Central Idea:

Shashi Tharoor, a prominent Indian politician and author, highlights the transformation of Indian media since liberalization in 1991. He expresses concern over the negative impact of the “breaking news” culture, sensationalism, and the lack of fact-checking, emphasizing the importance of a free and responsible press in a democracy.

Key Highlights:

• Media Transformation: Tharoor discusses how economic growth, government control relaxation, and the internet have transformed Indian media since 1991.
• Issues with Breaking News Culture: The author criticizes the sensationalism-driven “breaking news” culture, where speed often prioritizes over accuracy, leading to a rush to judgment.
• Impact of Social Media: Tharoor points out that social media exacerbates the problem, allowing unverified information to spread, and the print media is also affected due to the pressure to keep up with the 24/7 news cycle.
• Media’s Role in Democracy: He emphasizes that the media’s role in democracy is to critically assess elected officials’ actions, holding them accountable, but the current focus on superficial and sensational news trivializes public discourse.

Key Challenges:

• Quality vs. Quantity: The explosion in the quantity of media offerings has not necessarily improved their quality, leading to concerns about the substance of news coverage.
• Sensationalism Over Substance: The author criticizes the shift towards sensationalism, where the pursuit of breaking news takes precedence over accurate reporting.
• Blurring of Journalism Basics: Distinctions among facts, opinions, and speculation have blurred in Indian media, raising concerns about journalistic standards and accountability.

Key Terms/Phrases:

• Breaking News Culture: The focus on immediate reporting at the expense of accuracy.
• Trial by Media: The phenomenon where individuals face public judgment and scrutiny through media coverage.
• Fourth Estate: The media’s role as an unofficial fourth branch of government, serving as a check on power.

Key Quotes:

• “Television news in India… has long given up any pretence of providing a public service…”
• “Charges are reported uncritically, without editors asking even the most basic questions about their plausibility.”

Key Statements:

• “The rush to judgment on the basis of partial information must stop.”
• “What democrats want is not less journalism, but better journalism.”

Key Examples and References:

• Tharoor mentions instances where the government has intimidated newspapers and blocked TV channels, raising concerns about press freedom.
• Reference to The Hindu newspaper’s practice of having a Readers’ Editor to acknowledge mistakes and engage with readers.

Key Facts/Data:

• The author refers to the lack of restrictions on media ownership by affluent citizens in India.
• Mention of the government’s role in introducing laws to limit control of multiple news organizations by a single entity.

Critical Analysis:

Tharoor critically examines the impact of sensationalism on media quality and the blurring of journalistic standards. He underscores the need for a free press while acknowledging the challenges posed by the current media landscape.

Way Forward:

• Fact-Verification Culture: Promote a culture of fact-verification and accuracy, discouraging the rush to break news at the expense of accuracy.
• Journalistic Training: Enhance journalistic training to prioritize values of accuracy, integrity, and fairness, ensuring that media outlets issue retractions for false claims.
• Diversity in Newsrooms: Encourage diverse perspectives in newsrooms to avoid becoming echo chambers and ensure fair representation of alternative views.
• Public Engagement: Foster engagement between journalists and the public through feedback mechanisms, acknowledging mistakes, and building trust.
• Government Regulations: Introduce laws and regulations to limit the control of news organizations by a single entity, promoting an independent and robust press.

In conclusion, Shashi Tharoor calls for a responsible and accountable media, urging for improvements in journalistic practices, training, and regulations to ensure that the media continues to play a vital role in India’s democracy.

Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024

Attend Now