💥Crack UPSC In 1st Attempt | Admission Open | Ultimate Assessment Program 2027/2028
Talk to Mentor

Civilsdaily

Login

Type: Op-ed

  • [10th August 2026] The Hindu OpED: The fiscal cost of unconditional cash transfers to women

    PYQ Relevance
    [UPSC 2022]     Reforming the government delivery system through the Direct Benefit Transfer Scheme is a progressive step, but it has its limitations too. Comment.
    Linkage: The PYQ Examines DBT-based welfare delivery, fiscal sustainability, and the trade-off between welfare transfers and human-capital expenditure. The article highlights the trade-off between cash transfers and spending on education, health and development.

    Mentor’s Comment

    Delhi rolled out the Lakshmi Yojana on August 1, an unconditional cash transfer (UCT) of ₹2,500 a month for eligible women, joining a rapidly growing list of States running similar schemes since 2023. Fresh State-wise expenditure data show that in several States this spending already exceeds the entire education or health budget, reopening the question of what these transfers displace. The concern is set against the 16th Finance Commission’s award period.

    What is an unconditional cash transfer?

    • Definition: A UCT is a direct income payment to a beneficiary with no work, attendance, or behaviour condition attached, unlike a conditional transfer or an in-kind subsidy.
    • This wave: The current schemes target women with a fixed monthly sum, framed as income support rather than a service.

    Why are states rushing to launch women’s UCT schemes?

    • Electoral promise: Most schemes were pledged at assembly elections and rolled out immediately, drawing the label of a pre-poll dole.
    • Near-universal spread: From 2023 onward almost every major state added a scheme, making it politically hard for any state to abstain.
    • Compensation framing: Some argue the transfers compensate women for the state’s failure to create broad opportunity and services.

    Are these transfers a benefit to women or a burden on states?

    • Used productively: Evaluations show women mostly spend the money on food, health and education, so the transfer reaches real welfare needs.
    • Fiscal pressure: The same spending expands a recurring liability that presses on existing health and education budgets.
    • Genuine trade-off: The tension is real, the cash is used well by recipients yet competes with the public services those recipients depend on.

    How much fiscal space do states actually have?

    • Committed spending: The 16th Finance Commission notes almost 44% of state expenditure is locked in interest payments, pensions and salaries.
    • Shrinking social share: Social sector revenue expenditure has stayed stable as a share of total spending since 2011-12 but has declined as a share of GDP since 2020-21.
    • Little room: With most of the budget pre-committed, new UCT outlays crowd against fresh investment in services and infrastructure.

    How large are these schemes across states?

    • Share of total spending: UCT outlays range from 10.03% of total expenditure in Jharkhand and 7.84% in West Bengal down to 0.97% in Goa and 0.26% in Himachal Pradesh.
    • Share of education spending: In the largest-scheme states the UCT bill exceeds half the entire education budget, near 74% in Jharkhand and Karnataka and 54% in West Bengal.
    • Named schemes and amounts: Karnataka Gruha Lakshmi (Rs 2,000), Madhya Pradesh Ladli Behna (Rs 1,500), Tamil Nadu Kalaignar Magalir Urimai Thogai (Rs 1,000), Maharashtra Majhi Ladki Bahin (Rs 1,500), Jharkhand Maiya Samman (Rs 2,500), Odisha Subhadra (Rs 10,000 a year), Assam Orunodoi (Rs 1,250), and Delhi Lakshmi Yojana (Rs 2,500).

    Do the transfers reach the poorest, or do barriers exclude them?

    • Rationalisation cuts: Maharashtra and Madhya Pradesh have reduced beneficiary numbers in the name of rationalisation.
    • Gatekeeping criteria: Delhi’s scheme requires a recommendation from the local MLA or MP, plausibly to cap numbers before rollout.
    • Access barriers: Lack of documents, weak bank access and errors in digital records still exclude eligible women.

    Conclusion:

    The transfers are used well by the women who receive them, but states have little fiscal room, since most spending is pre-committed and the social sector share of GDP is already falling. Without new resource mobilisation, the schemes are financed by squeezing the very education and health services their beneficiaries rely on. The unresolved question is whether states raise revenue to fund them or let public services erode.

    Back2Basics: 16th Finance Commission

    • Award period: The 16th Finance Commission’s recommendations cover the five years beginning 2026-27.
    • What it is: A constitutional body under Article 280, constituted every five years.
    • Mandate: Recommends the sharing of central taxes between the Centre and states (vertical devolution) and among states (horizontal devolution), plus grants-in-aid.

    [2022, GS2, 10 marks] Reforming the government delivery system through the Direct Benefit Transfer Scheme is a progressive step, but it has its limitations too. Comment.

  • RBI holds repo rate; core versus headline inflation debate

    Why in the News

    The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) held the repo rate at 5.25%. Economists are divided over whether the central bank is anchoring policy to headline CPI or to core inflation, which strips out food and fuel.

    What is core inflation?

    1. Definition: Core inflation measures price change after removing volatile food and fuel components, showing the underlying, persistent trend.
    2. Why it matters: Monetary policy affects demand-driven prices, not a monsoon-driven food spike, so core is a cleaner signal for interest-rate decisions.

    Why is the anchor contested?

    1. Mandate is headline: The RBI’s legal target is headline retail inflation around 4%, not core, so leaning on core risks appearing to shift the goalpost.
    2. Food weight is large: Food is a large share of India’s consumption basket, so ignoring it understates the inflation households actually face.
    3. Credibility risk: Frequent redefinition of the operative measure weakens the predictability that anchors inflation expectations.

    Conclusion

    The rate hold reflects a judgement that underlying price pressure is easing even as headline stays elevated. The next milestone is whether food inflation cools enough to align headline with the target.

    PYQ Relevance

    [UPSC 2024] What are the causes of persistent high food inflation in India? Comment on the effectiveness of the monetary policy of the RBI to control this type of inflation.

    Linkage: The PYQ examines the limits of monetary policy in controlling persistent food-driven inflation. The debate over headline versus core inflation highlights how the RBI balances its inflation mandate with supply-side food shocks.

  • Proposed food security amendment could hurt the poorest

    Why in the News

    The Union government has proposed replacing the fixed 35kg monthly foodgrain quota for Antyodaya Anna Yojana households with a 7kg per-person entitlement. This proposed amendment to the National Food Security Act, 2013 could hurt the poorest households by converting a fixed household ration into a per capita entitlement. The tension is between per capita fairness on paper and the real needs of small, elderly, and vulnerable households.

    What is the Antyodaya Anna Yojana (AAY)?

    1. Targeting: AAY covers the poorest of the poor households under the food security system.
    2. Entitlement: Each AAY household currently receives 35 kg of foodgrain per month, regardless of size.
    3. Zero Cost: Foodgrains are provided completely free of charge to all AAY beneficiaries.
    4. Distribution Channel: Handled via the Targeted Public Distribution System (TPDS) through local fair price shops.
    5. Portability: Access is supported nationwide via systems like One Nation One Ration Card

    Key Beneficiary Groups

    1. Widows, terminally ill, disabled persons, or persons aged 60+ with no support
    2. Single women or men with no regular income or livelihood
    3. Primitive tribal groups
    4. Landless agricultural laborers, marginal farmers, and rural artisans
    5. Daily wage earners and slum dwellers in the informal sector

    What does the proposed amendment change?

    1. Per capita shift: The household entitlement would be replaced by a per capita quota of about 7 kg per person. But the total family support cannot go over 35 kg.
    2. Small household hit: A one or two member household would receive far less than the current 35 kg.

    What are the issues with the proposed amendment?

    1. Large families may lose out: The 35-kg ceiling can reduce the effective per-capita entitlement of AAY households with more than five members, weakening the rationale of a family-size-based allocation.
    2. Unequal regional impact: States with relatively larger household sizes, particularly parts of northern India, could face a greater impact from the 35-kg ceiling.
    3. Cereal-centric approach: Linking food security primarily to cereal quantities overlooks the need for protein, pulses, fats and dietary diversity for nutritional security.
    4. No wider concerns addressed: The amendment does not address wider concerns over outdated NFSA coverage, biometric failures and access barriers in the Public Distribution System.
    5. Exclusion remains unaddressed: Revising the entitlement formula does not resolve the larger problem of eligible beneficiaries remaining outside the PDS due to outdated population estimates and identification gaps.

    Who is most exposed to the change?

    1. Elderly and widows: Single member and elderly headed households lose the most.
    2. Vulnerable groups: Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Groups (PVTGs) and small families face sharp cuts.
    3. Large AAY households among the poorest sections: Particularly families with six or more members, are likely to face the greatest disadvantage.

    What principle is at stake?

    1. Adequacy over arithmetic: A per head formula ignores that small poor households have high fixed food needs.
    2. Substantive equality in food security is at stake: A uniform ceiling may appear administratively simple, but it can produce unequal outcomes for households with different sizes and vulnerabilities.

    Conclusion

    The central idea is that a per capita rule can look equal yet strip protection from the smallest households. Whether the amendment proceeds, and with what safeguard for small households, remains open.

    PYQ Relevance

    [UPSC 2021] What are the salient features of the National Food Security Act, 2013? How has the Food Security Bill helped in eliminating hunger and malnutrition in India?

    Linakge: The PYQ examines the NFSA’s role in ensuring food security and addressing hunger and malnutrition. The proposed AAY reform raises questions about whether changes in foodgrain entitlements can preserve the NFSA’s objective of adequate and equitable food security for vulnerable households.

  • [8th August 2026] The Hindu OpED: The changing logic of the India-US partnership

    PYQ Relevance
    [UPSC 2019]     ‘What introduces friction into the ties between India and the United States is that Washington is still unable to find for India a position in its global strategy, which would satisfy India’s National self-esteem and ambitions’ Explain with suitable examples.
    Linkage: The PYQ examines the structural frictions in India-US ties arising from differences in strategic priorities and expectations. The article shows how the relationship is shifting from strategic convergence to reciprocal, transactional cooperation, reinforcing the PYQ’s concern over divergent expectations.

    Mentor’s Comment

    An analysis argues the India-US partnership now runs on ‘flexible realism’ rather than shared containment of China. The first decade of the India-U.S. partnership was propelled by shared concern over China’s rise, not by identical values. As Washington moves toward interest-based alliance building, India’s strategic relevance will depend less on China’s trajectory and more on India’s own economic, technological, and military weight. This is a test of how convincingly India can operationalise strategic autonomy through multi-alignment.

    What is the shift in the partnership’s logic?

    1. From convergence to reciprocity: The relationship is moving from a China driven strategic alignment to a value for value calculus.
    2. Tariff signal: Trump tariffs on Indian goods illustrate that shared interests no longer guarantee concessions.

    Why does the tariff dispute signal a deeper shift in American foreign policy, not merely a trade rift?

    1. Not an isolated trade dispute: The tariffs accompany demands for greater burden-sharing, tighter technology restrictions, and a more reciprocal approach to partnerships, indicating a policy pattern rather than a standalone measure.
    2. Flexible realism defined: This approach places national interest at the centre of foreign policy and treats trade, technology, industrial policy, and security as integrated instruments of statecraft.
    3. Departure from the post-Cold War order: Partnerships are judged by the tangible strategic and economic value they deliver, not by shared values or historical goodwill.
    4. Not a retreat from engagement: The approach recalibrates how the U.S. pursues its interests rather than signalling disengagement from global affairs.

    What strategic logic sustained the India-U.S. partnership over the past decade, and why can this convergence no longer be assumed?

    1. China as the organising driver: India’s growing strategic importance to the U.S. followed directly from China’s emergence as Washington’s principal strategic competitor.
    2. Convergence visible across domains: Defence cooperation, the Quad, technology partnerships, and supply-chain resilience all expanded on the back of this shared concern.
    3. Values were a backdrop, not the driver: Democratic values provided a favourable political context, but strategic convergence on China was the actual engine of cooperation.
    4. Assumption no longer holds: India can no longer assume that intensifying U.S.-China competition will automatically enhance its own strategic relevance.
    5. New basis of assessment: Washington will increasingly judge partners, including India, by reciprocal economic benefit, technological capability, and strategic contribution.

    How is the basis of the India-U.S. partnership shifting from convergence to complementarity?

    1. First phase defined: The initial phase of the relationship rested on strategic convergence driven by China’s rise.
    2. Second phase defined: The next phase depends on strategic complementarity, with each side contributing capabilities that reinforce the other.
    3. Substantive domains: Defence cooperation, critical technologies, resilient supply chains, and advanced manufacturing will matter for their own economic and strategic value, not only as tools to manage China.
    4. Net strategic effect: This evolution could make the partnership more balanced and resilient rather than weaker.
    5. Reframing India’s relevance: A more capable India becomes a more valuable partner for the U.S. and is also better placed to pursue its own strategic interests independently.

    Why is the shift happening now?

    1. Domestic priorities: Washington is prioritising reciprocal trade gains over grand strategy.
    2. Multipolar drift: A more contested global order weakens automatic alignment.

    What is India’s central challenge in this new phase of the relationship?

    1. Relevance must be self-generated: India’s strategic relevance must increasingly flow from its own economic dynamism, technological capability, defence preparedness, and diplomatic influence.
    2. From remaining relevant to becoming indispensable: The task is not just to stay useful in Washington’s calculus but to build the capabilities that make India an indispensable partner.
    3. Convergence still matters, but is insufficient alone: Shared concern over China will remain important but can no longer be the sole basis for sustaining momentum.
    4. Dual payoff: Building these capabilities would strengthen the India-U.S. partnership and reinforce India’s own strategic autonomy at the same time.

    How should India respond?

    1. Strategic autonomy: Preserve independent decision making rather than lock into one camp.
    2. Multi alignment: Deepen ties across the European Union, Japan, and the Global South.
    3. Strategic complementarity: Offer the US areas where Indian and American interests genuinely reinforce each other.

    Conclusion

    The tariffs mark a transition in American statecraft from strategic convergence to reciprocity-based partnership, and the India-U.S. relationship must transition correspondingly from a China-driven first phase to a capability-driven second phase. Strategic convergence around China will persist but can no longer be assumed sufficient on its own. India’s task is to build the economic, technological, and defence capabilities that make it an indispensable partner in its own right, using strategic autonomy and multi-alignment to convert this recalibration into greater agency rather than vulnerability.

  • RBI holds the repo rate for a fourth straight review

    Why in the News

    The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) kept its repo rate unchanged at 5.25% for a fourth consecutive Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) meeting. The decision exposes the tension between reviving growth through cheaper credit and defending price stability while inflation sits above target.

    What is the Monetary Policy Committee (MPC)?

    1. Statutory body: The MPC is the six member committee that sets the benchmark repo rate to keep retail inflation within a legislated band.
    2. Mandate: It is tasked with holding Consumer Price Index (CPI) inflation at 4%, within a tolerance range of 2% to 6%.

    Why has the RBI chosen to hold rather than cut?

    1. Inflation above target: Retail inflation has stayed above the 4% midpoint, removing headroom for a rate cut.
    2. Geopolitical spillover: The bank flagged the West Asia conflict and crude price risk as reasons to preserve policy space.
    3. External buffer: Protecting foreign exchange reserves and the rupee against capital outflows outranked a growth focused easing.

    What are the risks in a prolonged hold?

    1. Growth drag: A sustained high rate raises borrowing costs for firms and households and can slow investment.
    2. Transmission gap: Banks may not pass rate signals through fully, weakening the policy’s real economy effect.
    3. Fiscal friction: Elevated rates raise the government’s own interest burden on fresh borrowing.

    Conclusion

    The RBI is prioritising price and currency stability over a growth stimulus while inflation remains above target. The next MPC review will turn on whether inflation cools back toward 4% and whether the external environment stabilises.

    Back2Basics: Repo Rate

    1. Definition: The rate at which the RBI lends short term funds to commercial banks against securities.
    2. Function: It is the primary tool of monetary policy transmission; a higher repo rate raises the cost of money and cools demand.

    Matching Previous Year Question

    “[2017] Which of the following statements is/are correct regarding the Monetary Policy Committee (MPC)?
    1. It decides the RBI’s benchmark interest rates.
    2. It is a 12-member body including the Governor of RBI and is reconstituted every year.
    3. It functions under the chairmanship of the Union Finance Minister.
    Select the correct answer using the code given below:
    (a) 1 only
    (b) 1 and 2 only
    (c) 3 only
    (d) 2 and 3 only
    Answer: (a)”

  • Ethanol policy must count in water, sustainability costs

    Why in the News

    India has achieved nearly 20% ethanol blending (E20) in petrol by 2025, making it one of the world’s largest biofuel programmes. As the blending target is achieved, attention is shifting from quantity to the programme’s water use, life cycle emissions and energy efficiency.

    What is the E20 Ethanol Blending Programme?

    1. Definition: E20 is petrol blended with 20% ethanol.
    2. Progress: Ethanol blending increased from about 1.5% in 2013-14 to nearly 20% in 2025, with annual consumption of around 700 crore litres.
    3. Benefits: Reduces crude oil imports, boosts farmers’ income and strengthens energy security. Ethanol is often described as a low-carbon fuel because sugarcane absorbs atmospheric carbon dioxide during growth.

    What is Energy Return on Energy Invested (EROEI)?

    1. Definition: EROEI measures the usable energy obtained from a fuel relative to the energy spent producing it.
    2. Sugarcane Ethanol: EROEI of about 2 to 4 due to efficient bagasse based distilleries.
    3. Grain Ethanol: EROEI ranges from 1.2 to 2 because of higher fossil fuel inputs.
    4. Significance: Higher EROEI indicates a more energy efficient fuel.

    Why is water the biggest concern?

    1. High Water Demand: Estimates by the Commission for Agricultural Costs and Prices and NITI Aayog suggest that sugarcane requires 1,500 to 2,500 mm of water during cultivation.
    2. Large Water Footprint: Producing one litre of sugarcane ethanol may consume 2,000 to 3,500 litres of water.
    3. Groundwater Stress: Major sugarcane growing states already face groundwater depletion.
    4. Resource Trade-off: Excessive ethanol production may replace oil dependence with freshwater dependence.
    5. Distorting Subsidies: Subsidised electricity and fertilisers encourage over extraction of groundwater and excessive fertiliser use. Subsidised urea promotes overuse of nitrogen fertilisers.

    What are the other challenges?

    1. Lower Energy Density: Ethanol contains about 21 MJ/litre, compared to 32 MJ/litre for petrol, reducing fuel efficiency by about 6 to 7% under E20 blends. However, ethanol has a much higher octane rating, allowing engines specifically calibrated for higher ethanol blends to achieve more efficient combustion and partially offset this disadvantage. The overall outcome depends on engine design rather than fuel properties alone.
    2. Life Cycle Emissions: Sugarcane ethanol can reduce emissions by 50 to 70%, while grain ethanol offers 20 to 50% reduction, depending on production methods.
    3. Vehicle Compatibility: E20 can corrode certain engine components in older vehicles. Vehicles manufactured from April 2023 onwards are required to be E20 compatible.

    Conclusion

    India’s ethanol programme represents an important step towards greater energy security, but its long-term success will depend on aligning environmental objectives with sound economics. A resilient biofuel strategy must be guided by transparent life-cycle carbon accounting, rigorous assessment of water use, technology-neutral incentives and market signals that reflect the true value of natural resources.

    PYQ Relevance

    [2020] According to India’s National Policy on Biofuels, which of the following can be used as raw materials for the production of biofuels?
    1. Cassava

    2. Damaged wheat grains

    3. Groundnut seeds

    4. Horse gram

    5. Rotten potatoes

    6. Sugar beet
    Select the correct answer using the code given below:
    (a) 1, 2, 5 and 6 only (b) 1, 3, 4 and 6 only (c) 2, 3, 4 and 5 only (d) 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6

  • [7th August 2026] The Hindu OpED: Stop the scam: Digital arrest menace

    Why in the News

    The Supreme Court passed an order on 4 August 2026 on the digital arrest scam. It directed banks, states and regulators toward faster action on mule accounts and cyber fraud. The scams persist because they are run largely from overseas hubs.

    What is the digital arrest scam?

    1. Definition: Fraudsters impersonate authorities and coerce victims into transferring money under threat of fake arrest. There is no legal basis or process called digital arrest.
    2. Targets: Older victims fall prey through deference to authority and fear of legal trouble.
    3. New targets: Scammers now also target youth and professionals, and senior citizens whom advisories have not reached.

    Why are digital arrests keep happening?

    1. Human Psychology & Social Engineering: Cybercriminals use social engineering tactics to manipulate people into revealing sensitive information. Fraudsters also exploit emotions like fear (threatening legal action), excitement (fake lottery wins), or urgency (fake emergency fund requests). Cybercriminals often impersonate trusted sources such as banks, government agencies, or even close friends.
    2. Weak Cybersecurity Practices: Common weaknesses include weak password and credentials use, unpatched software and system and poor security hygiene.
    3. Rapidly Evolving Cybercrime Techniques: Cybercriminals constantly evolve their methods to stay ahead of security measures.
    4. Digital Payments & Financial Fraud Risks: With the rise of digital transactions, cybercriminals have developed sophisticated methods to exploit online payment systems like fake UPI requests & QR codes, card skimming & SIM swaps and crypto & investment scams.
    5. Dark Web & Cybercrime Networks: The dark web serves as a marketplace for stolen data, malware tools, and illegal activities. Cybercrime has become an organized industry where criminals buy and sell stolen data and identity theft, organised cyber-crime syndicates and also offer Ransomware-as-a-Service (RaaS) as well.
    6. Lack of Strong Cyber Laws & Enforcement: Despite increasing cyber threats, many scams go unpunished due to slow law enforcements response, cross border crime challenges and lack of cyber crime awareness and policies.

    What did the Supreme Court order?

    1. Debit holds: It directed the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) to circulate a standard operating procedure for temporary debit holds on mule accounts.
    2. State action: States must notify cybercrime coordination centres and operationalise electronic Zero FIRs.
    3. Compensation: An inter departmental committee must examine a victim compensation framework.
    4. Data cited: Complaints on the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal fell from 1,23,672 in 2024 to 16,377 in the first half of 2026.
    5. Recovery: Money was restored in 36,290 cases involving Rs 18.05 crore.

    What are the key terms in the response?

    1. Indian Cybercrime Coordination Centre (I4C): the nodal body coordinating action against cyber fraud and running the reporting portal.
    2. Mule account: a bank account used to receive and move fraud proceeds across states.
    3. Zero FIR: a First Information Report that can be filed at any police station regardless of jurisdiction.
    4. MuleHunter.AI: a detection system used in over 20 banks to flag mule accounts.

    Why do these scams persist despite falling complaints?

    1. Nimble methods: Fraudsters route calls through SIM boxes to mask origin and appear as Indian numbers.
    2. Deepfakes: They deploy deepfakes on video calls to dupe victims and stay untraceable.
    3. Few convictions: Convictions are rare as many schemes are run from overseas scam compounds.
    4. Overseas hubs: Compounds operate in Myanmar, the wider Golden Triangle and Cambodia, some with official patronage.
    5. Trafficking link: Indians are trafficked and coerced to run digital crimes against fellow citizens.

    Conclusion

    Detection systems and swift account freezes limit the damage even when perpetrators escape conviction. The core problem lies in overseas scam compounds beyond domestic law enforcement reach. New Delhi must use diplomatic pressure with China, the United States and ASEAN to compel host countries to act.

    Back2Basics

    Electronic-Zero FIR (e-zero FIR)

    An e-Zero FIR is an automated digital system in India that converts high-value cyber financial fraud complaints (above ₹10 lakh) filed via the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal or the 1930 helpline directly into a Zero FIR. It eliminates jurisdictional delays during the critical “golden hour” for fund recovery

    Key Features and Workflow

    1. Automatic Registration: Eligible financial fraud reports trigger an instant e-Zero FIR without requiring an initial physical station visit.
    2. System Integration: Combines the I4C portal, state e-FIR mechanisms, and the NCRB’s Crime and Criminal Tracking Network & Systems (CCTNS).
    3. Auto-Routing: The system instantly routes the electronic document to the correct territorial cybercrime station based on the victim’s location.
    4. Mandatory Follow-Up: Complainants must visit the designated local police station within three days to sign and convert the e-Zero FIR into a regular FIR under the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS).

    PYQ Relevance

    [UPSC 2022] What are the different elements of cyber security? Keeping in view the challenges in cyber security, examine the extent to which India has successfully developed a comprehensive National Cyber Security Strategy.

    Linkage: The PYQ tests India’s cyber security framework and response to cybercrime. The article highlights recent measures to strengthen India’s response to digital arrest scams and cyber fraud.

  • India-Bangladesh ties should be Hasina-proof

    Why in the News

    The former Bangladesh Prime Minister held her first question taking media interaction from exile in India. She announced a political comeback and said she would return in December. The event risks turning India’s grant of refuge into a diplomatic irritant with Dhaka’s elected government.

    What is the diplomatic dilemma India faces?

    1. Refuge granted: India gave the former Prime Minister refuge after she fled Bangladesh on 5 August 2024 amid protests.
    2. Legitimacy concern: the grant was defended given the unfairness of the legal proceedings against her, including a death sentence by the International Crimes Tribunal.
    3. Platform risk: using the refuge as a political platform complicates ties with the elected government.
    4. Elected counterpart: the Bangladesh Nationalist Party (BNP) led administration under the new Prime Minister took office about six months earlier.

    Why is the timing fraught?

    1. Reset underway: New Delhi is rebuilding ties after strained relations with the earlier Muhammad Yunus led interim government.
    2. Domestic backlash: a mob hurled petrol bombs at a party member’s residence after he joined the exiled leader online.
    3. Media bar: the statements were barred from broadcast in Bangladesh under laws the former government itself once used.
    4. Awami League banned: the leader’s party is barred from contesting, so the comeback call targets the incumbent government.

    What unresolved issues shadow the relationship?

    1. Ganga treaty: the 1996 Ganga Water Treaty is due for renewal this year.
    2. Teesta treaty: the Teesta water sharing treaty is still to be signed.
    3. Migration: New Delhi views illegal immigration from Bangladesh as a major irritant.
    4. Trade curbs: some trade restrictions remain even after Bangladesh removed visa curbs.
    5. China factor: India is wary of Dhaka drifting into China’s orbit, and the new Prime Minister has visited China but not India.

    Why must ties be insulated from any single individual?

    1. Shared border: a 4,000 kilometre border makes cooperation indispensable against trafficking and cross border extremism.
    2. Economic stakes: Indian investment and infrastructure financing support Bangladesh’s growth, with stakes in power and connectivity.
    3. Strategic caution: both governments need to insulate bilateral ties from short term compulsions.

    Conclusion

    India was right to shelter the former Prime Minister, but her political aspirations cannot bruise ties with the elected government. The bilateral relationship, anchored in geography and security, is too important to be held hostage by one individual. New Delhi’s task is to keep the reset with Dhaka insulated from her comeback bid.

    Back2Basics

    The 1996 Ganga Water Treaty is a 30-year bilateral agreement between India and Bangladesh signed on December 12, 1996. It governs the sharing of dry-season (January 1 to May 31) water flows from the Ganges River at the Farakka Barrage.

    Key Provisions and Formula

    1. Lean Season Focus: Applies specifically to lean-season flows from January 1 through May 31.
    2. 50:50 Sharing Rule: If the water flow at Farakka is 70,000 cusecs or less, India and Bangladesh each receive 50% of the water.
    3. Fixed Allocation Windows:
      • Flows of 70,000-75,000 cusecs: Bangladesh receives a fixed 35,000 cusecs, and India receives the rest.
      • Flows above 75,000 cusecs: India receives 75,000 cusecs, and Bangladesh receives the balance.
    4. Emergency Clause: If water flow drops below 50,000 cusecs in any 10-day period, both nations must hold immediate consultations for emergency adjustments.

    Administration and Oversight

    1. Joint Committee: An equal-representation monitoring committee measures daily flows at the Farakka feeder canal and Bangladesh’s Hardinge Bridge.
    2. Review Schedule: Subject to five-year reviews or earlier adjustments if requested.

    PYQ Relevance

    [UPSC 2013] Critically examine the compulsions which prompted India to play a decisive role in the emergence of Bangladesh.

    Linkage: It examines the strategic and political foundations of India–Bangladesh relations. The article highlights how India must balance humanitarian refuge with long-term bilateral and strategic interests.

  • [6th August 2026] The Hindu OpED: A climate resilience pathway between India and China

    PYQ Relevance
    [UPSC 2024]     The West is fostering India as an alternative to reduce dependence on China’s supply chain and as a strategic ally to counter China’s political and economic dominance.’ Explain this statement with examples.
    Linkage: The PYQ examines India-China strategic competition and the scope for selective cooperation amid geopolitical rivalry. The article shows how climate resilience and disaster management can provide a limited, low-risk avenue for India–China engagement despite strategic distrust.

    Mentor’s Comment

    El Niño delayed India’s monsoon, followed by intense rainfall that caused severe flooding in Mumbai, Surat, Assam, and Odisha. Similar extreme weather also affected Guangxi, Shaanxi, and Gansu in China, highlighting the increasing frequency of climate-related disasters. Shared exposure to extreme climate events is proposed as a low risk avenue for India China cooperation. The tension is between deep strategic rivalry and a narrow band of mutual interest in disaster resilience.

    How do India and China face similar climate challenges?

    1. Urbanisation: Wetlands, forests and permeable land are replaced by concrete, reducing natural water absorption.
    2. Drainage Deficit: Outdated drainage systems and poor waste management aggravate urban flooding.
    3. Loss of Green Spaces: Shrinking green cover increases runoff and weakens climate resilience.
    4. Coastal Risks: Coastal megacities face extreme rainfall, storm surges and sea-level rise.
    5. Inland Extremes: Inland cities experience recurring heatwaves, droughts and flash floods.
    6. Economic Costs: Climate disasters disrupt supply chains, reduce productivity and cause economic losses.
    7. Health Impacts: Frequent floods and heat events increase disease burden and public health risks.

    Past Engagement: How have India and China cooperated on climate resilience?

    1. Climate Frameworks: Since the early 1990s, summit-level joint statements, MoUs and agreements have promoted practical climate cooperation.
    2. Disaster & Data Cooperation: Collaboration covered floods, earthquakes, droughts, extreme weather, along with hydrological, oceanic and seismic data sharing, joint R&D and governance exchange.
    3. Strategic Economic Dialogues: Six dialogues focused on sustainable urban planning, waste management, sewage treatment, water efficiency and capacity building.
    4. Sister City Agreements: Delhi-Beijing, Mumbai-Shanghai and Chennai-Chongqing were created to implement joint urban resilience projects, but diplomatic tensions limited execution.
    5. Mutual Learning: China offers data-driven planning (transport, housing, drainage), while India contributes early warning systems, Heat Action Plans, cool roofs, nature-based solutions and community-led adaptation.
    6. Future Cooperation: Scope exists for sponge cities, resilient agriculture, hydrological modelling, Himalayan glacier monitoring and revival of shared water agreements (which ceased in 2022).

    What is the proposed cooperation pathway?

    In April 2026, the visit by a Chinese delegation led by China’s Special Envoy for Climate Change to New Delhi suggests that climate cooperation remains a priority.

    1. Shared exposure: Both countries face recurring monsoon floods and urban flooding disasters.
    2. Low risk domain: Disaster mitigation and urban resilience avoid the sensitivities of border and trade disputes.
    3. Existing channels: An April 2026 visit by a Chinese Special Envoy and past sister city agreements offer a base.

    What models could underpin it?

    1. Sponge cities: China’s urban water absorption model is cited as a resilience approach.
    2. Glacier concerns: Shared Himalayan glacier risks link both countries’ water security.
    3. City linkages: Past agreements between major cities offer a template for exchange.

    Why is the pathway limited?

    1. Strategic distrust: Border tensions constrain deeper engagement.
    2. Asymmetry: Cooperation must manage a large power imbalance.
    3. Narrow scope: Resilience cooperation cannot resolve the core rivalry.

    How can India and China bridge the climate finance gap?

    1. Public Funding Dependence: Climate adaptation is financed mainly through public funds in both countries.
    2. Private Capital: Expand blended finance, municipal bonds and credit enhancement to mobilise private investment.
    3. Ecosystem Gaps: Climate finance markets remain nascent, constrained by weak local capacity and regulatory gaps.
    4. Knowledge Exchange: Share evidence-based practices on innovative climate finance models.
    5. Global South Leadership: Develop common standards, metrics and fiscal frameworks for climate resilience financing.
    6. Win-Win Cooperation: Climate finance collaboration offers a low-risk pathway to strengthen India–China engagement and resilience.

    Conclusion

    Climate resilience offers a contained space for engagement without touching the strategic core. The unresolved question is whether either side will invest political capital in so narrow a domain.

  • GST must be fuelled by domestic production, not inflation or imports

    Why in the News

    Record monthly Goods and Services Tax collection was driven more by imports and price rise than by domestic output. The tension is between a headline revenue high and a weak production base underneath it.

    What is the Goods and Services Tax (GST)?

    1. Indirect tax: The Goods and Services Tax (GST) is a destination based tax on the supply of goods and services, in force since July 2017.
    2. Dual structure: It has a Central component and a State component, with an Integrated GST (IGST) on inter state and import transactions.
    3. Council: Rates are set by the GST Council, a federal body of the Union and States.

    What does the latest collection actually show?

    1. Headline figure: July GST touched Rs 2.11 lakh crore, up 15.4% year on year.
    2. Import driven: Integrated GST (IGST) on imports grew 26.9%, against just 4.5% for the domestic component.
    3. Price effect: Rupee depreciation and high Wholesale Price Index manufacturing inflation of 7.18% inflated the nominal figure.

    Why is the revenue base narrow?

    1. Geographic concentration: Collection is heavily skewed toward a handful of industrialized or consumption-heavy regions. Only 16 States and Union Territories were above the national average collection.
    2. Weak domestic demand: Sluggish home production limits the tax base.
    3. Inflation illusion: A rising nominal collection can mask flat real activity. Rising nominal collection numbers can be deceptive, as high wholesale price inflation and currency depreciation artificially inflate transaction values.

    Conclusion

    Strong collection numbers are being read as growth when they partly reflect imports and inflation. A broad based GST 3.0 must widen the domestic production base rather than lean on price rise.

    Back2Basic

    GST 2.0

    Launched in 2025, GST 2.0 is a major overhaul of India’s indirect taxation system. It simplifies the multi-tier structure into core merit (5%) and standard (18%) slabs, eliminates the old 12% and 28% categories for most items, and introduces a 40% demerit rate for luxury and sin goods.

    Key Tax Slab Changes

    1. Nil / 0%: Life and health insurance, basic food staples (UHT milk, paneer, Indian breads), and 33 life-saving medicines.
    2. 5% (Merit Rate): Common household essentials, agricultural machinery (tractors, harvesters), gym/fitness services, and handicrafts.
    3. 18% (Standard Rate): Consumer durables (TVs, ACs), small cars, two-wheelers, and cement.
    4. 40% (Demerit Rate): Luxury cars, aerated drinks, pan masala, and tobacco products

    PYQ Relevance

    [UPSC 2019] Enumerate the indirect taxes which have been subsumed in the goods and services tax (GST) in India. Also, comment on the revenue implications of the GST introduced in India since July 2017.

    Linkage: The PYQ examines the revenue implications of GST and its impact on India’s indirect tax system. The article evaluates GST revenue quality, showing that recent collections are driven more by imports and inflation than broad-based domestic economic growth.