Central Idea

• Israel conducted a military operation in the occupied West Bank, resembling past large-scale operations.
• This strike has resulted in casualties among Palestinians.

West Bank and Its Significance

• The West Bank: A landlocked territory in Western Asia, forming the main part of the Palestinian territories.
• Geographical Borders: Bordered by Jordan, the Dead Sea, Israel (south, west, and north), and the Mediterranean coast.
• Anti-Semitism as Official Policy: Several theocratic countries, including the Arab world, the self-proclaimed caliphate ‘Turkiye,’ and even Pakistan, have officially expressed hatred against Jews.
• Denial of Access: Jews, as a micro-minority of the world, have been denied access to their homeland.

Understanding Israel-Palestine Conflict

• Historical Background: The land of contention was under the Ottoman Empire and later the British Empire.
• Palestinian Aspirations: Palestinians, Arab people from the area, seek a state named Palestine in the region.
• Conflict over Land and Control: Dispute over territorial ownership and governance between Israelis and Palestinians.
• Jewish Aspiration for Homeland: Jews fleeing persecution in Europe sought to establish a Jewish state on what they believed to be their ancient homeland.
• Arab Resistance: Arabs resisted, claiming the land as their own, known as Palestine at the time.
• Balfour Declaration: In 1917, the United Kingdom expressed support for the establishment of a Jewish homeland in Palestine.
• Violent Resistance: Arab resistance to the declaration led to violence and further tensions.

Jewish Immigration to West Bank

• Migration Statistics: Thousands of Jews migrated to Palestine during the 1920s and 1930s.
• Arab Opposition: Palestinian Arabs demanded the UK to halt Jewish emigration, leading to violent incidents.
• The British Mandate for Palestine: Issued in 1923 by the League of Nations, giving the UK the responsibility to create a Jewish national homeland.
• Partition Proposal: In 1936, the UK recommended the partition of Palestine into Jewish and Arab states.

Escalation of the Conflict

• Involvement of the UN: In 1947, the issue of Palestine was referred to the UN, resulting in a partition plan.
• Peace Proposals: The UN suggested two separate states with economic cooperation or a single bi-national state with autonomous Jewish and Palestinian areas.
• Arab Invasion and Israeli Independence: In 1948, Israel declared independence, leading to immediate invasions by Arab countries.
• Territory Changes: Israel gained some territory designated for Palestinian Arabs under the UN resolution, including the Gaza Strip and the West Bank.

Resolving the Conflict: Two-State Solution

• Idea: The two-state solution aims to establish Israeli and Palestinian states coexisting in the region.
• Elusiveness of the Solution: Over the decades, the two-state solution has not been realized.
• Importance: Establishing separate states for Israelis and Palestinians addresses the root cause of the conflict.

Challenges to the Two-State Solution

(1) Borders:

• Drawing the Lines: No consensus exists on how to define the borders.
• Pre-1967 Lines: Some argue for using the borders before the Israeli-Arab war in 1967.
• Israeli Settlements: The presence of Israeli settlements in the West Bank complicates the border issue.

(2) Question of Jerusalem:

• Capital Claims: Both Israel and Palestinians claim Jerusalem as their capital.
• Complex Division: Dividing Jerusalem into Israeli and Palestinian sectors proves challenging due to the overlapping of holy sites.

(3) Refugee Issue:

• Palestinian Refugees: Large numbers of Palestinians became refugees during the 1948 War.
• Right of Return: Palestinians and their descendants, numbering around 5 million, demand the right to return, which Israel rejects.

(4) Security Concerns:

• Harassment by Hamas: Israel faces security threats from Hamas, a terrorist group controlling the Gaza Strip.
• Palestinian Attacks: Palestinians also face security concerns, seeking an end to foreign military occupation.

Importance of the Two-State Solution

• Fulfilling Aspirations: The two-state solution provides both Jews and Arabs with their respective states.
• Alternative Limitations: Other solutions, such as a single state, would lead to a minority status for Jews or an unhappy Arab majority.

Moral Reasoning for a Two-State Solution

• Balancing Aspirations: Advocates argue against subordinating one group’s aspirations to another’s vision.
• Jewish Minority: A single state would diminish Jews to a minority, potentially compromising their aspirations.

Way Forward

• India’s Perspective: India believes that a negotiated two-state solution is essential for long-term peace in Israel and Palestine.
• Establishment of a Palestinian State: India supports the establishment of a sovereign, independent, and viable State of Palestine within recognized borders.

Conclusion

• Understanding the Israel-Palestine conflict and the significance of a two-state solution is crucial for achieving lasting peace in the region.
• By addressing the challenges and considering the aspirations of both Israelis and Palestinians, a negotiated settlement can lead to a sovereign and independent Palestine living alongside Israel.

Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024

Attend Now