start entrepreneurial ventures remotely on the scale of the Chinese.” – Yasheng Huang
- “India needs deep industrialization, not just the service sector, that has the power of changing the foundations of society.” – Authors (Rajan and Lamba)
Useful Statements:
- “India’s historical struggle with industrialization despite various reform efforts.”
- “Proposal for a shift towards high-skill services-led growth to stimulate manufacturing.”
- “Impact of unequal access to education on labor market outcomes and economic disparities.”
- “Importance of mass education and collective absorptive capacity for innovation and economic development.”
Examples and References:
- Periodic Labour Force Survey, 2021-22.
- Raghuram Rajan and Rohit Lamba’s book “Breaking the Mould: Reimagining India’s Economic Future”.
- Economic historian Joel Mokyr’s insights on the role of useful knowledge in economic development.
- Comparison between India and China’s approaches to rural entrepreneurship and industrialization.
Facts and Data:
- India’s manufacturing share in output and employment has been stagnant and below 20%.
- India’s trade deficit has been widening, largely driven by imported goods.
- Inequality in the service sector is higher compared to manufacturing.
- India is one of the world’s most unequal countries in terms of education.
Critical Analysis:
- The article presents a critical examination of India’s historical industrialization efforts and their limitations.
- It questions traditional approaches to industrial policy and offers a provocative alternative centered around high-skill services.
- The critique of inequality in the service sector and its implications for socio-economic disparities adds depth to the analysis.
- The cultural factors influencing India’s industrial stagnation provide valuable insights into the broader challenges faced by the country.
Way Forward:
- Emphasize the need for a comprehensive approach to economic development that addresses both industrialization and service sector growth.
- Invest in mass education and skills training to enhance collective absorptive capacity and promote innovation.
- Reevaluate cultural attitudes towards certain occupations to foster organic innovation in manufacturing.
- Ensure that economic policies prioritize reducing inequality and promoting inclusive growth.
Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024
Attend Now
