Central Idea:

The article reflects on the recent security breach in the Indian Parliament, drawing attention to the historical debate around the choice of a parliamentary government for India. It explores the importance of having a stable government with effective opposition, emphasizing the parliamentary system’s capacity to accommodate diversity. The author questions the handling of the security breach incident and the subsequent suspension of a significant number of opposition members.

Key Highlights:

• Security lapse in the Indian Parliament in December 2023.
• Historical debate on the choice of a parliamentary government in India.
• Importance of stable government with effective opposition.
• Challenges faced by the ruling party in accommodating opposition.
• Critique of the current leadership’s response to the security breach.

Key Challenges:

• Grappling with the aftermath of a significant security breach.
• Balancing the need for a stable government with the necessity of an effective opposition.
• Managing the paradox of majority endorsement while ensuring constant validation for the common good.
• Ensuring parliamentary committees address security concerns adequately.
• Striking a balance between executive authority and parliamentary dignity.

Key Terms:

• Parliamentary government
• Opposition
• Security breach
• Westminster system
• Presidential system
• Swarajist model
• Indian orthodoxy
• Common good
• Effective representation
• Stability in governance

Key Phrases:

• “Foundational institution of public life.”
• “Parliamentary form of government.”
• “Security lapses and pandemonium.”
• “Doctrinal, ethnic, and cultural pluralisms.”
• “Dialectics of stable support and effective opposition.”
• “Insistent demand of the Opposition.”
• “Suspended members from both Houses.”
• “Ruling party’s ability to defend its course.”

Key Quotes:

• “A parliamentary system marks a better space for minorities.”
• “The ruling party has not found it easy to face a sustained Opposition.”
• “It is not the truth that a ruling dispensation upholds that serves its claim to rule but its ability to defend the course it pursues as the truth.”

Anecdotes:

• Incident involving Jawaharlal Nehru and Speaker Mavalankar’s refusal to go to the Prime Minister’s chamber.
• Reference to historical debates within the Constituent Assembly on the form of government for India.

Key Statements:

• “The security breach is a breach inflicted on the nation as a whole.”
• “The ruling party, despite challenges, has to live with the logic of the parliamentary system.”
• “The suspension of almost the entire Opposition from both the Houses can hardly meet the test of becoming the voice of the nation.”

Key Examples and References:

• Two young men with gas canisters causing pandemonium in the Lok Sabha.
• Historical references to arguments for the presidential, Indian orthodox, and swarajist models.
• Mention of Jawaharlal Nehru’s sensitivity to the absence of an effective opposition.

Key Facts and Data:

• December 2023: Security breach in the Indian Parliament.
• Suspension of 146 members from both Houses.
• Reference to the historical debate within the Constituent Assembly.

Critical Analysis:

The article critically evaluates the current state of the Indian Parliament, questioning the handling of the security breach and the subsequent suspension of opposition members. It emphasizes the importance of a stable government with an effective opposition, highlighting historical debates on the choice of a parliamentary system. The author critiques the leadership’s response and underscores the need for a balance between executive authority and parliamentary dignity.

Way Forward:

• Address the security concerns through parliamentary committees.
• Foster a more collaborative approach between the ruling party and the opposition.
• Uphold the principles of parliamentary democracy and the importance of an effective opposition.
• Prioritize transparency and communication in addressing lapses and challenges.
• Reaffirm the commitment to diversity, pluralism, and the common good in parliamentary governance.

Get an IAS/IPS ranker as your 1: 1 personal mentor for UPSC 2024

Attend Now